It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: toysforadults
a reply to: ntech
you realize homeless people go to jail on purpose so they can get medical care or it's cold outside right? it doesn't work, to them jail is just a safe place to sleep at night with free food
People who have clear mental issues or severe drug addiction issues need to be dealt with humanely. I don't think jailing them works, but we do need to bring back looney hospitals and maybe instead of "jail" it is more like a rehab center.
I live in a very liberal community with all kinds of homeless services. I've literally seen the same drug addicts / bums hanging out for years. They come to the community leaving their needles and crap all over our parks. We had one of these losers OD in our public library. I don't want my kids around them.
I am not heartless but we need to have some common sense in dealing with the issue.
originally posted by: toysforadults
a reply to: Edumakated
People who have clear mental issues or severe drug addiction issues need to be dealt with humanely. I don't think jailing them works, but we do need to bring back looney hospitals and maybe instead of "jail" it is more like a rehab center.
I totally agree.
"I don't agree with their lifestyle so they should be in jail" is very authoritarian.
I live in a very liberal community with all kinds of homeless services. I've literally seen the same drug addicts / bums hanging out for years. They come to the community leaving their needles and crap all over our parks. We had one of these losers OD in our public library. I don't want my kids around them.
I am not heartless but we need to have some common sense in dealing with the issue.
I can see your point here. I go to my local library regularly to study, well I used to anyway but since they allow the crazies to hang out there I can't do it anymore. Kinda sucks I pay for the library so people can use it to study and read and the youth can have exposure to something other than an IPad.
It seems to me more than anything these people just need a place to go that's not at our Library's or city halls.
Forcibly removing people from the streets is authoritarian but I don't think any other approach will work. I don't want to trample on people's rights, but if someone is homeless and mentally unstable / addict they cannot care for themselves.
Their homelessness has nothing to do with income inequality, affordable housing, etc. These people simply cannot function in society hence their homelessness.
originally posted by: toysforadults
a reply to: Edumakated
Forcibly removing people from the streets is authoritarian but I don't think any other approach will work. I don't want to trample on people's rights, but if someone is homeless and mentally unstable / addict they cannot care for themselves.
I agree. But saying, "I don't agree with the homeless lifestyle or people using drugs so we should put them in jail" is as equally authoritarian as "you gotta pay for everyone elses healthcare".
If people don't want help like many suggest and I bet many don't (not all but probably a bunch of people), then, leave them alone. I for sure don't want my tax dollars spent on helping someone who doesn't want help.
We can agree on that right? Not spending money on people who don't want help.
Their homelessness has nothing to do with income inequality, affordable housing, etc. These people simply cannot function in society hence their homelessness.
Hmmm. I don't know. I would have to see data is there any data on homeless people?
I can agree that the majority of homeless people have serious mental health issues, should we institutionalize them? Should they be in prison with maniacs?
I don''t have any data on it but it seems like common sense. If you want them to either go away or try to improve themselves and work there way out of it then jail would be a good start. Sticks and carrots. Jail would be a big stick. A big incentive to stop wallowing about when you hit bottom.