US-Afghanistan withdrawal in 6-Months?, page 3
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 21 times


reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 09:19 AM by arcnaver
reply to post by SLAYER69



If Obama does withdraw, which I see as unlikely, he would OWN the defeat and I don't think the Democrats would allow that.

The feet dragging probably is an attempt by Obama to create a disaster, via military means so as to further push legislations meant to bind rights to nothing.


reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 09:33 AM by whaaa
reply to post by Pathos




Isn't it odd how things move in the world of politics and war?

During the Bush Administration; if you protested the war you were called a

Terrorist sympathizer, commie, traitor etc.

Now the same people that were doing all the name calling are placing the

responsibility on the sitting president. And now some want to "cut and run" to use the term once so popular.

I wonder if Obama had of lived up to his promises and pull out early in his

first term; how he would be viewed now?

Wars started for corruption and greed of a few all wrapped up in patriotism and retribution, and sold just like breakfast cereal, automobiles, soap and toilet paper.

God help us!!!




[edit on 5-11-2009 by whaaa]


reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 09:48 AM by Pathos
reply to post by whaaa


reply to post by gaslaugh123


If you think about this the right way, Obama is taking a big gamble on this one element. Since the Afghans have been very vocal about not wanting us there, maybe this will give him the excuse we need to leave.

Afghanistan is falling into the same historical mold as Iraq. Even though both wars were necessary at on point in time, we escalated them way too late in history.

Gulf War (Iraq War I) should have been thorough in the 90s, and the Afghanistan War between 2001 and now should have been thorough.

Both wars are being fought too late in history.


reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 10:20 AM by Pathos
U.N. to evacuate 600 staff from Afghanistan
Move follows last week’s deadly Taliban attack at guest house in Kabul
www.msnbc.msn.com...

KABUL - The United Nations said on Thursday it would temporarily evacuate hundreds of its international staff from Afghanistan due to deteriorating security, a sharp blow for Western efforts to stabilize the country.

Spokesman Aleem Siddique said the United Nations would relocate about 600 of its roughly 1,100 international staff, with some being moved to safer sites within Afghanistan and the rest withdrawn from the country temporarily.

The move, a week after five U.N. foreign staff were killed by militants in Kabul, is a blow for U.S. president Barack Obama's counter-insurgency war strategy, which foresees an influx of civilian assistance alongside extra troops.

Obama must have sent out word that 'we are' leaving Afghanistan. Its not longer a possibility. 'We are leaving' in 6-months. UN has already started to evacuate the region. Its not a question of 'if'. Its a question of 'how fast' and 'how orderly' they can get everyone out of Afghanistan. Six months is just about right. Hopefully, we will not relive the MIA hell of Vietnam.


[edit on 5-11-2009 by Pathos]


reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 10:33 AM by Helmkat
reply to post by Blue_Jay33



Excellent point and one I very rarely seen brought up. Where would we be right now if all the blood and treasure of these two wars had not been flushed down the toilet? Where would the economy be? What would our world look like right now if Gore had made it to office...

To me these are points where we as a people went down the wrong path and we began paying the price for it soon after.

Sorry for the wistful wishing, it neither toil or spin.


reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 10:58 AM by SLAYER69
Well this isn't a new development. Here is a part of an article I posted in another thread the 14th of last month it didn't get much attention then. I've been following this for some time.

AP sources: Afghan corruption worries McChrystal
A still-secret document by Army Gen. Stanley McChrystal that requests more troops is expected to be among the topics discussed Wednesday when President Barack Obama meets with his national security team to hash out a strategy for Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Even with additional troops, McChrystal concluded that corruption still could let terrorists turn Afghanistan back into a haven, according to officials at the Pentagon and White House.

His request outlines three options for additional troops — from as many as 80,000 to as few as 10,000 — but favors a compromise of 40,000 more forces, the officials said. They described it to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss it publicly.



reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 11:03 AM by nunya13
reply to post by SLAYER69



I started a thread because this exact same scenario is happening in Iraq. It is being suggested that some of these bombings have been able to occur because the security forces have been infiltrated by insurgents.

How in the world can WE do anything to make the country stable if you can't even trust the government, let alone the security forces???

