reply to post by brill
"Hey Man, Nice Shot" was about R. Budd Dwyer's suicide (see references in popular culture section
here). If you want a non-wikipedia source, try
this Rolling Stone article. It has nothing
to do with murder or, if you prefer, supposedly righteous slayings. Richard Patrick (lead singer of Filter) has made this pretty clear.
***
As for Joe Horn, I don't believe that his brand of punishment fit the crime. He did not *have* to shoot those guys -- he wanted to shoot them. His
actions infer that he values property over life, which I find myopic. Those guys will never have a chance to reform or make amends for their actions.
They will never have the opportunity to learn from their mistakes. I realize that it is speculative to suggest that they ever would have learned a
lesson, but it is just as speculative to suggest that they would not have.
To be very clear here, I'm not defending the criminals or their
actions, but neither will I defend Joe Horn. He removed that possibility for two men who had technically done no harm to him. I'm all for
personal/home defense and for killing to protect family and self in the face of immediate danger. I do not believe that killing for the sake of a
neighbor's property is anything other than the satisfaction of one's own bloodlust.
/tn.
[edit on 6-4-2008 by teleonaut]