It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
ou can't draw simplistic comparisons on race or ethnic makeup. In fact, the FBI warns against drawing conclusions for the following reasons: “Crime in the United States provides a nationwide view of crime based on statistics contributed by local, state, tribal, and federal law enforcement agencies. Population size and student enrollment are the only correlates of crime presented in this publication. Although many of the listed factors equally affect the crime of a particular area, the UCR Program makes no attempt to relate them to the data presented. The data user is, therefore, cautioned against comparing statistical data of individual reporting units from cities, counties, metropolitan areas, states, or colleges or universities solely on the basis of their population coverage or student enrollment. Until data users examine all the variables that affect crime in a town, city, county, state, region, or other jurisdiction, they can make no meaningful comparisons.”
This is racial coding. This is trying to get you to believe that white individuals commit crimes at a far lower rate than any other group. This just isn’t true; it is only her perception. African Americans are imprisoned at a rate disproportionate to their makeup in society. There is clear and documented racial bias and discrimination in sentencing. Coulter's statements feed into the notion that black equals criminal. For those that say racism isn't the problem here, Americans still express explicit and implicit racial attitudes towards minorities and these views contribute to how we think about and view crime in America.
Originally posted by CJCrawley
It can't just be down to poverty, surely?
Otherwise, any poor area - regardless of ethnic makeup - would have the same stats.
What about poor white areas?
Poor Asian areas?
Poor Mexican areas?
Poor Arabic areas?
Do Asians, Mexicans, and Arabs suffer less than blacks from poverty and discrimination?
Originally posted by Infi8nity
Originally posted by Superhans
Originally posted by iSHRED
While it may be true that minorities are involved in more cases of gun violence, it's still a very small percentage of total minorities.
Look up the prison population by race, that is all im going to say about that one.
While I do agree with the comments made...
Understand that the prison system is all about making money. The more people locked up the more money the owners of the prions make. Its not a fluke, the system was designed this way. It would seem that America and EU has "problems" with minority's. But whats causing those problems? Who's manipulating them?
Whites and Mexicans aren't very different. I have lived in many trailer parks, cheap crappy apartments, and even project housing in my childhood and I can tell you without a doubt that there isn't much of a difference on the skin color, 90% of the people there are "criminals." If you think poor whites aren't just as guilty then you my friend have never met very many truly poor white people. I am one, poor white that is, one of the few who wouldn't screw another person over for a buck, trust me, I should know better than most.
But obviously they aren't the only ethnic group to suffer poverty and discrimination, yet their gun homicide rate is disproportionately higher than any of the others. Why?
The elephant in the room is the dissolving family unit. Have you checked the black marriage rates lately? My experience with younger blacks who live in poverty is that a large percentage have no plans to ever marry. They are still having children, though, and the majority of these children don't have a live at home dad to help raise them, and they don't have the resources to do it without help. That is a problem, and a big one. I think that the point about admitting a problem is valid, but the real problem lies in how to go about bringing back the importance of family to the black community. You can restrict guns all you want, but it will have no effect on this problem. I think it is tragic, and I wish there was a good solution. Parts of the culture need to change.
Originally posted by No_man4
Originally posted by Superhans
Originally posted by No_man4
reply to post by Superhans
That's because you already ignored it and edited it out of my post that you quoted, but I'll gladly reiterate for you:
It is my opinion that the argument shared by the OP and Anne Coulter is fallacious. The stresses that cause these incidences are primarily socioeconomic. That more ethnic minorities populate the lower classes (and prisons) says more about the endemic bigotry and nepotism that permeate our "egalitarian" society than the disposition of those minority groups.
Yeah that is called sociological wankery...
I know what you are saying but I can clearly see you are just trying to hide an absence of a decent argument amongst a bunch of big words.
Then I'll rephrase my argument in smaller words you might understand better:
I think the OP and Anne Coulter are wrong.
These killing sprees happen because being really poor for a really long time is really stressful making the number of white people that have to deal with the kind of problems that lead people to commit those crimes in the first place smaller.
Originally posted by sirjunlegun
reply to post by Anundeniabletruth
Whites and Mexicans aren't very different. I have lived in many trailer parks, cheap crappy apartments, and even project housing in my childhood and I can tell you without a doubt that there isn't much of a difference on the skin color, 90% of the people there are "criminals." If you think poor whites aren't just as guilty then you my friend have never met very many truly poor white people. I am one, poor white that is, one of the few who wouldn't screw another person over for a buck, trust me, I should know better than most.
I know what you mean. I watch Trailer Park Boys & I say they are alllll white!
Originally posted by Teabags
Originally posted by No_man4
Originally posted by Superhans
Originally posted by No_man4
reply to post by Superhans
That's because you already ignored it and edited it out of my post that you quoted, but I'll gladly reiterate for you:
It is my opinion that the argument shared by the OP and Anne Coulter is fallacious. The stresses that cause these incidences are primarily socioeconomic. That more ethnic minorities populate the lower classes (and prisons) says more about the endemic bigotry and nepotism that permeate our "egalitarian" society than the disposition of those minority groups.
Yeah that is called sociological wankery...
I know what you are saying but I can clearly see you are just trying to hide an absence of a decent argument amongst a bunch of big words.
Then I'll rephrase my argument in smaller words you might understand better:
I think the OP and Anne Coulter are wrong.
These killing sprees happen because being really poor for a really long time is really stressful making the number of white people that have to deal with the kind of problems that lead people to commit those crimes in the first place smaller.
I took out the racist comments and boiled this down. Being poor is not an excuse for killing people.
The point that I was trying to make is that the problem is a result of our inherently flawed system and the racist majority that operates it and not the color of the skin of the criminals it creates.