Yes it sounds crazy but i think the principal was concerned that the kids were going to get the S beat out of them. If there are a majority of Spanish kids in the school and the white boys stood up to them it would not be pretty.

They were probably looking for trouble, looking to start a fight like a lot of people on this forum are. Some people will do anything to start a fight.

Again i don't know if i agree with how it was handled but i think the principal was looking out for the kids.

I think that the parents should be going in and raking the principle and all involved over the coals. This is the United States of America, not Mexico, and the reality is that we are not obligated to celebrate any holiday that is not approved by congress.
Quick think on Cinco de Mayo, is that it was one battle that the mexican army won against the french. The next day the french came back and really wooped up on the Mexicans. It was not a popular holiday until it was introduced to the Americans, as an excuse to party.
So the school is wrong as they are not seeing to the needs of only part of the students, and not all of them. I think a lawyer to sue on the grounds of discrimination is needed in this case.

This makes me so angry.

I agree with Beast Master in that trying to keep the peace was probably the principle's intention. However, this needs to be brought to light as well then.

If we actually have to be fearful of violence because we wear a shirt that has an American flag on it, then that is indicative of a MUCH larger issue instead of a simple 'PC gone awry' issue of wearing a flag on a day that is 'insensitive' to Mexican Americans.

Pandering to the over sensitivities of others is simply aggravating. Doing it to avoid possible violence is infuriating.

Originally posted by BeastMaster2012
Yes it sounds crazy but i think the principal was concerned that the kids were going to get the S beat out of them. If there are a majority of Spanish kids in the school and the white boys stood up to them it would not be pretty.

So, once again AMERICANS need to be the one to sneak away with their tail between their legs while THEIR rights are violated in their OWN country? No!

They were probably looking for trouble, looking to start a fight like a lot of people on this forum are. Some people will do anything to start a fight.

Your own apologetic opinion. It doesn't say anything like that in the article

Again i don't know if i agree with how it was handled but i think the principal was looking out for the kids.

Right, or the gutless principal could have told all the mexicans, "Hands off!".

Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't all immigrants, upon naturalisation have to swear allegiance to the flag in the US?

I beggers belief that if they have sworn allegiance to something that they could find it offensive.

PC BS gone mad!

"Listen all you dirty MEXICANS, this is AMERICA, you got that? See these good white boys with their AMERICAN shirts? IF you touch these kids i will see to it that you are not only expelled but sent to JAIL for hate crimes against AMERICA."

-Live Oak Principal's Speach to the Mexicans.

sorry had to do it.

The other question that needs to be asked and watched for when the time comes:

Will the principal send home any mexicans wearing their flag on or around the 4th of July?

Originally posted by BeastMaster2012
"Listen all you dirty MEXICANS, this is AMERICA, you got that? See these good white boys with their AMERICAN shirts? IF you touch these kids i will see to it that you are not only expelled but sent to JAIL for hate crimes against AMERICA."

-Live Oak Principal's Speach to the Mexicans.

sorry had to do it.

No you didn't.

All the principal had to really do was explain to the mexicans that in THIS country it is a student's right to wear any flag on any day. Call it a lesson in civics.

That was stupid. Now we have more martyrs. The American flag is everywhere in America. Whatis the problems??

Originally posted by nik1halo
Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't all immigrants, upon naturalisation have to swear allegiance to the flag in the US?

I beggers belief that if they have sworn allegiance to something that they could find it offensive.

PC BS gone mad!

Who said all these students were legal and have gone through the naturalization process?

They seem, after all, seem to feel like they are "mexicans" first ...

Oh and from the article:

But to many Mexican-American students at Live Oak, this was a big deal. They say they were offended by the five boys and others for wearing American colors on a Mexican holiday.

Get over yourselves!

This is how you know how wrong this is. Reverse the countries and what would happen to Americans students in mexico that claimed to be offended by mexicans there wearing the mexican flag (in mexico) on the 4th of July.


[edit on 5/6/2010 by centurion1211]

Originally posted by AshleyD
This makes me so angry.

I agree with Beast Master in that trying to keep the peace was probably the principle's intention. However, this needs to be brought to light as well then.

If we actually have to be fearful of violence because we wear a shirt that has an American flag on it, then that is indicative of a MUCH larger issue instead of a simple 'PC gone awry' issue of wearing a flag on a day that is 'insensitive' to Mexican Americans.

Pandering to the over sensitivities of others is simply aggravating. Doing it to avoid possible violence is infuriating.

Hunny it isn't just about keeping the peace. I live in Northern California where we have a rather large Hispanic population. To be TOTALLY blunt they get what ever they want to simply keep the money for special programs rolling in!
All of the grammar school programs for ALL the children in the area where I live have been eradicated to make way for the state funded ones for the Hispanic children.
My children who are half Portuguese and half American were refused entry into any of the after school programs for not being "Hispanic". I can understand it is in their best interest to try and help them learn English etc. But they DON'T EVER even try; they just cart them around on field trips etc.

It has gotten to the point where they are demanding that the American children learn to speak Spanish because there are more Spanish speaking children than English speaking children. When we got hit with that one in "kindergarten"we pulled our kids out of the district here and have been having them privately schooled ever since.
Spanish or French is a language requirement for graduation from high school here. Not something that 5-9 year old's need because the school wants money for special programs that are only for a select few.

All of these politically correct "rules" have gotten out of hand. It has gotten to the point here where being a "citizen" is a bad thing and something our children feel they are being punished for.
EVERYONE has a right to celebrate their heritage; trying to stop those who do in any way is wrong. But like most things around here it will be buried in a day or two until the next time it happens (daily). I really think they are only reporting on it just because of the Arizona bill to be honest. It happens every single day here.

I'd say sue them. they're not in Mexico, they're in America. Americans don't celebrate the fifth of may because it's not Important to us, and it's of limited significance and celebration nationwide in MEXICO itself. if they bearly celebrated in Mexico, WHY celebrate here?