Originally posted by SpookyVince
Maybe not a government agency, but it is quite obviously subject to some government rules, regulations, and controls. When specifically those members
are deleted, one is in right to ask "why them, and not others who are as much as them, if not more, 'illegal'? What was illegal in posting those
videos? How was it a TOS violation? Why not simply remove the movie, instead of the whole account?"
Besides, let me insist that it is the US constitution. That one that is supposed to be governing "the country of freedom"... What a big joke! Maybe
it ought to be burned and rewritten in a way that fits nowadays world, and not the late XVIIIth century!
spooky.. do you even know what you are talking about?
I did not go on about the right to ask.. everyone can ask, that is not what I was bitchin about...
Do you know the difference between a company and a government?
A company is "at will", a government is "by law".
YouTube is NOT subject to the constitution in this way.
They have NO obligation to uphold your personal free speech.
NONE.
Removal of your videos, your comments or your account from YouTube by Google in NO WAY is a violation of your free speech as guaranteed under the
constitution of the United States.
Please... cite me something that proves me wrong here and I will gladly all you my master.
This is why I posted this, there are TOO MANY Of us here who cannot differentiate between the two.
I am not defending YouTube.. I am trying to educate some of you.
ATS reserves the right to delete comments, partial comments, threads, or even GASP! accounts that they see fit.. it is NOT a free speech violation.
Can some MOD please back me up on this.. we need at least to have a starting point for discussions like this, there are to many people who are just
misinformed.
[edit on 3-11-2008 by gormly]