Here's the thread:

abovetopsecret.com

But here's the links to the articles in my thread (the thread ain't exactly hopping right now, apparently it's not that big of a deal if it's happening in Iraq. The Iraq war is soooooo last season! The Afghanistan war is the new Iraq war! lol)

Largest Iraq bombing in two years may have been an inside job

Iraq blasts an 'inside job'

Thanks for bringing this forth, Slayer. It just really goes to show that these wars are running their course and we can't correct thousands of years of unrest that are the result of DEEP seeded religious and ethnic issues. S&F


reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 11:04 AM by SLAYER69
Originally posted by Pathos
Obama must have sent out word that 'we are' leaving Afghanistan. Its not longer a possibility. 'We are leaving' in 6-months. UN has already started to evacuate the region. Its not a question of 'if'. Its a question of 'how fast' and 'how orderly' they can get everyone out of Afghanistan. Six months is just about right. Hopefully, we will not relive the MIA hell of Vietnam.


The US wants to defeat al-Qaida in Afghanistan
Whisper it quietly. Contrary to popular opinion, the west has won the war in Afghanistan.

We've won. It was critical, after 9/11, that we went into Afghanistan to destroy the terrorist training camps that the plotters had attended … and we've done that: there are no camps left in Afghanistan, and all of the terror plots now come out of Pakistan.




reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 11:17 AM by nunya13
reply to post by Benevolent Heretic



That's what bothers me about some people in government not knowing all the facts. Especially those who represent the people. They are expected to make decisions to go to war or get out of a war, yet they are told "you don't have all the info so it's not your decision to make. Just trust us".

This is so wrong on many levels, namely that reasserts the idea that we have faction of the government operating on information only it knows and the rest of us don't; therefore, they do whatever they want regardless of how we feel about it because we don't have all the facts.


reply posted on 5-11-2009 @ 11:17 AM by jam321
Seems like "withdrawal" is a mighty popular theme as of late.

A major rift in Britain's governing party over the war in Afghanistan opened up Wednesday when a former Foreign Office minister became the first senior British politician to call for a withdrawal of British troops.

Kim Howells, a Labour Party MP who chairs a parliamentary committee overseeing intelligence and security, published his article calling for withdrawal just ahead of news that five British troops were shot dead in southern Afghanistan. Analysts say his senior position, and the access to classified information it affords him, will likely give his words resonance among the broader British public.


www.csmonitor.com...

The United Nations today temporarily pulled half its international staff out of Afghanistan and threatened that a complete and permanent withdrawal could follow.

Amid an atmosphere of increasing gloom in Afghanistan, the UN Special Representative in Kabul, Kai Eide delivered a pointed warning to the government of Hamid Karzai.

“There is a belief among some, that the international community (presence) will continue whatever happens because of the strategic importance of Afghanistan,” he told a press conference this morning. “I would like to emphasise that that’s not true.”


www.timesonline.co.uk...

This means that at the very least two of the ten key allies of the US in Afghanistan will withdraw their troops within max. 1.5 years time. Germany, the third most important provider of troops, has also talked about withdrawal, as have several other important allies.

I expect it will not take long before the West’s coalition decides to withdraw altogether and hand the country back to the Taliban – especially considering America’s unwillingness to do what’s necessary to win this war.


www.poligazette.com...

Rather than doubling down on a strategy with objectives that could be unachievable, we should announce a flexible timetable to draw down our forces from Afghanistan. A timetable would defuse the perception that we are occupying that country, and help ensure that our presence does not fuel militancy and instability in the region.

Sen. Russ Feingold, D-Wis., is a member of the Senate Foreign Relations and Intelligence Committees.


host.madison.com...

The Australian government has asked military commanders to find ways to complete their missions in Afghanistan as soon as possible. The announcement is being seen as a clear hint that Canberra may pull its 1,500 troops out of Afghanistan earlier than expected.


www.voanews.com...
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6  >>    ^^TOP^^



Did Carl Sagan know something?
  Posted 17 days ago with 276 member flags
Earthly coincidences...or not.
  Posted 13 days ago with 122 member flags
STOP....Take a STEP BACK....and look at the BIG PICTURE!!
  Posted 19 days ago with 115 member flags
Was this the real reason why Megaupload was closed down?
  Posted 18 days ago with 96 member flags
The Mysterious Death of Marilyn Monroe
  Posted 16 days ago with 85 member flags

Newest topics getting replies, in real-time:

Anonymous hacks CIA
  Breaking Alternative News, Posted 15 hours ago, 110 replies
Free Psychic Readings
  General Chit Chat, Posted 11 hours ago, 96 replies
Hollow Earth Theory New Evidence.
  General Conspiracies, Posted 9 hours ago, 62 replies
Free will
  Philosophy and Metaphysics, Posted 13 hours ago, 50 replies