It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
How would you even know?
. . .I don't think it's the inspired, infallible word of God.
Originally posted by madnessinmysoul
reply to post by NOTurTypical
Why? Because this discussion needs counterpoints.
And I can say, though with possible doubts, that you may be unconsciously selecting the positive examples while ignoring possible negative outcomes, as most people tend to do.
We unconsciously select with a certain bias in our memories, so I'm not accusing you of doing anything different than what I do when I think about my own life.
Though I must also deem it fit to ask: why does God say no so often?
If God can cure cancer, and a righteous individual asks for cancer to be cured or for a cure to be discovered now, why does it not happen?
And once more I must ask, why does God not heal amputees?
The concept of prayer seems...bogus.
I've yet to see any defense of it. And I'm not going to say that it's a point against theism, as I don't really think the concept of god/s is tied inherently to the concept of god/s that answer prayers.
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
Again I'll ask how you could possibly provide a counter-point to my 'personal experiences'?
And I can say, though with possible doubts, that you may be unconsciously selecting the positive examples while ignoring possible negative outcomes, as most people tend to do.
Now you're talking about others personal experiences. lol I can remember quite often my prayers falling on 'deaf ears" when I was still living in blatant, unrepentant sin. See my above post again. Now that I'm repentant anytime the Holy Spirit leads me to do so, my prayers have virtually always been answered except one in particular. I'm quite satisfied.
We unconsciously select with a certain bias in our memories, so I'm not accusing you of doing anything different than what I do when I think about my own life.
Were talking about prayer, I'd assume you have no prayer life. And since you were never born again, God had no obligation to answer any of your prayers to begin with.
Though I must also deem it fit to ask: why does God say no so often?
Quite often we ask for the wrong things, or things against His will. Quite often a person has bitterness or unforgiveness in their hearts and God will not "hear" their prayer. There are all scriptural basis for these.
If God can cure cancer, and a righteous individual asks for cancer to be cured or for a cure to be discovered now, why does it not happen?
I've been witness to 3 miracle cures of cancer in our congregation last year alone.
And once more I must ask, why does God not heal amputees?
Since when is an amputee a life-threatening situation?
The concept of prayer seems...bogus.
Purely arbitrary conjecture. Millions of born again, spirit-filled Christians would completely disagree.
I've yet to see any defense of it. And I'm not going to say that it's a point against theism, as I don't really think the concept of god/s is tied inherently to the concept of god/s that answer prayers.
I've provided my personal testimony. Take it or leave it, doesn't matter to me whatsoever.
Originally posted by FeedTic
I just am having a lot of trouble believing the Bible. I don't think it's the inspired, infallible word of God.
If that's the case then how are we supposed to worship or even conduct ourselves?
I feel pretty much like I've been hoodwinked almost my entire life.
Originally posted by madnessinmysoul
reply to post by NOTurTypical
The counterpoint is as simple as stating that personal experiences are nothing to go by. Which was essentially what I said.
Again, this is a clear example of either cognitive dissonance or selective prayer. There's never been a demonstration of actually answered prayers, though there have been many attempts to do so.
Le sigh...I don't want to get on to stupid doctrinal debate. Simply put: "born again" theology has no more scriptural basis than any other form of salvation theology...actually, Universalism technically is the most scripturally based salvation theology, but that's a matter for a different thread.
And nowhere in the Bible does it state that the basis for answering prayer has anything to do with your state of being either 'born again' or not....even if I were to take such a clearly contradictory book as evidence.
If God only answers prayers that are in favor of his will...wouldn't he have done those things anyway? What's hte need for prayer? If this being can violate
Bull*I'll preempt the profanity filter*. Pure, and utter bull*profanityfilterpremption*. F*profanityfilterpremption*ing bull*profanityfilterpreemption*.
Your statement, an argumentum ad populum (a misapplied one as the populace isn't even on your side here), is a logical fallacy. I was simply stating my opinion on the matter with that, not saying that my opinion was conclusive.
Just like your personal testimony, it doesn't matter whatsoever. Facts, evidence, tests...those are the things that matter. And every single time prayer was tested it failed.
Originally posted by speculativeoptimist
I don't want to tell you what to do, rather I will share my experience. When I hit the crossroads, I dropped the dogma but maintained the spirit in my heart. After watching Joseph Cambell, a scholar in international myth, something he said resonated with me and that is god is a god of a thousand faces, appearing through one's familiar vernacular. Additionally I expanded the notion and now I have a similar view to the Taoist and the tao as well as the Native American "spirit in all things." I see god more as a force than an entity, but this is just my opinion.
Follow your heart....
