It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by whirlwind
Madness....time itself changed because of His life here on earth. The first prophecy of the Bible, Gen. 3:15 is about Christ and part of that prophecy came to pass 2,000 years ago. The other half will happen soon.
Do you believe that His disciples could have started a movement that Christianity has grown into if he was just a myth?
He was and is very real. As far as "proof" that He lived - can you "prove" that Socrates or Plato were real?
Were the Pharoah's of Egypt real? Yes they had books written about their sayings or carvings imprinted on walls but Can You Prove they were real?
Christ also had a book that has stood the test of time written about Him and it shows how Divinely inspired it is.
The argument you put forth of needing to prove His existence is silly. How can you even prove your great great grandfather was real?
Mythology is a convoluted, confusing mess (to me). If one wants to study it that is terrific but to compare it to reality, to history, to what the very existence of our souls depends on is a non-sequiter. There is no comparison.
If it is one's religion then it is misplaced. Also, Christianity is not religion but rather a way of life.
That isn't true. Consider this....Cain, when thrown out of the garden, Cain knew his wife; and she conceived, and bare Enoch; and he builded a city, and called the name of the city, after the name of his son, Enoch.
What was that city? Could it have been Babylon where all the mythology came from? Babylon just means bable, confusion and that is what mythology is. A corruption of the creation story and who better to corrupt it then the one thrown out.
WW - You will find what appear to some to be inconsistencies in God's Word but often, after deeper study, discover that they are not at all.
Madness -
you know... there are outright contradictions.
like.. the last words of jesus
or... the death of judas.
and then there are far more complex theological contradictions... like the contradiction over whether or not there is an unforgivable sin.
I'll take your last one first. There is an unforgiveable sin but it can only be committed by one of God's Elect. At the end of days His elect will stand before Satan who has come to earth pretending to be Christ - and he will fool many who don't know the truth. The sin is in not allowing the Holy Spirit to speak through you.
Luke 12:10 And whosoever shall speak a word against the Son of man, it shall be forgiven him: but unto him that blasphemeth against the Holy Ghost it shall not be forgiven.
11.And when they bring you unto the synagogues, and unto magistrates, and powers, take ye no thought how or what thing ye shall answer, or what ye shall say:
12.For the Holy Ghost shall teach you in the same hour what ye ought to say.
As far as the "last words of Jesus or death of Judas" being contraditions please be more explicit. What do you mean?
Originally posted by whirlwind
Time itself changed because of His life here on earth. The first prophecy of the Bible, Gen. 3:15 is about Christ and part of that prophecy came to pass 2,000 years ago. The other half will happen soon.
Madness -
again, no evidence that jesus existed presented.....your argument is fallacious.
He was and is very real. As far as "proof" that He lived - can you "prove" that Socrates or Plato were real?
Madness -
yes, yes i can. plato wrote of socrates.. while socrates was alive.
plato also wrote stuff...
both of them have contemporaries that criticized them.
WW - Were the Pharoah's of Egypt real? Yes they had books written about their sayings or carvings imprinted on walls but Can You Prove they were real?
Madness -
yes, we actually have the body of one of them...
we have thousands of statues of them that were carved during their lifetimes...
Christ also had a book that has stood the test of time written about Him and it shows how Divinely inspired it is.
Madness -
ok, now we're really really ridiculously off topic...
The argument you put forth of needing to prove His existence is silly. How can you even prove your great great grandfather was real?
Madness -
genetics.
Mythology is a convoluted, confusing mess (to me). If one wants to study it that is terrific but to compare it to reality, to history, to what the very existence of our souls depends on is a non-sequiter. There is no comparison.
Madness -
to say that your mythology isn't silly while the others are is silly. you're refusing to make a realistic assessment of the situation by placing your personal myths on a level above the others.
If it is one's religion then it is misplaced. Also, Christianity is not religion but rather a way of life.
Madness -
you just proved the point i just made...
it IS religion. it is inherently theistic. even non-theistic religions exist...
but you follow a religion.
That isn't true. Consider this....Cain, when thrown out of the garden, Cain knew his wife; and she conceived, and bare Enoch; and he builded a city, and called the name of the city, after the name of his son, Enoch.
What was that city? Could it have been Babylon where all the mythology came from? Babylon just means bable, confusion and that is what mythology is. A corruption of the creation story and who better to corrupt it then the one thrown out.
Madness -
wow... you throw out the bible as a source for why the other religions are wrong... the circles this leads to dizzy me.
I'll take your last one first. There is an unforgiveable sin but it can only be committed by one of God's Elect. At the end of days His elect will stand before Satan who has come to earth pretending to be Christ - and he will fool many who don't know the truth. The sin is in not allowing the Holy Spirit to speak through you.
Madness -
oh, yes, another contradiction there... is there free will or predestination..
