It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by TheRedneck
reply to post by crazyewok
reply to post by biggm
Now this is really interesting... two people, both from the UK, both claiming to be offended by the very thought of patriotism, and both exhibiting the most unconditional support of their country as anyone in this entire thread... including the OP!
Close to a full page of patting each other on the back for it too.
I think I am supposed to be offended... if so, I apologize. There are so many social aspects I have yet to fully understand, since they simply do not make logical sense to me. This is one of them. My initial reaction is that I am very glad you are both so patriotic, but a bit confused as to why your patriotism includes disdain for others... or is it just disdain for us?
If the former, then sure, be proud of your country! Be proud of the contributions it has made to society. Of course, you might want to contact a few history authors in the process... the reign of Bloody Mary, the shenanigans of Henry VIII, the abuses of the East India Trading Company which led to the actual employ and political favors to pirates, an attempt at world conquest that saw its doom in the successful revolution of a bunch of upstart, poorly-armed woodsmen who soundly defeated the British military, the collapse of the once-great British Pound Sterling as the International Reserve Currency practically overnight
Just like I am proud of my country! Of course, it would be easier if not for the atrocities of the Civil War, the attempted genocide of the natives, the political maneuvering to maintain our dollar as the International Reserve Currency, the spying on our own people, the abuses of power.
Kinda makes it sound like both countries have their good and their bad when I put it like that. Interesting.
If the latter, then I am truly sorry your country's continued atrocities toward my ancestors forced them to throw your ancestors out (I believe that is the sort of thinly-veiled insult one is expected to put forth; I hope it meets with your approval).
I really should thank both of you for making my original point, which had nothing to do with who stopped slavery first or who gave women equal rights first, or who whipped who in what battle in a long-forgotten and romanticized war... it's about the whether or not the country has contributed to the overall good of mankind. I say the USA has done so... you say sure, but we did it better.
It does not matter who did what better. That wasn't the point; those were examples. Yet, both of you took the opportunity to show unconditional patriotism toward your country while attempting to make fun of my conditional patriotism towards mine, which you both seem to consider extreme.
As I alluded to earlier, I am not the most savvy individual socially... the nuances sometimes simply don't make sense to me. But I am curious by nature, and in an attempt to understand those social nuances, I have spent many years observing humanity. I can see a parallel to your arguments, in the form of young children on a playground."My daddy can beat up your daddy!"
"Can not!"
"Can too!"
"Can not!"
"Can too!"
And this leads me to the conclusion that you are simply exercising a human trait that is apparently not limited to young children. I thank you both for the insight.
Oh, and let me know when you have finished... I would not want to further interrupt your social tradition.
TheRedneck
Pop your dummy back in
I never have said I was offended by patriotism
Originally posted by biggm
Meat heads like you are exactly what is wrong with your country.
never did I say I was patriotic about the UK
never did I say I had distain for the US
you failed to address any point I made regarding George W and France and also failed to address any points regarding the industrial revolution
Originally posted by TheRedneck
reply to post by biggm
Pop your dummy back in
Say what? That has to be something cultural... thanks, I learned a new phrase today.
I never have said I was offended by patriotism
Really?
Originally posted by biggm
Meat heads like you are exactly what is wrong with your country.
That was in response to the OP, where Semper openly espoused his patriotism. Ergo, it appears you think patriots are "meat heats."
Just as I did not recognize your opening phrase, I may be misinterpreting... is "meat head" a term of endearment in the UK?
never did I say I was patriotic about the UK
You don't have to state exact words; your posts taken as a whole indicate such.
One need not use exact wording to convey a thought.
never did I say I had distain for the US
But you certainly seem to have such, again based on the entirety of your posts.
you failed to address any point I made regarding George W and France and also failed to address any points regarding the industrial revolution
What? You want me to defend George W., the one who implemented the Patriot Act? Sorry... can't do that.
As to the Industrial Revolution, there were more patents from American inventors than British inventors, which I will admit is probably due to the discrepancy in size of the two countries. I re-read the posts, and for the life of me it looks like I was extolling the virtues of the United States' good points, crazyewok tried to counter that the UK was superior in all those respects, I pointed out how his arguments were subjective and inaccurate, and you both had your little ceremony of back-patting.
Maybe we have different monitors here.... but that's what mine shows. Can you get a screenshot so we can compare?
TheRedneck
Originally posted by TheRedneck
Kinda makes it sound like both countries have their good and their bad when I put it like that. Interesting.
If the latter, then I am truly sorry your country's continued atrocities toward my ancestors forced them to throw your ancestors out (I believe that is the sort of thinly-veiled insult one is expected to put forth; I hope it meets with your approval).
Originally posted by OneManArmy
Originally posted by TheRedneck
reply to post by biggm
Pop your dummy back in
Say what? That has to be something cultural... thanks, I learned a new phrase today.
I never have said I was offended by patriotism
Really?
Originally posted by biggm
Meat heads like you are exactly what is wrong with your country.
That was in response to the OP, where Semper openly espoused his patriotism. Ergo, it appears you think patriots are "meat heats."
Just as I did not recognize your opening phrase, I may be misinterpreting... is "meat head" a term of endearment in the UK?
never did I say I was patriotic about the UK
You don't have to state exact words; your posts taken as a whole indicate such.
One need not use exact wording to convey a thought.
never did I say I had distain for the US
But you certainly seem to have such, again based on the entirety of your posts.
you failed to address any point I made regarding George W and France and also failed to address any points regarding the industrial revolution
What? You want me to defend George W., the one who implemented the Patriot Act? Sorry... can't do that.
