It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Equinox99
So what you are saying is that it did not create the universe but just help expand it over time? So what did create the universe then?
Originally posted by AncientVoid
Why do you think there's a purpose to everything?
You know science is trying to figure this out and we don't pretend to know everything, unlike religion. If you can tell me how did god came about then i'll answer your questions.
lol you can talk, lacking proof? Are you talking about god here? No proof what so ever.
The proof of evolution is overwhelming. Not believing in evolution is like believing everything revolves around the Earth.
How can you even suggest there's a god behind evolution when you guys say there's no such thing as evolution? First it was 'there's no evolution' and it's starting to become 'so what if there is, god created it'. =.=...
Religion provides nothing...
Yet god does nothing. Hmm some great god there...
'Why we are here?' is not a simple question and we do not know yet that's if there's a reason. Why don't you answer that question for us if it's so simple? Since i'm sure religion and your god is all so knowing...
God is not even a theory...
Originally posted by jfj123
Why are the physical constants in the universe so finely tuned to allow the possibility of complex life forms to exist?
Chance... The same way someone wins the lotto.
But, is there not a purpose to the lotto? Bad analogy.
or the universe to exist, it must be this way. Being this way, allows for but does not require the possibility of complex life forms.
that makes no sense.
Of course it doesn't but science does attempt to answer questions by using the scientific method and not by stories or religious dogma.
Forget religion for just a second. Because religion I do believe has been given a bad wrap. I think to a large degree, it has been poorely represnted. This is somthing, I feel you are just going to have to think for yourself on. How did we get here. Forget evolution for a second, and think the other way. What if somthing created us. This creator, gave us a purpose unique only to ourselves,to be alive in this vast universe. What is that purpose. Do you think the big bang along with evolution supporst that purpose? What created the 'bang' in order for it to happen? What created the mass of the big bang? How did it come about? What created that 'matter' inside of the 'big bang' from which we, as well as the milky way, orions belt, big dipper, small dipper, and billions of other galaxys came to exist from? Did this not, by evolutionary standards, give way to our existance?
Again, if you believe in evolution (which is lacking in the proof department) How or why do you feel that there wasnt something, maybe some supreme god, monitering and twitching our evolution pattern?
I don't think we have the answer for everything.
Wait a second Mr.jfj, what about science?!
provide evidence showing statistically that humans are wrong more then they are right.
Well Mr.jfj, why would I go about providing statistics, statistics which just so happens to be 'developed' by the same people I called wrong more then right?
You are a perfect example of the prototypical believer in evolution. Theres always answers, as long as you have statistics to back them up.
As I said earlier. Science, cannot provide all the answers my friend.
Watch CSPAN. Watch the democratic and republican debates, I dont know, its common sense. I guess the "BS berometer" is built into a select few of us.
Billons of people in this world starve to death. While the rest of the world stands by and does nothing. This world we live in today is controlled by the corrupt power that is paper money. We humans worship paper money, it is what be base our common lives around. We have misplaced priorities as an advanced species on this earth. That is why, I happen to think we are wrong more then we are right. Our vision is skewed, we rape and pillage earth for its dwindleing natural resources, we go out of our way to exploit other human beings just for our own personal gain. Modern politics, modern economics, all apart of a cut throat buisiness that is controlled by greed and power. And yet, you question me, by asking for statistical data, that proves just how wrong we are versus how right we are?
Everyone should believe the Theory of Evolution as it is a well-substantiated, well-supported, well-documented explanation for our observations.
Science, does NOT have the answers to everything, Mr.fjf.
It is not, and never has been 'right'. It has never been able to answer the common question, "what is our purpose". Evolution is theory, a theory that cannot answer even the most simplest, yet eluding questions out there, "why the hell are we here". Out of this vast universe, we are here, why? Things are to finely tuned for it to just be coincidence followed by the theory that is evolution.
If anything, your argument to me about evolution has as many holes as religion does to you.
Originally posted by Equinox99
You are right, science did create the computer. Science has knowledge, yes indeed it does. However claiming that God is not real because there is no evidence or proof backing it up is contradicting yourself don't you think? You said it yourselves that we do not know how the universe started. The Big Bang is not from point A to B it is from B to C, if it was from A to B then I would not be here debating about who started this universe.
Originally posted by Equinox99
The Big Bang is not from point A to B it is from B to C, if it was from A to B then I would not be here debating about who started this universe.