Luke 12:10 And whosoever shall speak a word against the Son of man, it shall be forgiven him: but unto him that blasphemeth against the Holy Ghost it shall not be forgiven.
11.And when they bring you unto the synagogues, and unto magistrates, and powers, take ye no thought how or what thing ye shall answer, or what ye shall say:
12.For the Holy Ghost shall teach you in the same hour what ye ought to say.
Madness -
read this in its context and you'll see it has absolutely nothing to do with the situation you presented.
As far as the "last words of Jesus or death of Judas" being contraditions please be more explicit. What do you mean?
Originally posted by whirlwind
I'm sorry you believe that.
To use your same reasoning...That is no evidence, anyone could have written that. Your argument is fallacious.
That is no evidence, anyone could have written them, anyone could have their picture carved on a wall, how do you know that is his body, how do you know the statutes are of them. Go ahead - Prove it !!!
No, it isn't. That is what we are discussing.
Genetics to whom. How do I know you are genetically related to the man you believe was your great great grandfather? Go ahead - Prove it!!!
I know my beliefs aren't silly or myths and they are far above mythology.
I follow Christ, not a man-made religion and you may call it whatever you wish.
There are many things you don't understand Madness because of how you approach God's Word. I know, because I was there before.
There is both. God's elect are predestined -
Those of free will are not. They must make the choice. God can and does involve Himself in the lives of the Elect but He will not do that to one of free will unless they ask.
It has to do with the unpardonable sin. That was our topic of discussion.
Thank you for your answer on this question Madness but I'll have to postphone it until later this afternoon.
...we have other people talking about them as well..during their lives. we have not a single source that speaks of jesus until decades after his death
WW - That is no evidence, anyone could have written them, anyone could have their picture carved on a wall, how do you know that is his body, how do you know the statutes are of them. Go ahead - Prove it !!!
Madness -
you're just playing a stupid semantics game here. it's just outright stupid to question the historical validity of the rulers of egypt... or socrates and his student plato....we know it's his body because we found it in his tomb surrounded by his stuff... you're just acting immature here.
WW - There is both. God's elect are predestined -
Madness -
can't be. you cannot have both free will and a predestined future. again, you can't have it both ways. some people not having free will and some having it. it's just a silly rationalization
It has to do with the unpardonable sin. That was our topic of discussion.
Madness -
yes, but read why jesus said it... he said it because people didn't much like him...
Originally posted by whirlwind
So...He is all a great, big, fabricated lie. Steven was stoned to death for following a lie, Peter was crucified upside down for following a lie, men dedicated their lives to following a lie???
Other people taked about Christ too. Why do you believe He wasn't spoken about for decades after His death?
That is my point. All of your arguments can be applied to everyone in ancient history. If you choose not to believe that He is real that is your choice but to say He wasn't on earth is a "stupid semantics game, outright stupid and you're just acting immature and arrogant".
We can and do. It isn't a rationalization at all but truth. There are reasons for it but you don't seem to be in the frame of mind for hearing truth at that depth yet.
The ones that didn't like Him were the scribes, Pharisees and holy joe's down at the temple.
That "same hour" is reference to the "hour of temptation" of Rev. 3:10.
The Death Of Judas:
Originally posted by JesusisTruth
Please dont bother with this man madness.
He denies everything to further his rebeliion nomatter the miracles or proof.
" Like the toothfairy "
Yea. The toothfairy and speghetti monster have not workded 2000 years of miracles, and created many prophets and apostles, nor did it creat us.
I have seen these miracles in my life. And his grace work in my life.
But will you even give the miracles a chance? The saints are too decent and faultless about what they have seen, they are greater than I, and I would not lie about what ive seen.
Sincere people give stuff a chance. But there is a type of people that have to deny everything, because they are not sincere and dont want proof.
and if proof is given they know they would have to give up sin and put themselves below a creator.
anybody who sees you post madness should realize you lack sincerity. Your not trying to understand anybody.
Now.
Judas died one way, what bible do you have?
" dude "
Hes a soul of God not a dude.
You see what made me say that?
Gods grace, which gives me love for strangers, and is the only one who follows our lives throughout bith till we die loving and watching like a mother./
Im telling you guys now, this conversation will go nowhere but circles.
Originally posted by whirlwind
So...He is all a great, big, fabricated lie. Steven was stoned to death for following a lie, Peter was crucified upside down for following a lie, men dedicated their lives to following a lie???
Madness -
wouldn't be the first or last time that people died for something that wasn't true.
Other people talked about Christ too. Why do you believe He wasn't spoken about for decades after His death?
Madness -
because the first mention of jesus in any piece of writing is by paul in one of his letters.
That is my point. All of your arguments can be applied to everyone in ancient history. If you choose not to believe that He is real that is your choice but to say He wasn't on earth is a "stupid semantics game, outright
stupid and you're just acting immature and arrogant".
