Alien interview movie

I love how the alien moves around as he is communicating telepathically.

Here's something that always bothers me about the telepathy explanation for means of communication. No matter how an alien would communicate, it would be in alien language. So, if some alien landed on my doorstep and started beaming thoughts into my head, they would be in a totally foreign language and I'd wind up blowing my brains out to make the noise stop.

How do these aliens come here and beam thoughts in our language? Do they take english (or spanish depending on what part of the US you live it) in school so they can come here and communicate with us? do they do the same with people that speak other languages?

I think it would be pretty damned odd for an alien to land here and start communicating in english. E.T. needed to watch some television for a day or so before he could communicate and even then he was only able to speak like a 3 year old.

I have more faith in mermaids like Madison learning perfect english in a day. Besides, she was hot. If you don't know the movie I'm referring to, you're going to make me feel old by asking.

Originally posted by Ess Why Kay
Just to clear a few things up for the readers who apparently don't know. The voice you hear is that of a man who claims he worked at a Top Secret Military Base, (Dulce I believe) and is not the voice of the alien.

Hi EWK,
I just watched it and if it's the voice of the top clearance agent, why does the "alien" say
to the doctor', 'stop shining that thing in my eyes'? It also appears to move it's head toward
a microphone, if you study the 'body language' during the interview.
Imo, most likley a fake. (I STUFFED THIS UP, SORRY Ignore this para')

Sanc'.

MAJOR EDIT: D'OH!!!
Note to self...don't try and do three things at once, and turn the stereo speakers down,
and the poota speakers up.

[edit on 12-8-2004 by sanctum]

I'm sorry this tape looks a little fake to me. I'm no specialist but this alien looks like a bobble head sitting on the dashboard of a car LOL . If it was real, why is it so dark? Plus how did he get it out? where was it taken? If it was a Goverment tape , it would have been used for a documentary purpose therefor I think They would have shot his whole body and lit the roommore. The darkness tells me it is a hoax. Seems like the maker of this tape has something to hide.

Interesting that people automatically think its a "fake" because of its body language...that is truely funny. How can a human whom has never seen nor made contact with an alien have any idea what "body language" they use. C'mon people, were talking about an alien race as if they are just like us, have the same values as us, same biology, etc. I find this very close minded and disturbing.

I still have seen no one argue definitively that this is a fake video. Its all speculation from what I have seen and not one person arguing against it has come up with one shread of proof for why they believe it to be fake.

I for one want to believe its real, and it may very well be, but to simply say that the creatures "body language", etc. is not real is to dismiss the fact that this creature would be from another world possibly completely different from our own.

Hum but why does the guy sound possesed then???



[edit on 8/12/2004 by SirKillallott]

Why do you think that is the aliens voice. People have just stated that its the voice of an official that took the tape from wherever it was being held. Thats not the aliens voice.....you know....uh, um.....its not the aliens voice.

well, humans say um or ah and this is supposed to be a human talking on behalf of the alien. So, a human is talking but the alien is emoting like it is talking.

If the alien's movements aren't a result of emoting, the alien has some serious parkinson's type disease.

It's very simple. once you hear cheesy background music, you can rule out reality.

The other thread www.abovetopsecret.com...

Despite making an idiot of myself, my last post...

About the darkness/lighting, why not just turn on the lights and give us a decent look!
Even if light will cause a life threatening situation, I don't think e.t. was looking
all that flash anyway, health wise.

I know there's heaps of threads about "blurry...etc" ufo still photo', but the one I ponder
over from time to time, is the 'alien in the city park' with the horses.
I live in a farm area and I know horses "spook" like many other animals.
Maybe, alien' are undetectable to 'animal sense'. Or photoshop...who knows?

Sanc'.

Like a horse would know the difference between a cat, dog, or small-sized alien

So fake. Didn't anybody notice the doctors using FLASHLIGHTS to check the aliens eyes. They used friggin flashlights! Not a penlight mind you, but a big honking flashlight! The alien's eyes look like they have one big pupil and nothing else. The only reason doctors use penlights on humans is to check for pupil contraction to see the responsiveness of the human. I did not see the alien pupil retracting at all when the light was shined straight into its eyes.

Originally posted by magnetism87
So fake. Didn't anybody notice the doctors using FLASHLIGHTS to check the aliens eyes. They used friggin flashlights! Not a penlight mind you, but a big honking flashlight! The alien's eyes look like they have one big pupil and nothing else. The only reason doctors use penlights on humans is to check for pupil contraction to see the responsiveness of the human. I did not see the alien pupil retracting at all when the light was shined straight into its eyes.

Come on, big black eyes need big flashlights

by Crakeur

It's very simple. once you hear cheesy background music, you can rule out reality.

lol! You are funny. The background music, as already stated, was added for the documentary. There was no audio track present on the original film copied from the DNI.

I think it has been proven under voice analysis that the voice of "Victor" is indeed Bob Lazar. That is what adds doubt to the authenticity of this footage and the reason Bob Lazar appears at the beginning of the documentary (not sure if it's in that version posted).

by Crakeur

Here's something that always bothers me about the telepathy explanation for means of communication. No matter how an alien would communicate, it would be in alien language.

If I showed you a picture of a monkey, would you need me to explain what a monkey is? Through telepathy, people can not only convey images and words, but meaning. Something verbal language isn't very good at.

Originally posted by electric

If I showed you a picture of a monkey, would you need me to explain what a monkey is?

what's a monkey?


Electric, if an alien version of a toaster is beamed telepathically to a human, how will the human know what the hell the image is. Unless the alien toaster is the same as our toaster, which I highly doubt since they might not have toast, which would be a shame because toast is pretty good, especially with butter and jelly on it.

I do believe that there are other creatures out there but I just don't believe in the many videos of them that pop up from time to time. I do believe that communicating with them would be rather difficult, way too difficult to conduct an interview with a cheesy musak background.

Perhaps my belief in telepathic conversations with aliens is hindered by the tinfoil helmet I'm wearing to keep me safe from their harmful thoughts.

I hate to say that, but even though I usually don't even bother to check things like this out, because I'm very sceptical... This somehow looks right. I just don't know. The background music was overlaid for the TV production and has nothing to do with the original material.

The original movie don't have that music and that twisted voice on it.

I am sorry but it is fake. Think about it logicly, if it were real-the moment it went on the net that site would be pulled/hacked and the info removed. Probably hacked-that way they don't have to explain why they shut it down.

Not necessarily. Once something like this gets on the net, it SPREADS like wildfire. The government would be hacking for years just to get all of em, and even then there's things like Kazaa.

It also would only lend to the credibility of the video if it was taken off the net.... Imagine the uproar THAT would have caused! "Multiple sites hacked and secret alien interview deleted by feds!"

that was sooooo bad........you can see the light reflecting in the aliens eyes....i'm no expert on alien biology, but it seems like a mask to me. the motions are very much like a 12 year old wearing a mask......

Originally posted by mrmonsoon
I am sorry but it is fake. Think about it logicly, if it were real-the moment it went on the net that site would be pulled/hacked and the info removed. Probably hacked-that way they don't have to explain why they shut it down.

Why would they pull it off the internet. Afterall, if it is real they know that people on forums just like this are going to say what you just did, and thus try to disprove the very thing they have been looking for all their lives. I'm sure many would think its a hoax, and the others would be told how dumb they are for thinking it could be real.

Why would the govt. try to stop it when the people will do the job for them. Its something to think about anyhow