Absolute, Irrefutable Evidence of a Creator, page 2

Originally posted by theyreadmymind
reply to post by InTrueFiction

Sorry, but I think I did understand you. You said the problem with my argument is the aliens would have to have either have always existed or have evolved. Your argument seems to revolve around either getting to the end of a debate or continuing discussions. You did in a previous post say aliens aren't a viable third option because it would hinder our discussions. So what is wrong with saying it's a possibility but until we find those elusive aliens and do scientific studies on their origins, we may never get to the bottom of it? Please tell me your only argument is not that the debate will never end. Because if indeed aliens did create us then the debate should never end until we come to that conclusion. I understand I am taking the difficult task of arguing for something in which there is virtually no evidence for and probably is a remote possibility. That is unfortunate for me, but even if it's a very small possibility, it shouldn't be thrown out of the argument until there's no possibility.

In any event, if you don't want to continue the discussion I will happily bow out.

[edit on 5-9-2009 by theyreadmymind]

My point is that whether you are talking about the creation of the universe and life by a God or by aliens you're still talking about a creator and therefore creationism.

So in the thread's discussion (this one and many others out there) that propose the possibility of creationism versus the more spontaneous system proposed by evolutionism, to bring in aliens as the creator is still a defence of creationism - of the universe and life having been created by a higher conscious entity.

That is why I think that appointing aliens as the creators of life instead of a God does not propose a viable third option to the concept of Creationism vs Evolution because either:

1- You're still talking about creationism you're just disputing the word "God" but just the word itself. Because in my opinion if you are talking about higher entities that are superior and eternal enough to not only surpass a hypothetical creation of existence but even be responsible for it you are talking about the very same thing that people throughout the ages have called God you're just using the word "aliens" instead.

2- You're not talking about aliens as a higher entity responsible for the creation of it all but about another race of living creatures that have achieved the power and knowledge to create life themselves - which does not discount evolution.

As for your questions of truth etc. who knows?

It is a debate - a sharing of opinions regarding a very old question that is "Where did it all begin?" There are two general theories:

Creationism - 1. everything was created by a higher entity (call it God or aliens or whatever you wish)

Evolution - 2. it all just happened without anyone or anything being responsible for it or creating it.

And then there's my option which is that existence isn't a creation but a constant and so there is no beginning, no end, just eternal change.

You can donate to my religion at... (j/k)

[edit on 5-9-2009 by InTrueFiction]

[edit on 5-9-2009 by InTrueFiction]