Originally posted by WraothAscendant
reply to post by Methuselah
There are a few problems I have with that story.
1) Why would God feel the need to kill his only begotten son to redeem us to himself?
2) Why did JC have to tell God "Forgive them for they know not what they do." if he planned it that way?
3) Why in the heck is God a he anyway?
Erm sorry. Please don't take my questions as an attack on your faith but they are questions I have had and no one has been able to sufficiently
answer them for me.

God didnt kill anyone, Jesus Christ sacrificed himself to pay for our sins.
meaning that because we have sinned, we were on our way to hell unless we found a substitute. Jesus Christ sacrificed himself so that we could live
and go to heaven instead. thats why Jesus died. God didnt kill him, that would be murder. there is a difference there.
Jesus was praying to God, probably telling him that he himself forgives them. yes they both knew what was going to happen. but you have to remember,
Jesus was in the form of a human being, capable of feeling ever bit of human pain possible while on the cross. think about it, you are making a choice
and at the same time knowing the outcome and still have to chose what to do. he still had the choice to call down his angels and have them save him.
but instead he stayed on the cross, took our punishment and forgave us.
also God turned his back on his son due to the sin of the world being the weight on shoulders.
Why is God a he? are you more so asking why is he not a she?
a man presents an image of power whereas a woman does not.
now I dont know everything, and im not always the best at explaining things. but this is what makes sense to me. Now I havent heard a better
explanation, im sure there is one but this is to the best of my knowledge.
does this answer any of your questions?