*Jews were in region at 1200 B C
*Palestinians lived in area for 2000 years
*Both groups claim the area as home
Long before the Arab conquest, a thousand years before the Prophet Mohammed was born, the Jew, already exiled, sitting by the waters of Babylon, was
singing: "If I forget thee O Jerusalem, may my right hand forget its cunning."
Israel had already become a nation about 1220 B.c. - nearly two thousand years before the first Arab invasion began. The Jews' persistent presence on
the land survived periodic attempts to extinguish them throughout their history. Around the first century, many Diaspora Jews observed the
commandments of pilgrimage, and on the High Holidays in Jerusalem one might have met Jews from such different lands as Parthia, Media, Elam,
Mesopotamia, Cappadocia, Pontus, Asia Minor, I'hrygia, Pamphylia, Cyrene, Crete, Rome and Arabia. By the time of the Roman conquest of Judea the
Jews were considered "turbulent and troublesome people to deal with," according to the Encyclopaedia Britannica, when they stubbornly refused to
surrender their country to Roman rule.
The Emperor Hadrian, "determined to stamp out this aggressive Jewish nationalism," ruled that henceforth Jewish traditions such as circumcision, the
Sabbath, reading of the law-in fact, the beliefs of Judaism itself-were illegal and "forbidden." Hadrian was "determined to convert the still
half-ruined Jerusalem into a Roman colony." After the Jews' Temple was destroyed in A.D. 70, the revolt of Jewish leader Bar Kochba-who had
"200,000 men at his command" -- recaptured Jerusalem and many "strongholds and villages throughout the country." The "full-scale country-wide
war raged with fierce bitterness for four years, the Romans having to bring in legion after legion of reinforcements to suppress the insurgents."
Although the Romans ultimately regained political reign, "sacked the city (of Jerusalem) and expelled the bulk of the Jewish survivors from the
country", the cost of victory was shattering "It is said that as many as 580,000 men were slain!" Romans as well as Jews. It was after the
debacle that Hadrian changed the name of the city of Jerusalem to Aelia Capitolina, ordered the building of a temple of Jupiter on the Jewish Temple
site and "forbade any Jew, on pain of death, to appear within sight of the city."
But in the same way that the name Judea did not disappear, neither did the Jews abandon their land. A number had obstinately remained, and many others
quickly returned to rebuild their world. Some Jews, however, fled the Roman conquest for other points -- including Arabia, where they formed some new
settlements and in many instances joined Jewish Arabian communities established at the time of release from the captivity in Babylon or existing even
before then. Thus evolved the flight of the first "Palestinian" refugees-the Judeans, or Jews.
The Haven in Arabia
A look at the haven where these "Palestinian" or "Judean" Jewish refugees from the Romans found sanctuary is important to understanding the
"heart of the matter" in the Middle East today -- the conflict between Arab and Jew. The circumstances of the Arabian Jewish communities in the
Arabian Peninsula -- both before and after the Arab Conquest-bear importantly upon Arab-Jewish relationships until this day, because the pattern that
developed in Arabia established a tradition that has been followed ever since.
According to Arabist scholar Alfred Guillaume, Jews probably first settled in Arabia in connection with the fall of Samaria in 721 B.C.: it is almost
certain that the self-contained Jewish military colony in Aswan and upper Egypt, about which the world knew nothing until a few years ago, was founded
just after the fall of Samaria, and consequently it is not impossible that some Jewish settlements in Arabia were due to fugitives fleeing from the
old northern capital of the Hebrews.
Guillaurne is certain that "in the first and second centuries A.D., Arabia offered a near asylum" to the Jews who had been victimized by the
"utterly ruthless" Romans. In the Arabian land considered by many to be "purely Arab," the land which would spawn Islam many centuries later,
Numbers of Jewish and Christian settlements were established in different parts of Arabia, both spreading Aramaic and Hellenistic culture. The chief
southern Arabian Christian centre was in Najran, where a relatively advanced political life was developed. Jews and Judaised Arabs were everywhere,
especially in Yathrib, later renamed Medina. They were mainly agriculturists and artisans. Their origin is uncertain and many different theories have
been advanced.