Originally posted by West Coast
What I find interesting is the fossil record. I think it was in the 1970's, that a prehistoric fish was caught off the coast of south america or somewhere in asia. This fish was thought to have died out with the dinosaurs over a 'bogus' "65,000,000" years ago. It hadnt changed a bit. Not once!
Crocodiles! What about crocodiles? they are virtually the SAME as they were 225 million years ago. No evolutionary changes.
How did whales go from landing mammals, to gigantic sea mammals that spend no time on land what so ever? Where are the bones of a whale before it became a 'sea creatur'? Surely there would be proof that helps validate what evolution bases its 'theorys' off of. I am going to stop there, but i could go on..
Originally posted by West Coast
How did whales go from landing mammals, to gigantic sea mammals that spend no time on land what so ever? Where are the bones of a whale before it became a 'sea creatur'? Surely there would be proof that helps validate what evolution bases its 'theorys' off of. I am going to stop there, but i could go on..
Originally posted by West Coast
Why are you so insistant that there isnt?
I think the evidence supports a 'God like figure' more so then the 'big bang, evolution theory'
. Now you can ask "well whys that?" We are living beings that live in an extordinary world. Everything around us fits us so perfectly. The fruits and vegetables, meat, and poultry, trees, and grass, water which feeds EVERYTHING. Its as ifsomeone designed it.
Its to perfect.
How did evolution 'get it right' without some sort of force pushing it into a certain direction?
We cannot just evolve on our own and still be the beings we are today. Infact, we couldnt evovle period.
What I find interesting is the fossil record. I think it was in the 1970's, that a prehistoric fish was caught off the coast of south america or somewhere in asia. This fish was thought to have died out with the dinosaurs over a 'bogus' "65,000,000" years ago. It hadnt changed a bit. Not once! Where was evolution during those 65,000,000+ years? Crocodiles! What about crocodiles? they are virtually the SAME as they were 225 million years ago. No evolutionary changes. How did whales go from landing mammals, to gigantic sea mammals that spend no time on land what so ever? Where are the bones of a whale before it became a 'sea creatur'? Surely there would be proof that helps validate what evolution bases its 'theorys' off of. I am going to stop there, but i could go on..
And the proof is....well...you. It is literally right under your nose.
Again, no its not. Where is the proof? If there was proof, I wouldnt be here debating it. So obviously, it is not overwhelming enough. But it clearly has you fooled.
Because I just dont believe in it. The evidence is lacking. Is what I met, however, is, If you wanted to make that your excuse (God saw evolution through), it would have more ground to stand on then then current one.
Something created us. For what purpose, now theres the real question.
God is not even a theory...
Not to you "monkey to man" boys. But since when did your type make up the rules? Ciao
"The Big Bang is the cosmological model of the universe whose primary assertion is that the universe has expanded into its current state from a primordial condition of enormous density and temperature."
Originally posted by Equinox99
So wait, is that evidence or just a guess that science has made? Because science has not traveled back in time to check how it happened. So they have an idea of how the universe began, yet they can not even figure out what the purpose of dark matter is, or where it comes from. Did the Big Bang eventually make dark matter? If science can not answer questions about these types of stuff, nor have evidence on how the universe started then it is just a hunch. Evidence is like a witness, or anything you can present to prove your case.
In this matter, there is no evidence, so when science does get the evidence you can come in these forums and start a thread called "God is not real!"
But until then this battle between both sides over the existence of God is a stalemate.
So if science does not know how something works, they throw out a theory and say it is true. Tell me something, how many theories of the universe are there?
Big Bang, The Bouncing Universe, The Protouniverse, The Inflationary Theory, and I can keep naming some. Does that mean they are right? Science is debating about which theory is the right one, so if they are debating for theories, how do you know it's a fact that the universe started with a big bang?
The Big Bang theory, which claims the universe began 15 billion years ago when a single point of unimaginable heat and density spontaneously exploded, is a scientific tale so well-known in popular culture that most people accept it as a fact.
However, while the Big Bang theory explains many mechanisms of the universe, it leaves plenty of questions unanswered.
What caused the Big Bang? Why is the universe flat rather than curved, as predicted by the theory of relativity? Why is matter clumped into galaxies but more uniform at larger scales? How did the laws of the universe come into being?
reply to post by jfj123
without revealed knowledge being given to us thru moses and the prophets from G-D we would know nothing of why we are alive and our existence would be meaningless and useless until we had a purpose a goal revealed to strive towards.G-D is not so cruel that They would give us the ability to comprehend Their creation from beginning to end and then deny us to have a part in it.what parent that loves their children would deny them to share in the parents wealth and everything they have?what was revealed to the prophets and moses has suffered a lot of abuse thanks to being mishandled by some of the scribes and translators that couldnt resist the urge to make little changes because they just couldnt believe what they were reading while they were making copies---thankfully the changes they made they also copied in their side notes----it is possible to undo the damage that these do gooders did because of their notes----it just makes for more studying for us.
