It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by sirnex
reply to post by v01i0
True, I can't necessarily speak for the whole of humanity, but I figure we're all alike enough that this should be a trait achievable by anyone regardless of gender, race, color, or belief..
I mean, is the effect only realizable by those who strongly believe or create enough of a positive/negative thought towards the changes in the PH level of the water? If say, negative thoughts bring about certain PH imbalances that can be construed as having been caused by negative thoughts, then should I not have at least had a 'positive' result in that regard?
Explain the logic in asserting that if science has yet to demonstrate something, it must not exist?
Originally posted by Witness2008
Obviously the chemical triggers the electrical signal.
Originally posted by bsbray11
reply to post by v01i0
It's ok if you don't believe in this stuff. But an opinion isn't a fact. That's where you are all getting tripped up.
Originally posted by sirnex
Do you have to 'believe in it' in order for it to 'work'?
Originally posted by bsbray11
reply to post by v01i0
I am up all for a logical debate,
Originally posted by bsbray11
reply to post by v01i0
Critical examination went out the window as soon as sirnex started relying only on logical fallacies to make his case against work he has never even seen before and has made it clear that he does not understand.
Only direct personal experience is a fact!
If one day I wake up in astral and then can subjectively experience it, then I am ready to admit the existence of astral plane as you understand it. But I think that sirnex had a point when said:
I was here to inquire, but it is impossible with the attitude where people have pre-existent beliefs about the matter.
Well, sometimes there are decent conversations when people are willing to actually look upon the phenomenons, not just pushing and justifying their own beliefs.
Yet according to my own experiences and experiments, astral travel is more like psychological game, perhaps misinterpreting the capabilities of human psyche.
Originally posted by sirnex
reply to post by v01i0
Only direct personal experience is a fact!
That's a cop-out BS answer if you ask me. So all these various religions and personal experiences for everything under the sun that are in direct contradiction of each other are all fact solely because they were personally experienced?
You must forgive my manner to rely only on personal experience - without it, subjectively it can as well categorized as belief. You can do all the 'scientific' experiments you want yet still I won't be taking your word for it. I must do same tests myself in order to validate it as a fact.
You see, it was only few hundred years ago when religious priesthood were the definers of truth and fact - today we (well not me) tend to give that authority to the 'science'. In my opinion, it not any better. We have had many kind of scientific facts later to be proven BS.
I only rely on personal experiences and my own reasoning - I don't require it from you tho. You can believe in whatever presumptions you like but don't expect me to enter in debate with you.
I know that many people will give me remarks of stubbornness or even ignorance by not believing in established science. It must've been so with those that were not believing in whatever explanation the church gave few centuries back. I must say I have nothing against scientific methodology itself, but I am all against in believing in whatever has been scientifically proven, without better personal knowledge.
I know I am bad person to debate with as I often outwardly cast aside scientific research what other people try to present as evidence for their beliefs. But as said, believing in science is no better than believing in some religion - they both are dogmas and authorities that tend to bend masses on their side in order to fortify their unquestionable authority.
Originally posted by v01i0
Well, first of all - I don't believe in anything. Opinion isn't fact, that is true - but nor are facts the researches and stories of others. Only direct personal experience is a fact!
I was here to inquire, but it is impossible with the attitude where people have pre-existent beliefs about the matter.
It is really the same situation where atheist and believer are having debate
Go on and blame other people when they don't suck up in your opinions.
Yet according to my own experiences and experiments, astral travel is more like psychological game, perhaps misinterpreting the capabilities of human psyche.
Originally posted by bsbray11
Regardless of your cerebral analysis of the phenomena, are you looking in from the outside, or have you had lucid dreams/astral projections before?
Originally posted by v01i0
reply to post by Witness2008
It seems that my psyche is constructed in a way that I cannot enter these realms of astral, may them be objective or subjective realities - I have no idea. Because I cannot, I feel inclined to suspect the authenticity of whole phenomena, yet I cannot say for sure...
Originally posted by bsbray11
You said you were inquisitive. You come here and you get two sides of a debate. What's the problem man? This stuff is very easy to try for yourself.
Originally posted by bsbray11
I recommend to start off listening to guided body relaxation meditations either in the morning after you wake up, or at night before you fall asleep. I have a CD player with headphones next to my pillow, and I just lay there on my back and do this. This will get you used to becoming relaxed, and releasing tension all throughout your body. I can link you to good meditations for this. They will generally start at your feet... a very calm and soothing (though alert..) female voice guiding you through this.. tensing and then relaxing your feet... calves.. knees... thighs.. on up until your jaw, your cheeks, relax your scalp... and after some practice with this, you will begin to feel like a huge chunk of lead laying against the bed/floor/couch/whatever. You can feel your weight against whatever is holding you up. Your body literally goes to sleep, a feeling almost as though blood has been cut off (you know, the "tingly" kind of "asleep," but without the "tingles") but in reality it's only your awareness that has been affected.
Originally posted by bsbray11
Astral Projection is going into deep inner spaces when in meditation.
Originally posted by v01i0
What do you mean by inner spaces? Your personal (sub)consciousness? Or some objective reality that penetrate physical reality?