Although the fact is little recognized, more than one historian has affirmed at the Arab world's second holiest city, Medina, was one of the
allegedly "purely Arab" cities that actually was first settled by Jewish tribes." Bernard Lewis writes: The city of Medina, some 280 miles north of
Mecca, had originally been settled by Jewish tribes from the north, especially the Banu Nadir and Banu Quraiza. The comparative richness of the town
attracted an infiltration of pagan Arabs who came at first as clients of the Jews and ultimately sucqeeded in dominating them. Medina, or, as it was
known before Islam, Yathrib, had no form of stable government at all. The town was tom by the feuds of the rival Arab tribes of Aus and Khazraj, with
the Jews maintaining an uneasy balance of power. The latter, engaged mainly in agriculture and handicrafts, were economically and culturally superior
to the Arabs, and were consequently disliked.... as soon as the Arabs had attained unity through the agency of Muhammad they attacked and ultimately
eliminated the Jews.
Guillaume reports that the anti-Jewish attack at Khaibar was fiercely fought off, but "though the inhabitants fought more bravely here than
elsewhere, outnumbered and caught off their guard, they were defeated." Those who somehow survived constituted the formula for Islam's future
successes. Some of the Jews, "non-Muslims" or infidels, "retained their land," at least until Muslims could be recruited in sufficient numbers to
replace the Jews. Meanwhile, the Arabian Jews paid a fifty-percent "tribute," or tax, for the "protection" of the new plunderers. As Professor
Lewis writes, "The Muslim victory in Khaibar marked thefirst contact between the Muslim state and a conquered non-Muslim people and formed the basis
for later dealings of the same type."
Other Jewish colonies succumbed in much the same way: "Jews were allowed to keep their land on condition that they surrendered half the produce to
Medina." But, "the arrangement did not last long Virtually all of Khaibar's and Medina's surviving Jews along with "all the other Jews and
Christians in the peninsula" were dispossessed and expelled through the Prophet Muhammad's edict, zealously implemented by his caliph Omar.
Much of the wealth of the country which had been concentrated in the hands of the Jews had now been seized by the Muslims, who were no longer indigent
immigrants but wealthy landowners, men of substance, owning camels and horses and their own weapons.... Muhammad's fame spread far and wide, and the
bedouin flocked to him in thousands.
Medina, Islam's second holiest city, was originally a Jewish settlement
The city of Medina, some 280 miles north of Mecca, had originally been settled by Jewish tribes from the north, especially the Banu Nadir and Banu
Quraiza. The comparative richness of the town attracted an infiltration of pagan Arabs who came at first as clients of the Jews and ultimately
succeeded in dominating them. Medina, or, as it was known before Islam, Yathrib, had no form of stable government at all. The town was tom by the
feuds of the rival Arab tribes of Aus and Khazraj, with the Jews maintaining an uneasy balance of power. The latter, engaged mainly in agriculture
and handicrafts, were economically and culturally superior to the Arabs, and were consequently disliked.... as soon as the Arabs had attained unity
through the agency of Muhammad they attacked and ultimately eliminated the Jews.
According to Guillaume:
At the dawn of Islam the Jews dominated the economic life of the Hijaz [Arabia]. They held all the best land; at Medina they must have formed at least
half of the population. There was also a Jewish settlement to the north of the Gulf of Aqaba, what is important is to note that the Jews of the Hijaz
made many proselytes (or converts) among the Arab tribesmen.
The first "Palestinian" or Judean refugees -- the Jews -- had resettled to become prosperous, influential Arabian settlers.
The prosperity of the Jews was due to their superior knowledge of agriculture and irrigation and their energy and industry. Homeless [Jewish]
refugees in the course of a few generations became large landowners in the country, the refugees who had come to the Hijaz when the Romans conquered
Palestine controllers of its finance and trade.... Thus it can readily be seen that Jewish prosperity was a challenge to the Arabs, particularly the
Quraysh at Mecca and other Arab tribes at Medina.
The Prophet Muhammad himself was a member of the Quraysh tribe, which coveted the Jews' bounty, and when the Muslims took up arms they treated the
Jews with much greater severity than the Christians, who, until the end of the purely Arab Caliphate, were not badly treated.
