Originally posted by Cyberbian
OK maybe we need to define a few things to free peoples mind from circular thinking.
Phenomena, the knowable, the proveable, the measurable.
Neumena, the unknowable the un-provable, the unmeasurable.
Astral Projection is Neumena. I don't think anyone who has any experience of it has the slightest interest in convincing you or anyone else of it's existence. It simply is not possible.
If you don't believe, you can either mutter the same phrases over and over, try for yourself and then decide, or move on.
Those of us who have some experience consider those who choose the first option to be only partially conscious. Both in this reality and the other.
I don't suppose you might have considered "the other" possability on why people are discussing this subject here. Not everyone who believe in something is an evangelist with some rigid set of cannonical laws, perhaps like yourself.
Maybe they are looking for others to compare notes with to enhance their personal experience, and fill out their own personal understaning of their experiences.
Maybe it is you who is trying to "Convert Everyone" to your dogmatic droning of predigested formality.
Is it so brave to always have to keep your eyes tightly shut hiding in the dark from things which may not fit neatly into your belief system, then go running to ask some authority what it is you believe in when you accidentally catch a peek of something untidy?
Just keep your fingers in your ears and keep chanting. There is nothing out there, there is nothing out there, there is nothing out there!
[edit on 28-6-2009 by Cyberbian]
You get a star for your post. LOL. Did you make up that word up,Nuemena?
"Those of us who have some experience consider those who choose the first option to be only partially conscious. Both in this reality and the other."
I know what you mean. I consider 99 percent of the population to be "unconscious". I have had the rare privilege of sitting at the feet of arguably one of the greatest spiritual teachers, Adi Da. See below signature for link.
AD could transmit incredible spiritual energy, even over great distances to His Disciples. I experienced it. But I cant explain it. But it had nothing to do with belief. He literally appeared to be God to His Disciples and His Disciples literally experienced a degree of Oneness with Him while in His Presence.
It certainly would be hard to prove you experienced "Divine Grace" ,even to someone sitting right next to you at the time!!!!!. Astral Projection on the other hand seems to be rather objective. You would simply fly into a sealed room and read some numbers on a peace of paper.
D is G


