Originally posted by David2012
well then they are very closeby, the signal cant have travelled further then 36 lightyears.
if they don't have a way around lightspeed and relativity issues then they can't be further then 18 lightyears away and their reply has taken 18
years to get back to us.
According to the reply, if it is the Sol system depicted Earth is one of the planets they inhabit. So all they need is Internet access.
but tbh I think it's a hoax, if actual life out there would respond they would have sent a signal back using the same method we used to get it
to them, because that is the only way they could be certain we were abe to receive their reply.
That's assuming they're not already well aware of us.
this sounds to me like an inside joke tbh.
And as to making cropcircles from lightyears away as a valid communications device is doubtfull, one must look from their perspective.
you just received a transmission from 18 lightyears away containing details of a civilization and decide to reply.
Now what do you know about their communications technology? you know they could send this type of radio transmission. It figures to send the reply
back using the same type of transmission. You're certain they can receive it.
The problem is we didn't send the message to a system 18 light years away, it was a tight-beam transmission to a star cluster some 25,000 light years
away. So either they get the message a little over 25k years in the future and come (or send messages) back in time, it was intercepted, or they have
Internet access.
on the other hand, somehow making cropcircles remotely on some alien's planet doesn't sound like a good idea for a few reasons.
1 - you don't know if they see like you do, maybe they use echolocation, who knows, so visual communication is an uncertainty whereas you know they
could send radiotransmissions for sure.
The message we sent was an image. Of course we can see.
2 - actually altering anything physically on an alien's planet could be misinterpreted and be undisirable or even concidered hostile or morally
unacceptable to the alien species who send a message into space, they might frown apon it because they didn't invite you to interfere on their
planet's surface. Would you risk such a misunderstanding on first contact?
I'm not convinced they're benign anyway.
Sorry to pick your post apart like that man. I don't mean to offend.
I think if we are to assume that this is a reply of non-human origin, the fact that it came in the form of a crop formation strongly suggests they are
also behind some, if not most, of the rest of the crop formations. So this is nothing new for them. In this case we just gave them a protocol with
which to 'ping back' so to speak. I think the Cymatics argument is rather compelling to explain the other forms.
I've been thinking about why they would choose to make their drawings in the crops. Maybe the temporary nature is part of the message, as in here's
today's lesson, better pay attention and take notes because we have a lot of ground to cover(no pun intended I promise) and there will be a test.
I'm trying really hard not to anthropomorphize these creatures, but doesn't there seem to be a lot of oneupsmanship in the message? Like 'our DNA
is 4 nucleotides more efficient than yours, and yet we have more base pairs' or 'we outnumber you by 8 billion or so, and we have more planets AND
bigger brains!'
I say 'That's like, your opinion, man'
EDIT: math error and forgot to explain the edit
[edit on 13-3-2008 by Zelun]
[edit on 13-3-2008 by Zelun]