One of the reasons for "this discrimination" against the Jews is what Guillaurne called "the Quran's scornful words" regarding the Jews
development of land and culture was a prime source of booty in the Arabian desert peninsula. Beginning at the time of the Prophet Muhammad and Islam
from the expulsions, depredations, extortion, forced conversions or murder of Jewish Arabians settled in Medina to the mass slaughter of Jews at
Khaibar, the precedent was established among Arab-Muslims to expropriate that which belonged to the Jews. Relations between the Prophet Muhammad and
the Jews were "never easy": They had irritated him by their refusal to recognize him as a prophet, by ridicule and by argument; and of course their
economic supremacy was a standing irritant.
It appears that the first "instigation" by the Prophet Muhammad himself against the Jews was an incident in which he had "one or two Jews murdered
and no blood money was paid to their next of kin."
Their leaders opposed his claim to be an apostle sent by God, and though they doubtless drew some satisfaction from his acceptance of the divine
mission of Abraham, Moses, and the prophets, they could hardly be expected to welcome the inclusion of Jesus and Ishmael among his chosen
messengers.
The existence of pockets of disaffected Jews in and around his base was a cause of uneasiness and they had to be eliminated if he (Muhammad) was to
wage war without anxiety.
Because the Jews preferred to retain their own beliefs, a tribe of Jews in the neighborhood of Medina, fell under suspicion of treachery and were
forced to lay down their arms and evacuate their settlements. Valuable land and much booty fell into the hands of the Muslims. The neighboring tribe
of Qurayza, who were soon to suffer annihilation, made no move to help their co-religionists, and their allies, the Aus, were afraid to give them
active support.
The Prophet Muhammad's pronouncement: "Two religions may not dwell together on the Arabian Peninsula." This edict was carried out by Abu Bakr and
Omar I, the Prophet Muhammad's successors; the entire community of Jewish settlements throughout northern Arabia was systematically slaughtered.
According to Bernard Lewis, "the extermination of the Jewish tribe of Quraiza was followed by "an attack on the Jewish oasis of Khaibar."
Messengers of Muhammad were sent to the Jews who had escaped to the safety and comfort of haibar, "inviting" Usayr, the Jewish "war chief," to
visit Medina for mediations. Usayr set off with thirty companions and a Muslim escort. Suspecting no foul play, the Jews went unarmed. On the way, the
Muslims turned upon the defenseless delegation, killing all but one who managed to escape. "War is deception," according to an oft-quoted saying of
the Prophet.
The late Israeli historian and former President, Itzhak Ben-Zvi, judged the "inhuman atrocities" of the Arabian communities as unparalleled since
then: the complete extermination of the two Arabian-Jewish tribes, the Nadhir and Kainuka' by the mass massacre of their men, women and children, was
a tragedy for which no parallel can be found in Jewish history until our own day.
The slaughter of Arabian Jews and the expropriation of their property became Allah's will. According to the Koran, some you slew and others you took
captive. He (Allah) made you masters of their [the Jews'] land, their houses and their goods, and of yet another land [Khaibar] on which you had
never set foot before. Truly, Allah has power over all things.
Guillaume reports that the anti-Jewish attack at Khaibar was fiercely fought off, but "though the inhabitants fought more bravely here than
elsewhere, outnumbered and caught off their guard, they were defeated." Those who somehow survived constituted the formula for Islam's future
successes. Some of the Jews, "non-Muslims" or infidels, "retained their land," at least until Muslims could be recruited in sufficient numbers to
replace the Jews. Meanwhile, the Arabian Jews paid a fifty-percent "tribute," or tax, for the "protection" of the new plunderers. As Professor
Lewis writes, "The Muslim victory in Khaibar marked the first contact between the Muslim state and a conquered non-Muslim people and formed the basis
for later dealings of the same type."
Thus the Jewish dhimmi evolved (the protected ones), the robbery of freedom and political independence compounding the extortion and eventual
expropriation of property. "Tolerated" between onslaughts, expulsions, and pillages from the Arab Muslim conquest onward, the non-Muslim
dhimmi-predominantly Jewish but Christian too provided the important source of religious revenue through the "infidel's" head tax. He became very
quickly a convenient political scapegoat and whipping boy as well.
Link -
www.eretzyisroel.org...
Arab Oppression of Jews
As a Muslim in Hebron retorted when he was confronted with his theft and vandalism of Jews in 1858, "his right derived from time immemorial in his
family, to enter Jewish houses, and take toll or contributions at any time without giving account." This attitude and its prevalence in Palestine
cannot be overlooked. It is perhaps the most powerful factor in the Middle East conflict today and certainly the core of the "Palestinian" question
-- the true "heart of the matter."