G-D is not so cruel that They would give us the ability to comprehend Their creation from beginning to end and then deny us to have a part in it.what parent that loves their children would deny them to share in the parents wealth and everything they have?
Originally posted by DarkSide
Originally posted by West Coast
How did whales go from landing mammals, to gigantic sea mammals that spend no time on land what so ever? Where are the bones of a whale before it became a 'sea creatur'? Surely there would be proof that helps validate what evolution bases its 'theorys' off of. I am going to stop there, but i could go on..
Happy you asked
"Whales, of course, are sea animals with flippers, lacking external hindlimbs. Since they are also mammals, the consensus phylogeny indicates that whales and dolphins evolved from land mammals with legs. In recent years, we have found several transitional forms of whales with legs, both capable and incapable of terrestrial locomotion."
So not only did we predict that whales evolved from terrestrial mammals, but we also found transitional fossils...
Originally posted by jfj123
No actually it refers to random chance. The analogy is just fine thank you.
Yes it does, it's just not what you want to hear. The universe came into being because it could based on a number of factors. Had the factors changed, the universe would not have come into being.
I think your missing the big picture. What I'm telling you is that although science doesn't have all the answer, it doesn't automatically mean an all mighty being did it. Even if you were to disprove evolution tomorrow, it in no way validates the existence of a supreme being.
Evolution isn't lacking in the proof department. Thats why its called a THEORY and not just an IDEA or FAITH.
We have the knowledge of some things.
By the way, sarcasm is childish.
Well you made the statement right?
I'm just asking you to back up what you said. If you can't back it up, don't say it or tell me your just guessing/speculating.
I never said it could. There's a lot about a lot we don't know. There also is alot about alot we do know.
HUH??????
I never said it did. What I said was, "Everyone should believe the Theory of Evolution as it is a well-substantiated, well-supported, well-documented explanation for our observations."
So science has never been right. Well since you are reading this on your computer, you are wrong. The computer was made by SCIENCE !!
Again, why does there need to be a purpose for us to be here???? The theory of evolution isn't about the philosophy of the mind. It's about facts. The theory of evolution is not meant to answer why we're here and what our purpose is.. Thats like saying 2+2=4 because the color of our sky is blue.
If things are too finely tuned for it to be just coincidence, please prove it or are you saying this is just your opinion??
Originally posted by West Coast
Im not buying it for the simple fact that what is known as the whales "hind limbs" today (which is the nail in the coffin for the evolution of th whale), is actually for mating purposes, meaning this is how the whale goes about procreating. It is not, what 'used to be' hind limbs...
Originally posted by West Coast
I think the evidence supports a 'God like figure' more so then the 'big bang, evolution theory'. Now you can ask "well whys that?" We are living beings that live in an extordinary world. Everything around us fits us so perfectly. The fruits and vegetables, meat, and poultry, trees, and grass, water which feeds EVERYTHING. Its as if someone designed it. Its to perfect. How did evolution 'get it right' without some sort of force pushing it into a certain direction? We cannot just evolve on our own and still be the beings we are today. Infact, we couldnt evovle period.
Originally posted by West Coast
Crocodiles! What about crocodiles? they are virtually the SAME as they were 225 million years ago. No evolutionary changes.
Originally posted by West Coast
And the proof is....well...you. It is literally right under your nose.
Originally posted by West Coast
Again, no its not. Where is the proof? If there was proof, I wouldnt be here debating it. So obviously, it is not overwhelming enough. But it clearly has you fooled.
Originally posted by West Coast
Because I just dont believe in it. The evidence is lacking. Is what I met, however, is, If you wanted to make that your excuse (God saw evolution through), it would have more ground to stand on then then current one.
Originally posted by West Coast
And yet you completely missed my point (intentionally) to take a cheap shot at religion. Was that reply even to you? Does Mr.fjf have two accounts? I suggest you go back, read what Mr.fjf wrote, then reread what I wrote to help you understand the purpose behind what I wrote. You sir, are trolling.
Originally posted by West Coast
If there wasnt a purpose, we would not exist. It is that simple.