It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Wolf321
reply to post by kiwifoot
I disagree. At least partly. I think they do on a regular basis help us, perhaps taking out a unseen asteroid, or screwing with the CERN facilty, knocking out the power of an ICBM. But that doesn't progress humanity past its problems of being on the wrong path.
If there were some major, global planet destroying event, I think they would save as many as they could, making themselves known. But that is about it.
Originally posted by kiwifoot
The only way for Earth to discover the 'right' path, is to go down the wrong path and learn from its mistakes.
We aren't, as a rule, that enlightened. We'll only ever go in the right direction after dozens, hundreds, thousands?? of mistakes.
I think they lean over our shoulder, make sure we don't destroy ourselves and the universe entirely, but let us find our own way.
[edit on 22-2-2010 by kiwifoot]
Originally posted by Wolf321
Originally posted by kiwifoot
The only way for Earth to discover the 'right' path, is to go down the wrong path and learn from its mistakes.
We aren't, as a rule, that enlightened. We'll only ever go in the right direction after dozens, hundreds, thousands?? of mistakes.
I think they lean over our shoulder, make sure we don't destroy ourselves and the universe entirely, but let us find our own way.
[edit on 22-2-2010 by kiwifoot]
I think that may be a plausible line of thinking by any benevolent ETs. However, I go back to my universal family-big brother analogy, it is better to offer guidance or tell us how something works, and then allow us to either follow, ignore, or improve on that information.
I have considered, that open contact and sharing of information was done in the past, and led to great advancement in human civilization, but the timing of helping a primative species versus a more technologically advanced one leads me to conclude that any such ET would not really be that benevolent and altruistic. Either needing a resource or wanting to be worshiped.