It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by blackhatchet
Hypothetical Scenario:
"What if I were to come to the United States and walk around naked in the streets - and when you politely ask me to comply with customs and wear clothes, I then call you a racist?"
"Clearly I can't help being born in No-Clothes Land and it is part of my DNA. You can't discriminate against me, that's not fair! I can't change my nakedness, it's who I am! Why should I learn to wear clothes?!!" /s
[edit on 22-5-2010 by blackhatchet]
Originally posted by Imprtracr1
English IS the language of The United States of America. Thats FACT. Everybody across the globe knows this. To try and debate otherwise is just hanging on to technicalities and red tape. Yes there are other spoken languages brought here from other backgrounds but ALL PEOPLE coming to America SHOULD LEARN AND SPEAK ENGLISH if you are going to be a citizen. Furthermore, it is EXTREMELY RUDE to speak any other language then English in a public setting PERIOD. NO EXCEPTIONS. If your ass is here then ENGLISH is what you should be using. IF you're at home or among your fellow ethnic communities then you can speak your native tongue. OTHERWISE ENGLISH 24/7.
YEAH I SAID IT
Originally posted by beyondsense
reply to post by Vitchilo
So ridiculous this Mclintock fella, "diplomacy", "need to become a U.S. citizen to take part in the debate". When did Bush or Obama or Reagan ever become Irani or Iraqi citizens in order to lecture those countries? The US is the first one to meddle in other countries's businesses. When meddling isn't enough, they just overthrow govts. and put in puppet presidents instead. Calderon has every right to speak as long as the US keeps doing so.
Peace.
Originally posted by Imprtracr1
English IS the language of The United States of America. Thats FACT. Everybody across the globe knows this. To try and debate otherwise is just hanging on to technicalities and red tape. Yes there are other spoken languages brought here from other backgrounds but ALL PEOPLE coming to America SHOULD LEARN AND SPEAK ENGLISH if you are going to be a citizen. Furthermore, it is EXTREMELY RUDE to speak any other language then English in a public setting PERIOD. NO EXCEPTIONS. If your ass is here then ENGLISH is what you should be using. IF you're at home or among your fellow ethnic communities then you can speak your native tongue. OTHERWISE ENGLISH 24/7.
YEAH I SAID IT
Don't fall for such obvious games of politics.
The People of Mexico do not care what you do with your laws. Not one bit!
Originally posted by JakiusFogg
This is ridiculous. All this tooing and froing about English is the only languiage in the USA, no you can speak whatever you want, its the law, no its not.
One of the posters here already cited evidence that there is no law to state that English is the official language of the US.
But in the same time it is hard for a country to function well in a bi lingual society without the full agreement and cooperation of society and the social framework.
Look at
Belgium, Flemish and French
Singapore, English/Malay/Mandarin
India, English/Hindu
Holland, Dutch/English
Canada, English/French
All these countries and more have successfully recognised that they have a dual language history and have area of demarkation for it.
Should it not be hightime that the USA, recognised officially that a vast area of its territory from Florida to Californa, traditionally are areas of majority Spanish speaking. That the nation rose from the same situation as that of Canada. An amalgamation of colonial states arising from the clash of two empire. The British and the Spanish. Therefore it should only be right that the USA adopts Spanish as one of it's "official" languages. Without which you are ostracizing a large proportion of it's LEGAL community!.
By the way, I walked into t a 7.11 in Miami and ordered a pack of smokes in Spanish!!
There is no need to get angry about it. Even in the home of the English language, we have 2 official languages (and several recognised) English and Welsh. ( plus Urdu and Hindi are well signposted (as well as Polish))