It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
To get bumble bees protections from agricultural practices, judges determined that bees could actually be considered fish.
A trio of judges in California said on Tuesday that bees could be legally classified as a type of fish as part of a ruling that gave added conservation protections to the endangered species.
"The issue presented here is whether the bumble bee, a terrestrial invertebrate, falls within the definition of fish," the judges wrote in their ruling. And, they concluded, it does.
The opinion is 35 pages of debate and legal explanation on what makes a fish a fish.
originally posted by: Sookiechacha
a reply to: nugget1
I mean, it's a stretch. But what is really head scratching is why they had to resort to this to protect bees.
To get bumble bees protections from agricultural practices, judges determined that bees could actually be considered fish.
The Trinity bristle snail, a land-dwelling snail that was classified as a fish in order to make it onto the threatened species list in 1980, set the precedent for deciding that a fish doesn’t have to be something that swims—and by that logic, bees, too, are fish.
But we do have to do everything we can to save the bees.
originally posted by: opethPA
Are you willfully ignoring what this classification is truly about ?
Literally taken from the source you linked this classification is just leveraging a loophole get protection from specific agricultural practices that are detrimental to bees.
To get bumble bees protections from agricultural practices, judges determined that bees could actually be considered fish.
Also taken from your own source this same loophole has been used in the past to get the same type of protection.
The Trinity bristle snail, a land-dwelling snail that was classified as a fish in order to make it onto the threatened species list in 1980, set the precedent for deciding that a fish doesn’t have to be something that swims—and by that logic, bees, too, are fish.