It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
What are Regulations?
There are three types of law which prevail at the federal, state, and local levels of government in the United States: Statutory Law, Case (or Judicial Law) , and Regulations (or Administrative Law). Regulations are written by executive agencies to establish the rules and detailed procedures needed to administer the statutory laws passed by Congress and signed by the President.
Does revolutionary Spain show that libertarian socialism can work in practice?
Yes. As Murray Bookchin puts it, "n Spain, millions of people took large segments of the economy into their own hands, collectivised them, administered them, even abolished money and lived by communistic principles of work and distribution -- all of this in the midst of a terrible civil war, yet without producing the chaos or even the serious dislocations that were and still are predicted by authoritarian 'radicals.' Indeed, in many collectivised areas, the efficiency with which an enterprise worked by far exceeded that of a comparable one in nationalised or private sectors. This 'green shoot' of revolutionary reality has more meaning for us than the most persuasive theoretical arguments to the contrary. On this score it is not the anarchists who are the 'unrealistic day-dreamers,' but their opponents who have turned their backs to the facts or have shamelessly concealed them." ["Introductory Essay," in The Anarchist Collectives, Sam Dolgoff (ed.), p. xxxix]
The Makhnovist movement was one of the most important events of the Russian Revolution. It was a mass movement of working people who tried and succeeded to implement libertarian ideas in extremely difficult circumstances.
As such, the most important lesson gained from the experience of the Makhno movement is simply that "objective factors" cannot and do not explain the degeneration of the Russian Revolution or Bolshevik authoritarianism. Here was a movement which faced the same terrible circumstances as the Bolsheviks faced (White counter-revolution, economic disruption, and so on) and yet did not act in the same manner as the Bolsheviks. Where the Bolsheviks completely abolished army democracy, the Makhnovists extensively applied it. Where the Bolsheviks implemented party dictatorship over the soviets, the Makhnovists encouraged and practised soviet self-management. While the Bolsheviks eliminated freedom of speech, press, assembly, the Makhnovists defended and implemented them. The list is endless
Originally posted by earthdude I would be a Libertarian but the ranks are full of complete nut cases. I lean left but some of the Libertarians fall over into the extreem right.
Originally posted by lastzoroastrianleft
Canada boy is argueing that manipulation has lead freedom to our current state of crisis. So your saying that we should MANIPULATE EVERYONE INTO THINKING ONE WAY, and THATS HOW WE SOLVE THE GOD DAMN PROBLEM!!!! How does that EVEN make sense? YOU (For(Home)Country) ARE A HYPOCRITE!
[edit on 17-5-2010 by lastzoroastrianleft]
Originally posted by endisnighe
reply to post by For(Home)Country
I once wrote a paper in Bio 4 in high school on juvenile diabetes and the field at the time. Biology 1 was mandatory all the other were elective. I was going to become a doctor but did not follow that dream.
I received an A. I used the same paper in college. Received an A. My sister went to college to become a nurse and also some 2 year course on some psychological thinga majig. She used my paper and got an A. Shhh.
That being said, does not mean I am a doctor.
Or should force MY views on someone else. Just as no company or government or individual should force any system of control on another individual.
Good sir, I am sorry if I have offended you. However, your anger seems to contradict what you preach. Although you preach freedom, you condemn me because I do not agree with you. Sounds ironic, does it not?
You seem to fail to properly estimate the ability of large corporations to manipulate the populace and government. People, in today's western culture, are born and educated to consume and get what they want. If they don't, they whine until it comes true. In turn, we see politicians with similar ideology.
If you knew anything about communism and Marxism, you would realize that it was a solution to freedom from oppression experienced by the proletariat due to the bourgeois.
If you wish to intelligently discuss this, please continue to do so. However, your seemingly immature words and argument fail to properly represent your views. Also, if you are interested in a lengthy read, I can provide you with a University paper I have written explaining why the Communist Manifesto provides a more solid platform for freedom as opposed to John Stuart Mill's ideas presented in his essay On Liberty. (It got an A)
Also, I would like to believe that a large, notable Canadian University (with a large bureaucracy put in place to combat plagiarism mind you) would be slightly more, dare I say, Academic than a standard American college and have higher standards.
Originally posted by Pappie54
reply to post by Jean Paul Zodeaux
Boy from look and volume of your post, you don't have a life beyond ATS do you? Frankly, you come off as a Mr. Know-it-all but it is only your opinion. I disagree with your views of what works and what does not. When someone spouts such self proclaimed knowledge, I see it as opinion lacking wisdom and insight. If you were truly an extremely smart individual, you wouldn't spend so much time here trying to influence ATS members. You would have smart things to be doing in the real world if your knowledge and education were of real unique value. Get over yourself, yours is just a perspective. You are trying too hard to be a guru.
Originally posted by endisnighe
reply to post by earthdude
Here was your quote that hawiye was responding to.
Originally posted by earthdude I would be a Libertarian but the ranks are full of complete nut cases. I lean left but some of the Libertarians fall over into the extreem right.
Ignorant means lacking knowledge. It is not a disparagement.
Ignorance is not bliss. Information is power. Spread the power.