What does a 33 degree freemason know?, page 16
Pages: <<  13    14    15    16  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 4 times


reply posted on 18-12-2011 @ 12:27 PM by browsey
reply to post by JoshNorton



spelling it out, i am not stating facts! i was purely hypothesising and speculating, look deeper than trying to break down what i say into it all being wrong and why not focus on us having a discussion about it, my point was if he were a mason, degree irrelevant, how difficult would it be for it to be hidden and covered up for the reasons i presented above.



reply posted on 18-12-2011 @ 01:00 PM by JoshNorton
reply to post by browsey



And if you'd said that from the beginning, I'd have no argument. But your first post in this thread made two specific, unwavering claims, which you now acknowledge you shouldn't have made, or would have worded differently given the chance to revise them.

If you claim a positive that I believe to be false, I will ask you to show me the foundations of your assertion. If they hold merit, they may change my own views on the topic. I'm fully willing to admit when I'm proven wrong, and I'm always open to learning new things.

But bombshells like "You can be given the 33rd degree from the 3rd without need to obtain 4-32" (direct quote from your post), and "Tony Blair, the apparent figurehead of the labour party, is himself a 33rd degree mason" are clearly not coached as hypothesis or speculation.

My intent in arguing the matter with you is to urge you to take ownership of your words and convictions, to give you a stronger stance even if it's not one with which I agree. I'm tired of people one these forums repeating half-assed claims based on some YouTube video they saw, or some picture of a handshake. I enjoy well founded, reasonable & logical debate, and become frustrated when most of the posts on ATS fail to rise to any level of intellectual credulity.

So let us start over.
my point was if he were a mason, degree irrelevant, how difficult would it be for it to be hidden and covered up for the reasons i presented above
That's a good question, and one we can certainly build on.

To even become a "high level" Mason, such a politician would still have to take the 3 regular degrees in a Masonic lodge acting under a charter issued to them by a Grand Lodge. If we're talking about political figures in England, then they would, by necessity, be members of the UGLE. This cannot happen in a vacuum, and it takes a certain amount of time and work.

Another hypothetical to consider would be, was he a Mason before he became a public figure? Or did he join the fraternity after he was already in office? If the former, then commoners would have sat in lodge with him at some point or another. SOMEBODY would know he was a brother. If it was the latter, wouldn't it actually be harder to get to lodge unnoticed? Particularly when one is hounded by photographers, journalists & the like?


reply posted on 18-12-2011 @ 01:13 PM by browsey
reply to post by JoshNorton



understood and agreed im too used to my crazed debating rantings which sometimes without my own knowledge can lead me to "go off on one" if you will.

About when if he did, join, if he did, i believe it would have been during his time at oxford as per usual with many high-flying people who join societies albeit masonry, skull and bones or bullington, it was no uncommon for these people to join during their higher education process, however again, this is mere speculation


reply posted on 18-12-2011 @ 01:13 PM by browsey
reply to post by JoshNorton



understood and agreed im too used to my crazed debating rantings which sometimes without my own knowledge can lead me to "go off on one" if you will.

About when if he did, join, if he did, i believe it would have been during his time at oxford as per usual with many high-flying people who join societies albeit masonry, skull and bones or bullington, it was no uncommon for these people to join during their higher education process, however again, this is mere speculation


reply posted on 18-12-2011 @ 01:44 PM by KSigMason
reply to post by browsey


But you were using his claim to say one can go straight from the 3rd degree to the 33rd degree. Once claims is not evidence. That was my point.

Taking what we know, he was not a recognized Mason. He supposedly received the 33rd degree in Mexico, but there is no record of that existing today.

freemasonry.bcy.ca...

this being a quote i keep at mind whenever disregarding information as we really do not know, whether he is or isnt, the only people to know truly will be him, and his brothers in his lodge, which if he had one, would be very secretive and higher than any form or freemasonry anybody attempting to work their way up the ranks, could achieve.

No offense, but this is a fairly innaccurate statement. You're trying to make Crowley, and his Lodge, out to be more important than other Lodges. That's not how it works. Sounds a little pretentious to me.

Swearing an oath in Freemasonry does not void our duties and responsibilities outside the Craft. In fact we are charged to not devout so much time to Freemasonry that other things in life fall by the wayside. We are also charged to be good citizens in the discharge of our civic duties.


reply posted on 18-12-2011 @ 02:12 PM by browsey
Originally posted by KSigMason
reply to
post by browsey


But you were using his claim to say one can go straight from the 3rd degree to the 33rd degree. Once claims is not evidence. That was my point.

No offense, but this is a fairly innaccurate statement. You're trying to make Crowley, and his Lodge, out to be more important than other Lodges. That's not how it works. Sounds a little pretentious to me.

Swearing an oath in Freemasonry does not void our duties and responsibilities outside the Craft. In fact we are charged to not devout so much time to Freemasonry that other things in life fall by the wayside. We are also charged to be good citizens in the discharge of our civic duties.


I cant see once where i have mentioned Crowley to be 'more important' than any other mason, in fact not have i mentioned him being a mason, only that he claimed to be one. Let alone whatever lodge he belonged to, i didn not mentioned that lodges superiority to any other, so i cant see how im being pretentious as i didnt mention the above.

I understand that it would not want you to compromise yourself, or anything else, however if one gained a position in which they were your as i believe the masons call it, your 'masters in the shadows' you must agree we me that it is possible, not fact, but possible that if one obtained high ranking status' both in the government and the worlds oldest and largest (To what we know) secret society, the positions could be used corruptly and cause people to be wary, hence the need to cover up or hide ones status within a lodge. All of the above is merely me playing the devils advocate if you will and asking those questions that seem to me are possible and if executed correctly plausible.


reply posted on 18-12-2011 @ 05:48 PM by browsey
reply to post by KSigMason



*facepalm* A dubious misunderstanding, i was talking about tony blairs 'alleged' membership, not crowley haha, utter mistake but still, it is an unknown thing and truly only he (Tony Blair NOT Crowley ) and his fellow lodge brother will know, if he were.


reply posted on 19-12-2011 @ 11:46 AM by KSigMason
reply to post by Masonic Light


And Yarker was eventually expelled for his push of the Primitive Rite?

Pages: <<  13    14    15    16  >>    ^^TOP^^



Fundamentalist Christianity: a mind control CULT?
  Posted 4 days ago with 36 member flags
A masons ring of the 32nd degree
  Posted 11 days ago with 11 member flags
Monarch programming - evidence or coincidence?
  Posted 3 days ago with 11 member flags
The Court System and Freemasonry.
  Posted 5 days ago with 10 member flags
Exposing Freemasons & 33 - Geometry,Astrology, or Devil Worship?
  Posted 6 days ago with 7 member flags
FACT: Buzz Aldrin claimed moon as a Scottish Rite \'Territory\'
  Posted 14 days ago with 6 member flags
Must Read! Elite Paedophile Ring.
  Posted 4 days ago with 6 member flags
I was a Mason and here\'s what I learned...
  Posted 2 days ago with 6 member flags