It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Hecate666
Can someone explain how an omnipotent and omniscient being can not have foreseen that one of only two of its creations would fall for the apple trick?
Does your god know or doesn't he?
If he did, he can't blame eve, as he could have foreseen what she would be doing and if he didn't, he is not able to know everything and hence he/she/it is fallible.
I am serious, could a christian elaborate please?
Oh yes and I don't want to hear that it was a test, as explained above it would have been a cruel joke to play on an innocent being with no life experience.
Sorry it's all complete cotswallop.
Originally posted by Iason321
reply to post by Hecate666
He wanted it to happen.
We'd be boring if he didnt allow evil into our world,
This life is mainly just a test to decide what sort of real life (after life) we truly want.
Originally posted by Iason321
reply to post by smithjustinb
No, and that thought is a dangerous one.
I'm going to paint a picture here, and it's going to be pretty brutal, but I feel the need to do it -
Do you have a wife? Or kids?
Would you idollay stand by while a gang of thieves brutally raped, tortured, and murdered them in front of you?
I am sorry for having to use such an extreme and graphic example, but I think you need to hear this.
Imagine the look of horror as a group of evil thugs violate your closest loved ones, and brutally butcher them
Would you accept them?
Originally posted by Hecate666
Originally posted by Iason321
reply to post by Hecate666
He wanted it to happen.
We'd be boring if he didnt allow evil into our world,
This life is mainly just a test to decide what sort of real life (after life) we truly want.
Did he come up with that excuse or his human followers?
I stress again, that if he is all knowing, he would have known the outcome. You are saying that he had planned all along to throw adam and eve out and subject them to the cruelty known on earth today.
Why did he not just chuck them out?
Why did he have to disguise it as a 'test' [the old excuse]?
He must have found pleasure in seeing eve play right into his trap. That worries me as it is not loving, kind or clever in any which way.
Whilst I believe the bible to be full of metaphors, I know why you try and excuse him. I personally think that Satan [the biblical one] is one heck of a decent guy.
He sees these puny humans being patronised and told what to do and what not to do all day long, so he offers them the 'red pill'.
You'll eat that apple and you'll see that all is not as perfect as you have made to believe.
Good on eve to choose the truth and knowledge.
It was Satan who liberated humans and now you followers turn the argument by saying 'god planned it all along'.
It doesn't make sense at all.
You can't believe in stories that do not make sense.
And your god can't get away with a weak excuse to cover up his/its shortcomings.
Did this really teach humans to TRUST in god?
A god that tricks you left right and centre?
I rather choose the freedom fighter who wants us to really stand on our own two feet.
You are listening to the wrong side's propaganda.
Please christians, there are so many more stories about god's hilarious tests and tricks [Abraham, kill your son...nah only joking, 'twas only a test, Cain and Abel, give me the food I like...just kidding, I don't eat just anything, anyway, I was only testing you.
Here humans is the most interesting tree ever in the world ever and I'll leave it standing just here in your reach, can you see this tempting brilliant tree Just don't try anything stupid, even though I know you have never learned consequences and have no bad bone in your body I'll be damned if I can't get you to disobey...as a test of course etc etc etc] that it should really make you think who is the good guy here.
The one that wants you to enjoy life with everything that it brings, wants you to explore your world and ask questions, wants you to be free from big bro...or the 'Testmaster extraordinaire'?
The message should be clear.
Originally posted by Iason321
reply to post by Hecate666
You've got 666 in your name and you claim satan is a "good guy" yet you also dont believe in him?
Why should anyone listen to anything you're saying unless they're completely deceived and believing in a world of lies?
I can't fathom what goes on in some peoples heads while posting here......
Actually, I can,
They are so deceived it seems normal to say things like this to them,
I can only shake my head in disbelief from the sidelines, and hope and pray I talk some sense into some of you reading this......
Originally posted by Iason321
reply to post by smithjustinb
Dude you needa lay off whatever you've been taking,
LOL!
I find it pretty awesome though that you have that much restraint and love in you,
Unfortunately the beast still resides in me and I'd unleash it in a second if someone attacked my family......
I suppose if everyone on earth thought like you, we wouldn't have the killers and the evil in the first place....
it's just wishful thinking though man, the world will never be like that.
At least not this world anyways......
Originally posted by CirqueDeTruth
Sorry my post doubled up. So I guess I'll ask a couple of clarifying questions.
Could you sum up in two or three sentences what the greatest lie ever told was?
Originally posted by CirqueDeTruth
The apple is the symbol of sexual desire.
Originally posted by Evanzsayz
reply to post by smithjustinb
I don't really get what you are saying, God wouldn't punish ignorant people just like he wouldn't punish someone who never knew God. It's said he loves us all, I'm starting to believe there is no heaven or hell that we go to. He loves us all so he just reincarnates us over and over.
Originally posted by Iason321
reply to post by smithjustinb
The message your preaching is like a combination of Jesus' teaching from the NT combined with some zen buddhism,
I like it.
All is good, all is perfect, everything is exactly how it should be right now.
Be present, be thankful, enjoy being, Be.
Ahhhh, i feel waves of relaxation from meditating on these thoughts