Due to recent current events I have seen a line something like this repeated in many threads:
"Six Million Jews died in the Holocaust and no one did anything to stop it!
Beyond the number of deaths(and I know even that is disputed here) This statement is historically inaccurate in many ways.
Let me clear some things up, ATS. There is no need to cling to this ignorance and besides, as I've said, I take personal offence to this statement.
At the time of WWII one half of my family was busy getting their keisters out of Germany so they wouldn't be among the 6 million, and the other half
was busy fighting the Nazis or supporting that war effort.
1. It was not only Jews who were killed in the Holocaust:
Of the 11 million people killed during the Holocaust, six million were Polish citizens. Three million were Polish Jews and another three million
were Polish Christians and Catholics. Most of the remaining mortal victims were from other countries including Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Ukraine,
Russia, Holland, France and even Germany.
www.holocaustforgotten.com...
Romani (commonly but incorrectly called Gypsies) were considered by the Nazis to be social outcasts. Under the Weimar Republic--the German
government from 1918 to 1933--anti-Romani laws became widespread. These laws required them to register with officials, prohibited them from traveling
freely, and sent them to forced-labor camps. When the Nazis came to power, those laws remained in effect--and were expanded. Under the July 1933
sterilization law, many Romani were sterilized against their will.
In November 1933, the "Law Against Dangerous Habitual Criminals" was passed. Under this law, the police began arresting Romani along with others
labeled "asocial." Beggars, vagrants, the homeless, and alcoholics were arrested and sent to concentration camps.
fcit.usf.edu...
If you must persist with the "We owe Jews a homland and special protection because of the Holocaust," please keep this in mind.
Why don't we spent so much time and money looking out for Poland?
Why aren't we also fighting for a Roma homeland?
I am truly appaled at what happened during the Holocaust but that isn't an excuse to baby a foreign country. Sorry, this is the real world, if you
can't hack it as a country, you aren't going to make it long. if Israel wants to be babied by the US, they should apply for statehood.
I am especially appaled that this protection of a potential holocaust in Israel often comes while we are turning a blind eye to ongoing genocide, such
as in Darfur.
2. There was an active resistance movement fighting the Nazis.
Just a taste:
For two years, from 1939 to the summer of 1941, the resistance movements of Europe had found it hard to make much of an impression on the might of
the German military. However, they had been useful in gathering intelligence for the Allies. The devastating Blitzkrieg attacks of 1939 to 1941,
taking in Poland, Norway, Western Europe and Russia had given little time for each country to prepare any semblance of a secret army to undermine the
invaders. Reports from commanders in the field to the German Army’s headquarters (OKW), indicate that the resistance movements were an irritant but
no more than this. The savage repression of local populations usually did enough to put people off of joining any local resistance force.
www.historylearningsite.co.uk...
This page has many more articles:
www.experiencefestival.com...
3. At the time most governments were not in a position to fight the Nazis, or did not know what was happening.
This really shouldn't need elaboration, but I'll go at it anyway:
Remember that in the 1920s and 30s, most of Europe was absolutely
devestated by fighting in WWI. Specifically, the countries who had lost that
war. Their efforts to reconstruct their own countries were hindered by occupation and demands to pay reparitions for WWI. Combine that with loss of
life, famine in some places, and staggering inflation.
Ask yourself, beyond individual participation, what were these countries supposed to do? They were not allowed to raise up an army to invade to stop
the Nazis. Even if they were, the money that went into that would have been sucked up for reparitions. Even if that wasn't true, where were they
supposed to get the manpower for this army when they had just lost WWI, and the rescources when they could marely keep from starving already?
Combine that with the fact that at the time, technology was not as advanced, and it was much easier to conceal a Holocaust-scale opparation. Remember,
the Nazis were masters of manipulating information.
As far as US involvement goes, well, that is a whole other convaluted story. We did not even get involved until we we declared war on Japan and were
then fighting Germany and Italy by proxy. I do beleive t here was some ultieror motive there, but that's another story.
4. There were many individual people helping the Jews.
Here's just part of a Wiki list:
* Per Anger, Swedish diplomat in Budapest who originated the idea of issuing provisional passports to Hungarian Jews to protect them from
arrest and deportation. Anger collaborated with Raoul Wallenberg to save the lives of thousands of Jews.
