Originally posted by seentoomuch
reply to post by Element-115
Do you believe that exceptional events happen to people on occasion? Ever? Please share one exceptional event that you consider valid so that we
know where your bar is set. If it is non-existent, that there are none well it says a lot about your ability to judge, which is what you're doing.
Think about it, do you know All? Are you qualified to judge All? A simple yes or no would do for my last question and will tell me loads about
you.
STM
[edit on 7/7/2008 by seentoomuch]
You're joking right?
A simple yes or no will do? Are you aware that the question you ask is rhetorical? That it can't be answered with a yes or no. You just want to win
an argument by posing such a question and you're not winning.
Half way through your post you have already judged me... so what do you want me to say? Other than you're a waste of my time.
Am I qualified to see who's lying and who's not? As a matter of fact I am. But then would you believe me if I said who I was working for and what my
position is without giving you my office number and my diplomas? Think about it, if I didn't do that, you wouldn't believe me right? Why? Isn't it
possible that I am who I say I am (I've not told you what I do for a living) without giving you any of YOUR standards in proof?
But you'd rather believe a man who says he was attacked by a FISH MAN CREATURE?
Wow.. I mean, wow.
Alright Mr. seentoomuch, it seems YOU HAVEN'T SEEN enough to be able to decode the post Dan has written.
IN plain English... You're not at all asking the right questions here... You're questioning me on how I can know a character is lying or not.
You're asking me if I believe that exceptional situations might happen to people... Yes I do believe that exceptional things can happen to people.
Like a person who's been brought up in a tribe in the deep jungles far away from technology, presented with a moment of a full featured demo of an
iPod Touch... I'm sure he's got an amazing story to tell... But then... since he's got NO idea of the technological progress from the outside
world... he'll interpret his experience and retell the story in terms only he can make sense of. I'm sure magic is included in the explanation.
Remember that this person in the jungle never knew about the outside world.
So.. in Dan's case... it's NOT that he's seen something that he can't explain... I'm just saying that I do believe in people having exceptional
moments. Like meeting your wife to be, seeing your child for the first time. Things like that are pretty magical... but not unrealistic cause it's
how we interpret things. You choose to believe in Dan, because you need to. You don't apply any logic or reasoning to his persona or actions. You are
more consumed with the thought of WHY CAN'T this be real? And then you defend it possibility that it might, without knowing anything about forensic
psychology or good old reasonable doubt.
If you are happy living in a magical world.. then stay there.. just don't drag others with you because it's your own make belief world and it's
tailor made just for you by you!
I've answered your questions and I'm concluding our conversation because you're clearly not a reasonable person... otherwise you'd agree... by
saying "He MIGHT be lying..." but you don't...
Sorry but your boat won't float for much longer...