From the beginning of Turkish rule in the sixteenth century, the infidel dhimma code of oppressions against non-believers was maintained in Palestine.
The humiliation was a given; the degree of harshness of injunctions against Jews depended on the whim of the ruler, local as well as the lord of the
empire. Among the constants of dhimma restrictions in the Holy Land:
Jews had to pass Muslims on their left side, because that was the side of Satan. They had to yield the right of way, step off the pavement to let the
Arab go by, above all make sure not to touch him in passing, because this could provoke a violent response. In the same way, anything that. reminded
the Muslim of the presence of alternative religions, any demonstration of alternative forms of worship, had to be avoided so synagogues were placed in
humble, hidden places, and the sounds of Jewish prayer carefully muted.
Link -
www.eretzyisroel.org...
Throwing Stones at Jews is based in Ancient Islamic Ritual
During the Hajj pilgrimage there is a ritual in which pilgrims stone a pillar symbolising the devil near the holy city of Mecca. Islamic sermons
repeatedly emphasize the connection between the Jews and Satan. What is the proper way to deal with an insolent Jew? To throw stones.
Dr. Abdul Halim Mahmoud, rector of Cairo�s al-Ashar University, theologically and politically the most influential university in Islamdom: �Allah
commands Moslems to fight the friends of Satan wherever they are to be found. Among the friends of Satan indeed, among the foremost friends of Satan
in the present age, are the Jews.�
Just after the turn of the present century, the British vice-consul in Mosul wrote a report that illustrated the nature of the "traditional
relationship" between Muslim and Jew in a less volatile moment: The attitude of the Moslems toward the Christians and Jews, to whom as stated above,
they are in a majority of ten to one, is that of a master towards slaves whom he treats with a certain lordly tolerance so long as they keep their
place. Any sign of pretension to equality is promptly repressed. It is often noticed in the streets that almost any Christian submissively makes way
even for a Moslem child. Only a few days ago the writer saw two respectable looking, middle-aged Jews walking in a garden. A small Moslem boy, who
could not have been more than 8 years old, passed by and, as he did so, picked up a large stone and threw it at them -- and then another -- with the
utmost nonchalance, just as a small boy elsewhere might aim at a dog or bird. The Jews stopped and avoided the aim, which was a good one, but made no
further protest.
Perhaps the definitive historian on the North African Jews, H. Z. Hirschberg, notes that in fifteenth-century Tunis, several Jews held "positions of
honor." To a Western-oriented reader, the "position of honor" would indicate freedom from persecution. Yet an authenticated and respected
document of that period, written by a visiting Flemish nobleman, describes Tunisian Jews as "despised and hated." After noting the privileged
positions of local Christians, the nobleman wrote: The Jews, on the other hand, have no freedom. They must all pay a heavy ... tax. They wear special
clothes, different from those of the Moors. If they did not do so, they would be stoned, and they therefore put a yellow cloth on their heads or
necks; their women dare not even wear shoes. They are much despised and hated, more than even the Latin Christians. A teacher was sent from Beirut
in 1910 to assess the constant reports of travail for the Yemenite Jews. He noted that, after more than a week, I have made myself acquainted with the
life of the Jews in all its phases.... They are exceedingly unfortunate.... If they are abused, they listen in silence as though they had not
understood; if they are attacked by an Arab boy with stones, they flee...
According to nineteenth-century historians, some Jewish families in Aleppo -which, like Alexandria, was an atypically tolerant cosmopolitan center of
international commerce -- were affluent and relatively safe. Others, even in Aleppo, who were less well-connected were "subject to violence and
oppression from various quarters." Money was extorted by officials on every pretext, petty bullying was commonplace, and one Jew reported that
"When a Jew walked among them (the Muslims) in the market, one would throw a stone at him in order to kill him, another would pull his beard and a
third his ear lock, yet another spit on his face and he became a symbol of abuse."
Reference Links:
www.us-israel.org...
www.stateofisrael.com...
www.time.com...
www.marxists.de...
www.cdn-friends-icej.ca...
www.memri.de...
www.eretzyisroel.org...
www.jajz-ed.org.il...