Peace,
spec
Originally posted by NewAgeMan
reply to post by FeedTic
.P.S. The spirit also tells me that the OP is an atheist hoaxer, but I still operated like that wasn't the case, to be as informative and as helpful as possible for the collective reader, as well as other ATS members.
edit on 9-1-2011 by NewAgeMan because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
Originally posted by madnessinmysoul
reply to post by NOTurTypical
The counterpoint is as simple as stating that personal experiences are nothing to go by. Which was essentially what I said.
That's your arbitrary opinion, you realize therefore I'm equally entitled to mine. You're wrong.
Again, this is a clear example of either cognitive dissonance or selective prayer. There's never been a demonstration of actually answered prayers, though there have been many attempts to do so.
You mean God has refused to bow down and answer prayers for the skeptics for testing? Now why would He EVER do that???? lol
Le sigh...I don't want to get on to stupid doctrinal debate. Simply put: "born again" theology has no more scriptural basis than any other form of salvation theology...actually, Universalism technically is the most scripturally based salvation theology, but that's a matter for a different thread.
Utterly false. And Jesus tells Nicodemus he must be born again to enter the kingdom of heaven.
And nowhere in the Bible does it state that the basis for answering prayer has anything to do with your state of being either 'born again' or not....even if I were to take such a clearly contradictory book as evidence.
Wrong again. The Bible states in numerous places the prerequisites for god to "hear" prayers and answer them.
If God only answers prayers that are in favor of his will...wouldn't he have done those things anyway? What's hte need for prayer? If this being can violate
He has chosen to act through His creation. He's sovereign, I can't tell you why He does this.
Bull*I'll preempt the profanity filter*. Pure, and utter bull*profanityfilterpremption*. F*profanityfilterpremption*ing bull*profanityfilterpreemption*.
You're completely wrong. A young boy had a brain tumor the size of a golf ball, after prayer from the congregation the mass disappeared, not even visible on x-rays. He was wearing a patch over his right eye because the mass had screwed up his vision so bad without it it made him very nauseous. He no longer wore the patch after the mass was healed. Another woman had Leukemia, it is now gone, her doctor declared there was "no evidence" of the cancer anymore in her blood. And another woman had a mass in her breast which on her return visit in a month was completely gone.
Your statement, an argumentum ad populum (a misapplied one as the populace isn't even on your side here), is a logical fallacy. I was simply stating my opinion on the matter with that, not saying that my opinion was conclusive.
No it's not. I never claimed it was true because X number of people would agree with me.
Just like your personal testimony, it doesn't matter whatsoever. Facts, evidence, tests...those are the things that matter. And every single time prayer was tested it failed.
Like I said, I highly doubt God would bow down to skeptics to answer a prayer for their "testing". The Bible clearly states God acts on faith. God will not prove Himself to give someone faith.
Originally posted by rebeldog
reply to post by ACTS 2:38
see you just proved your lack of higher IQ.. god created us perfect?? really?
then how did man make a mistake if we were perfect?? would a perfect creation, created by a perfect being EVER be anything other than perfect? obviously you don't listen to yourself..
perfection is perfection, making anything that isn't perfect shows the creator as NOT PERFECT.. kinda like a parent blaming a kid for their behavior.. wouldn't the parent be responsible for the "childs" actions? hmmm
i know, i know..
Originally posted by rebeldog
reply to post by ACTS 2:38
see you just proved your lack of higher IQ.. god created us perfect?? really?
then how did man make a mistake if we were perfect?? would a perfect creation, created by a perfect being EVER be anything other than perfect? obviously you don't listen to yourself..
perfection is perfection, making anything that isn't perfect shows the creator as NOT PERFECT.. kinda like a parent blaming a kid for their behavior.. wouldn't the parent be responsible for the "childs" actions? hmmm
i know, i know..
Originally posted by andy1033
Like i said if you do not believe thats your business but do not assume that others around this world have not found things you will never, and most will never.
Why are you so selfish that you want stuff from god? Do you understand what i mean. You should go and ask yourself what that question means.edit on 1/7/2011 by andy1033 because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by FeedTic
I have been a Christian since I was 6 years old. I'm now almost 40 and I just don't see how God helps anyone. I mean I pray, my wife prays, and other people I know pray, but the prayers are randomly answered. The bible says that when two or more people come together and pray for the same thing that the prayer will be answered. In my experiences the prayers are hardly ever answered.
I know that there is always an out for the faithful. "It wasn't God's will" or "It will be answered in God's timing not ours." How convenient. I bet I could pray to the Sun and get the the same answers.
Anyway, I'm at a crossroad. Do I continue the path toward God, or do I turn away and follow my own path. I bet I get the same results either direction.
Is anyone else at this crossroad, or have been there? What did you do? What caused you to take the road that your on?
I hope this was the right forum to post this. If not, Mods please move. Thanks.