posted on Oct, 24 2008 @ 06:15 PM
reply to post by asmeone2
I believe when you factor in the expenditure of treating all the ailments caused by smoking the government actually loses money on the deal, which is
why they're pushing smoking cessation. Let's say the average smoker smokes for 30 years, a pack a day. They pay, let's say, $3 a pack in taxes,
that's $1,095 a year they pay in taxes, multiplied by 30 years is $32,850 over the course of their smoking lifespan. Now suddenly, they get a
disease from smoking... doesn't have to be the big 'C' it can be heart disease, emphysema, or even just an overall diminished health. My
mother-in-law smokes like a chimney stack and got heart disease from it, she's also getting medicare/medicaid. Even removing her open heart bypass
surgery and recooperation hospital stay from the equation, her annual medical bill between visits, tests, medicines, and home care equipment for her
bronchitis (also from smoking) probably pass $32K 2/3rds of the way through the
year. If you throw in the surgeries and attempts to cure
people's cancers and such caused by smoking, you have a single sick smoker who can easily burn through the tax revenue generated by 6 or 7 smokers or
even more.
When they initially upped taxes on cigarettes, I think they did so intending to ride the cash cow, what they didn't realize was that the tobacco
companies would need to increase the addictiveness of the product to keep people paying the higher price and, with that increased addictiveness, also
came an increase in the chemicals which make smoking so unhealthy. A viscious circle was formed and, eventually, we're going to be forced to break
it somehow. The nonsmoker's way would be to say "just quit smoking" whereas the smoker's way is to say "remove some of the chemicals and lower
the taxes to allow a chance for some of the natural tobacco companies to compete."
One thing I'll say to all the folks who are in favor of taxing the hell out of the smoker because it's unhealthy and costing everyone health
insurance money is that I sincerely hope you don't enjoy eating fast food, red meat, or anything classified as "junk" food. Y'all will be the
next in line to watch fascist government control of consumable goods in action. It wasn't until insurance companies started loudly complaining about
the cost of treating smokers that the government started this crap. The insurance companies pad our dear leaders' wallets handsomely and believe me
when I say this, all they'll have to do is place McDonalds in their sights and tell the government officials they have bought over the years that
something needs to be done and we'll see the Dollar Menu become the Dollar plus $2.75 sin tax Menu become a reality.