Madness -
no, not at all. you're comparing stuff that has mountains of evidence to a guy that is mentioned only decades after his death in mythological text...
you're comparing apples and tow-trucks here.
normally i've heard this argument from others, but they use something like caesar...the simple fact is that you don't have any reliable evidence to show that your mythological messiah figure existed.
We can and do. It isn't a rationalization at all but truth. There are reasons for it but you don't seem to be in the frame of mind for hearing truth at that depth yet.
Madness -
^translation "i know something you CAN'T know"....there isn't a frame of mind for hearing the truth, the truth is something that rings true to all people in all mindsets.
The ones that didn't like Him were the scribes, Pharisees and holy joe's down at the temple.
Madness -
yep, that's how the story goes.
That "same hour" is reference to the "hour of temptation" of Rev. 3:10.
Madness -
it's a reference to something that wasn't written yet....
yeah, that makes complete sense.
The Death Of Judas:....again, you're rationalizing. nowhere does it say judas bought anything, you're adding your own stuff. throwing money down to buying a field is quite a leap...now... can we get back on topic?
"But they were disobedient and rebelled against you; they put your law behind their backs. They killed your prophets, who had admonished them in order to turn them back to you; they committed awful blasphemies.
Has a nation ever changed its gods?
(Yet they are not gods at all.)
But my people have exchanged their [d] Glory
for worthless idols.
Be appalled at this, O heavens,
and shudder with great horror,"
declares the LORD.
"My people have committed two sins:
They have forsaken me,
the spring of living water,
and have dug their own cisterns,
broken cisterns that cannot hold water.
Is Israel a servant, a slave by birth?
Why then has he become plunder?
Originally posted by junglejake
There's more evidence for Christ than Julius Caesar, so I guess we should just throw out all of history and assume the world began about 50 years ago.
Bigotry, you say, while quoting a Jew stating Jews are going in the wrong direction. Is this bigotry? It is referring to the Jews:
"But they were disobedient and rebelled against you; they put your law behind their backs. They killed your prophets, who had admonished them in order to turn them back to you; they committed awful blasphemies.
or this:
Has a nation ever changed its gods?
(Yet they are not gods at all.)
But my people have exchanged their [d] Glory
for worthless idols.
Be appalled at this, O heavens,
and shudder with great horror,"
declares the LORD.
"My people have committed two sins:
They have forsaken me,
the spring of living water,
and have dug their own cisterns,
broken cisterns that cannot hold water.
Is Israel a servant, a slave by birth?
Why then has he become plunder?
So what constitutes bigotry? Christianity, the Bible, was not seen as anything separate from Judaism until Paul was in Antioch. It was a sect of Judaism, and, in many ways, still is. There are those that believe their messiah has come, and those that believe He has not.
To take individual passages critical of the Jewish leadership at the time and say it is evidence of bigotry requires that you not be familiar with the books of the Prophets that are part of Jewish canon that do exactly the same thing.
Anti-Jewish? Hardly. Why, then, would it be written that the good news, the news about the messiah, is to be preached to the Jew first, then the Gentile, and that the Jew is closer to God and has a place that no Gentile could ever attain (the first is verbatim, the second requires more interpretation)?
listen, we're really off topic.... and i think you should realize that. you've threadjacked this in an attempt to avoid the real issue, that there is bigotry in scripture.
now, i'll quickly address your points:
you have no historical evidence for jesus or the 13 apostles
the argument that i provide doesn't stand up to other historical figures whose existence is proven... i already showed that with your attempt at saying "you can't prove socrates and plato exist"
now, back on topic. ok?
i already have pointed out places, please backtrack and find them yourself.
John
5:16 And therefore did the Jews persecute Jesus, and sought to slay him, because he had done these things on the sabbath day.
5:18 Therefore the Jews sought the more to kill him, because he not only had broken the sabbath, but said also that God was his Father, making himself equal with God.
7:1 After these things Jesus walked in Galilee: for he would not walk in Jewry, because the Jews sought to kill him.
7:13 Howbeit no man spake openly of him for fear of the Jews.
8:44 Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of it. (this is jesus talking to jews)
11:8 His disciples say unto him, Master, the Jews of late sought to stone thee; and goest thou thither again?
19:7 The Jews answered him, We have a law, and by our law he ought to die, because he made himself the Son of God. (again blaming the jews for the death of jesus... not the pharisees, all the jews)
19:12 And from thenceforth Pilate sought to release him: but the Jews cried out, saying, If thou let this man go, thou art not Caesar's friend: whosoever maketh himself a king speaketh against Caesar.
20:19 Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.
so you're saying that john is talking about residents of a nation that didn't exist at a time?
sorry, that one falls flat on its face. at the time the area was known as palestine (after philistines)
the argument you put forth also doesn't work in the context...