* Władysław Bartoszewski - Polish Żegota activist.
* Count Folke Bernadotte of Wisborg - Swedish diplomat, who negotiated the release of 27,000 people (a significant number of which were Jews) to
hospitals in Sweden.
* Jacob (Jack) Benardout - British diplomat to Dominican Republic before and during World War Two. Issued numerous Dominican Republic visas to
Jews in Germany. Only 16 Jewish families arrived in the Dominican Republic (the other Jews dispersed into countries along the way e.g. Britain,
America) and so created the Jewish community of The Dominican Republic
* Hiram Bingham IV, American Vice Consul in Marseilles, France 1940-1941.
* José Castellanos Contreras - a Salvadoran army colonel and diplomat who, while working as El Salvador's Consul General for Geneva from
1942-45, and in conjunction with George Mantello, helped save at least 13,000 Central European Jews from Nazi persecution by providing them with false
papers of Salvadoran nationality.
* Georg Ferdinand Duckwitz, German diplomatic attaché in Denmark. Alerted Danish politician Hans Hedtoft about the imminent German plans deport
to Denmark's Jewish community, thus enabling the following rescue of the Danish Jews.
* Frank Foley - British MI6 agent undercover as a passport officer in Berlin, saved around 10,000 people by issuing forged passports to Britain
and the British Mandate of Palestine.
* Varian Fry - American journalist who saved 2,000 - 4,000 Jews, including many prominent artists and intellectuals.
* Albert Göring - German businessman (and younger brother of leading Nazi Hermann Göring) who helped Jews and dissidents survive in Germany
* Paul Grüninger - Swiss commander of police who provided falsely dated papers to over 3,000 refugees so they could escape Austria following the
Anschluss.
* Kiichiro Higuchi - lieutenant general in the Imperial Japanese Army
* Wilm Hosenfeld - German officer who helped pianist Wladyslaw Szpilman, a Polish Jew, among many others.
* Prince Constantin Karadja - Romanian diplomat, who saved over 51,000 Jews from deportation and extermination, as credited by Yad Vashem in
2005.[18]
* Jan Karski - Polish emissary of Armia Krajowa to Western Allies and eye-witness of the Holocaust.
* Necdet Kent - Turkish Consul General at Marseille, who granted Turkish citizenship to hundreds of Jews. At one point he entered an
Auschwitz-bound train at enormous personal risk to save 70 Jews, to whom he had granted Turkish citizenship, from deportation.
* Zofia Kossak-Szczucka - Polish founder of Zegota.
* Carl Lutz - Swiss consul in Budapest, managed to provide safe-conducts for emigration to Palestine to many thousands of Hungarian Jews.
* Luis Martins de Souza Dantas - Brazilian in charge of the Brazilian diplomatic mission in France. He granted Brazilian visas to several Jews and
other minorities persecuted by the Nazis. He was proclaimed as Righteous among the Nations in 2003.[19]
* George Mantello (b. George Mandl) - El Salvador's honorary consul for Hungary, Romania, and Czechoslovakia - provided fictive Salvadoran
citizenship papers for thousands of Jews and spearheaded a publicity campaign that eventually ended the deportation of Jews from Hungary to
Auschwitz.[20][21]
* Paul V. McNutt - United States High Commissioner of the Philippines, 1937-1939, who facilitated the entry of Jewish refugees into the
Philippines.[22]
* Helmuth James Graf von Moltke - adviser to the Third Reich on international law; active in Kreisau Circle resistance group, sent Jews to safe
haven countries.
* Delia Murphy - wife of Dr. Thomas J. Kiernan, Irish minister in Rome 1941-1946, who worked with Hugh O'Flaherty and was part of the network
that saved the lives POWs and Jews from the hands of the Gestapo.[23]
* Giovanni Palatucci - Italian police official who saved several thousand.
* Giorgio Perlasca - Italian. When Ángel Sanz Briz was ordered to leave Hungary, he falsely claimed to be his substitute and continued saving
some thousands more Jews.
Check out the article, it lists more people, and entire countries.
en.wikipedia.org...
Please keep this info in mind.