It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by alkesh
I am dumbfounded by people who believe in a book that was written in the bronze age by people that KNEW the earth was flat and KNEW the earth was the center of the universe. So they must KNOW how the universe and everything in it came to be.edit on 26-4-2012 by alkesh because: (no reason given)edit on 26-4-2012 by alkesh because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by autowrench
Well, the local Christian crowd assures me that the Bible is literally true, and must me taken in a literal manner. So which is it then? It states plainly that God created evil. Did God lie? Rhetorical question, I know. Circular logic? Care to explain to me just what Isaiah 45 means then?
Originally posted by Wonders
Originally posted by smithjustinb
Originally posted by BioSafe
I am trying to come to grips with what you are saying. The premise has merit. However can you please explain how Taking the life from another or forbidding liberty from another is good. How does greed fit into your equation? I get the general gist of your intent but am having a hard time bringing it all together.
We were made to be what we are. The point is accepting what we are. This includes the things we do. These things are going to happen probably for eternity regardless of what we believe. The point is, what are you doing? and how do you feel about being a part of a world where things like that happen? If we're ever going to find real peace, we're going to have to learn to accept that which is. Just because those things happen, doesn't mean if you were in their shoes you wouldn't have done the same thing. Who are we to judge? Its all about relativity, and all you can do is be you.
Why is the point of your thread convieniently on the 10th reply of the thread you posted? If you stated that the point of your thread was to tell everyone reading that they should just accept everyone and accept everything they do.."all you can do is be you", well you certainly seem to be trying to change some people, why can't they just be themselves? What are YOU doing? "Just because those things happen, doesn't mean if you were in their shoes you wouln't have done the same thing."
The bible is the most popular book of all time, each of us has a choice to pick it up and learn from it, there is a whole lot more to it than the story of Adam and Eve. I suggest you get off of your pedestal and try to understand what the bible teaches,
it wasn't written to teach people that, "Just because those things happen, doesn't mean if you in their shoes you wouldn't have done the same thing." Not only is that logic pathetic, it is, for many people, untrue. You call those who read bibles "bible thumpers",
a derogatory term for those who study the bible, you are hypocrite, why not "just accept" and "love" bible readers
instead you are so ready to agree with that "become a satanist" reply. I can only hope that people will be smart enough and moral enough to know that what they do matters and not stand by and accept whatever happens like a lab rat because there are going to be plenty of other people who make positive differences in the lives of others, they won't "just accept" their situation.edit on 10/01/11 by Wonders because: To add.
Originally posted by WickettheRabbit
Before reading through every response, I had to get this out.
You say God made everything that exists.
Evil exists.
God made evil?
So...
Originally posted by AQuestion
reply to post by smithjustinb
Dear smithjustinb,
I believe Satan is a mental condition created by said circumstances. I believe this mental condition serves a purpose which I barely have the wisdom to discern, and I am thankful to have this condition and I accept it. I am who I am and we are who we are and we couldn't be anything else. The question is, how much longer are we going to be blind to the glory of our existence? How much longer are we going to be in turmoil wiithin ourselves? When will there be peace? When we learn to accept this... all of it.
The conflict is in our defining ourselves. Satan, if you believe he exists, is defined as a sentient being with free will. His goal appears to be to have us worship him rather than God.
Originally posted by OptimusSubprime
reply to post by smithjustinb
You lost me when you said "we can create peace on Earth". Speaking from the same Bible that you quote, it states that only God will bring peace to Earth after the tribulation and the last great battle. In other words, there is no way that WE, as in mankind, can create peace on Earth. You have already contradicted yourself.
Another thing, at least according to the Bible, is that EVERYTHING NOT OF GOD is of Satan, so anything and everything is part of this Satanic agenda that you speak of, unless it is of God.
Regardless, I find it hard to believe a book written by man, and that isn't to say that I don't believe in God, because I certainly do, just not man's dogmatic deffinition of God.edit on 26-4-2012 by OptimusSubprime because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by Deetermined
Originally posted by autowrench
Well, the local Christian crowd assures me that the Bible is literally true, and must me taken in a literal manner. So which is it then? It states plainly that God created evil. Did God lie? Rhetorical question, I know. Circular logic? Care to explain to me just what Isaiah 45 means then?
As I already explained, God created evil when he created Satan and his angels, but they weren't always evil. He created them in perfection first, then they rebelled.
Originally posted by Deetermined
I just want to add that God wanted his angels and man to follow and worship him freely through free will. Unfortunately, it was through free will that evil was created. You have to know that Satan can't be too happy about the fact that man was given a plan of salvation and the angels were not. Once they chose to rebel against God, that was it for them. The angels were supposed to look after man and lead them, but some chose to corrupt them instead and God isn't going to forgive them for it.
Originally posted by Minori
reply to post by Akragon
It is his life that shows us how to live, but it was in his death that he saved us.
For Christ also died for sins once for all, the just for the unjust, so that He might bring us to God, having been put to death in the flesh, but made alive in the spirit . . .1 Peter 3:18
PLPL
Originally posted by Deetermined
As I already explained, God created evil when he created Satan and his angels, but they weren't always evil. He created them in perfection first, then they rebelled.
Maybe this in depth article on Lucifer's rebellion will help you to understand how evil came about. But as I stated before, God created Lucifer and God created free will, therefore, it can be said that God created evil.
I am dumbfounded by people who believe in a book that was written in the bronze age by people that KNEW the earth was flat and KNEW the earth was the center of the universe. So they must KNOW how the universe and everything in it came to be.
Originally posted by alkesh
reply to post by smithjustinb
very little wisdom offered in the bible..not anything anyone with lick of common sense or reason couldn't figure out on their own..
Originally posted by CirqueDeTruth
In the sixteenth century St. Augustine said, "Either God cannot abolish evil, or He will not. If he cannot, He is not all-powerful; if He will not, He is not all-God." He then went on to say, "Whence my ability to wish evil and refuse the good? Who placed this in me and planted the seedling of bitterness in me, since my whole being is from my most sweet God? If the Devil is the originator, then what is the source of the Devil?"
That is one of my favorite quotes from St. Augustine above. The question perplexed him as deeply then, as it does mankind today. I suspect the question will perplex man far into the future also.
Here is my thing. If there were no freedom (free will) then, and only then, could God alone be responsible for evil.