As to the Industrial Revolution, there were more patents from American inventors than British inventors, which I will admit is probably due to the discrepancy in size of the two countries. I re-read the posts, and for the life of me it looks like I was extolling the virtues of the United States' good points, crazyewok tried to counter that the UK was superior in all those respects, I pointed out how his arguments were subjective and inaccurate, and you both had your little ceremony of back-patting.
Maybe we have different monitors here.... but that's what mine shows. Can you get a screenshot so we can compare?
TheRedneck
I am also a brit but I didnt say anything against patriotism, but the OP is nothing about patriotism, firstly to be a patriot you have to first know what patriotism is, and be able to separate that from blind patriotism(nationalism).
crazyewok didnt say the UK was better, he said the uk and usa were about equal in regards to the inventions, but when did this become a penis comparison argument anyway?
No one said a patriot was a meat head, they said the OP was a meat head, as that is exactly what the OP shows. No one else posted a load of misguided tripe, although honourable in intent, its still a load of crap.
Isnt the motto of this site to deny ignorance? Well the OP is brimming with ignorance. Regardless of how noble he thinks he is.
If you cannot see how misguided the words in the OP are then you are as misguided as him.
We are all misguided from time to time, thats why the world is in such a state, all we can to is try to learn from each other and evolve mentally to overcome the ignorance that holds mankind back on so many levels.
Originally posted by crazyewok
Its not patriotism or being proud of ones country thats makeing us laugh.
Its loyalty. Loyalty to the country(Goverment) no matter what. And Loyalty is not what made America. The Loyal ones were the ones fighting you hence the name "loyalist"
Its supporting you troops and cheering them on even when they are clearly being used for wrong. Would you have cheered a redcoat on in 1776?
Its being proud of people that sigh up to the military even though they know they will not be defending there country anymore but be sent to oppress foreign countrys and meddle in anothers wars. Would you have donned a redcoat in 1776? Did you at the start of the war of independance thousands of officers and NCO of the British army either refused to fight or resign because they supported your cause? It why you got to fight againt muppets like Howe and Clinton who basicaly handed you the first half of the war as all out good officers left. Plus made it difficult to get manpower hence all the german mercsThey had moral integrity to know what was right and wrong. Imagine if thousnads of US officers and NCO resigned or refused to fight in Iraq or Afgahnistan? Or left the NSA/CIA? I think that would send a clear message that American say no to Tyranny still.
It those in the militray that will stand guard over a corrupt president, guard a CIA or NSA building or stand watch over America Toture camp (You know the one in Cuba). would you have stood guard for George III? Or a Patriot POW barge?
You say people that dont support the armed forces or join up dont have conviction? Yeah those that sigh up do have conviction. So did those that took the kings shilling in 1776 and those on the other side that signed the declration of independce. So did the Veit Cong and so too do the taliban ven if they are twisted head cases.
But conviction does not nessarly have to come through blind loyalty or fighting.
Conviction were the ones in America that went to prison for refuseing to go to Vietnam due to it being a immoral war. No not the Draft dodgers that ran to Cananda but the brave souls that stayed and said NO!
Conviction is the CIA/NSA/DEA/FBI/Policeman thatquits a good high paying job and informs the public the illegal and unconstitutional acts there goverment is doing.
Conviction are the people that camp outside banks for the corrupt acts they inflected on us.
Conviction is man/Women that refuses to vote for a mainstream politician just because they have nice smile or a bigger campaign budget.
Conviction is the man/women who writes letters and campiagns against there local politican even though they no it wont get them anyway.
Conviction is the Soilder who is sicken on his first tour of Iraq/Afgahanistan and resigns as soon as his enlistment is up in disgust at the wrongs his country is doing.
Conviction is standing in court and contesting one of the immoral, socialy devisive or corrupt laws our goverments have passed even though it may cost us our money and maybe our freedom.
Conviction are those in the concentration camps and Gulags througout history and now in China and North Korea and Even Greece! who refuse to give up there beleifs, religions or politcial ideas even though it will result in beatings or death.
Now I have not had the oppotunity to test MY convictions but they are there and I hope when the time comes they wont falter.
I dont hate Vets BTW, on the contary when I start recruiting soon I will have a eye out for ex engineers.
Originally posted by TheRedneck
Kinda makes it sound like both countries have their good and their bad when I put it like that. Interesting.
If the latter, then I am truly sorry your country's continued atrocities toward my ancestors forced them to throw your ancestors out (I believe that is the sort of thinly-veiled insult one is expected to put forth; I hope it meets with your approval).
Pssst the film The patriot was makeing things up. There were no "atrocities" not in the convential sense. It was just unfair treatmnet of the coloneys like in random taxes and faliure to allow representation. There were no ramapaging redcoats or concentration camps or village massacres, not anymore so than the Patriot side did too.
So another inaccuracy you might want to check uo.edit on 14-8-2013 by crazyewok because: (no reason given)edit on 14-8-2013 by crazyewok because: (no reason given)edit on 14-8-2013 by crazyewok because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by TheRedneck
[, crazyewok tried to counter that the UK was superior in all those respects,
Originally posted by crazyewok
reply to post by OneManArmy
Bravo Sir!
Good show old chapedit on 14-8-2013 by crazyewok because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by crazyewok
Originally posted by TheRedneck
[, crazyewok tried to counter that the UK was superior in all those respects,
Actually no I didnt
I just pointed out some facts and dates you got wrong thats all. Im a amatur hisitorian (doing my 2nd degree in that) and hate wrong history
Originally posted by crazyewok
reply to post by OneManArmy
Its useing a Galaxy tablet (plus a small bit of dylexia). I hate I repeat HATE useing touch pad keyboards
And this site really doesnt come up well on a tablet either its a nightmare to edit or quote.edit on 14-8-2013 by crazyewok because: (no reason given)
Its loyalty. Loyalty to the country(Goverment) no matter what.