It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
What I don't get is..
The Evil Bush and Friends can bring down the WTC, but they can't make a comparitively minor thing (like a video) disappear. The fact that we even HEARD about this tape makes me question the very notion of this all encompassing conspiracy against the Americans by its government.
You didnt get a word of what he said. What he said was that it is not what your average troop would do
You have people like this all over the world and they commit these crimes every day against children
Syrian Sister, do you have personal knowledge of what is on the alleged tapes or of this alleged judgement? Do you know for a fact that the reported incident is accurate and complete or are you just assuming it is?
If you are making judgements and statements of fact based upon allegations, then by definition, you are prejudiced. I respectfully submit that your passion and zeal are blinding your reason and judgement. It weakens your position immeasurably.
blaming the whole based upon the actions of a few is not only wrong, it is reprehensible.
Never should a modern army, a civilized army, a peace keeping army,
An Iraqi Woman's Ordeal
At Abu Gharib
23 July, 2004
The rape ordeal she suffered at the hands of US soldiers, both males and females, in the notorious Abu Gharib prison will continue to haunt Nadia for the rest of her life. Though freed now, she is "imprisoned" in painful memories that left her psychologically and physically scarred, paying the price of the brutality and sadism of her American jailers.
Nadia, the name given by a freed Iraqi female prisoner to Al-Wasat, a weekly supplement of the respectable London-based Al-Hayat newspaper,
....
Then, four soldiers raped me sadistically and I lost conscience. Later, she forced me to watch a clip of my raping, saying bluntly: ‘Your were born to give us pleasure’."
Naida was set free from the US hell in Abu Gharib after spending up to six months there.
Read more here
www.countercurrents.org...
...
I did not want to believe him, not because I thought he was not telling the truth but because such truth is too hard on anyone and I wanted, selfishly, to spare myself the agony. A few days later I met a friend coming out of Baghdad and he told me that two ladies from his neighbourhood were in Abu Gharib prison for a few weeks.
When they came out they were speechless when asked about what happened to them and how they were treated. Their only answer was tears and more tears. After many repeated attempts one of them only managed to say "I was touched" and left the rest to the imagination of her visitors. My friend also told me that some men were made to walk naked in front of women prisoners and vice versa.
.....
My tears and disappointment are because I am a western educated person who lived a large portion of his life in the west and never imagined that "liberal, democratic and civilised" nations, as the west is always described to us, could allow this to happen. What will I say to my friends in the west or rather what will they say to me?
more
bitterfact.tripod.com... [/rx]
On May 12, 2004 an Iraqi female professor revealed that U.S. soldiers in Iraq have raped, sexually humiliated and abused several Iraqi female detainees in the notorious Abu Ghraib prison. Professor Huda Shaker, a political scientist at Baghdad University, said an Iraqi young girl was raped by a U.S. military policeman and became pregnant.
Professor Shaker, an Amnesty International researcher, said she knows of other Iraqi females that were arrested, taken to Abu Ghraib prison and raped by the US Military Police. "Iraqi women here are afraid and shy of talking about such subjects," Professor Shaker said. Few women released from U.S. detention have come forward to talk about their experiences in a Muslim society where rape is sometimes equated with shame.
Women who stay at home in traditional roles are more likely to be imprisoned as bargaining chips by US troops seeking to pressurize male relatives, according to the New Statesmen (UK). In December 2003,
In September 2003, Selwa was taken by US military personnel to a detention facility in Tikrit, where an American of?cer lit a mixture of human feces and urine in a metal container and gave Selwa a heavy club to stir it. She recalls, “The ?re from the pot felt very strong on my face.” She leans forward and sweeps her hands through the air to show how she stirred the excrement.
“I became very tired,” she says. “I told the sergeant I couldn’t do it.” “There was
another man close to us. The sergeant came up to me and whispered in my ear, ‘If you don’t, I will tell one of the soldiers *EDIT*’” Selwa could not continue with the story.
psychoanalystsopposewar.org/resources_files/SVIW-1.doc
www.historiansagainstwar.org...
Following the initial revelations, two important reports came to light: a report prepared by the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) in February 2004 and another compiled for the U.S. military by General Antonio Taguba at the beginning of the year.
Following are some of the ICRC's findings:
* The crimes were not confined to Abu Ghraib, but occurred in more than a dozen
"internment facilities" in central and southern Iraq, "indicating a consistent pattern…
of brutal behavior during arrest."
Archives - November 09, 2005
DATELINE:Lifting the Hood- The Prisoners of Abu Ghraib.
Streamed video here:
blogagainsttorture.blogspot.com...
Partial transcript:
...
ABU MAAN (Translation): I told them the Americans were coming and to stay calm, because they were after me and I would be going with them. I was worried about the kids, and my wife was pregnant. I woke her up. As I was waking her up the troops entered the bedroom.
MUTHANA(Translation): I was with Mum when I heard the Americans overhead. The glass was shattered. They tied up my brothers like that. They pulled the cord so tight on my brother's neck he was choking. He was screaming and they punched him.
Abu Maan's wife Nadal was six months pregnant at the time of the raid.
NADAL (Translation): I was bleeding. I was shaking all over. In the morning I went to the hospital. I had a miscarriage.
...
ABU MAAN (Translation): I entered the cell around 5am. Before that, they took photos of me in degrading positions. They'd stripped me and were laughing at me. And I'd hear screaming. Men and women screaming. And children sometimes. I found out later that my cell was number 11.
For four months Nadal had no news of her husband and assumed he was dead. As an unregistered 'ghost detainee' Abu Maan lived in constant fear.
...
HAJ ALI (Translation): We've seen none of the Titan Corp or CACI interrogators who'd rape a man in front of his wife, and a woman in front of her husband and a girl in front of her family. We haven't seen any of them being charged. This company hides behind its billions. A month after Abu Ghraib, its contract was renewed.
....
Haj Ali has started an organisation called Victims of the American Occupation Prisons which claims to have 40,000 members. He now spends most of his time trying to help other ex-detainees and documenting new stories of abuse.
...
HAJ ALI (Translation): When a man's honour is violated before his eyes, or when he refuses sexual intercourse with a female soldier and then she straps on a dildo and rapes him, what do you expect from that man?
Originally posted by Syrian Sister
And for those who will inevitable post on here saying that "the people who did these crimes will be prosecuted, because the US is a civlised country". Allow me to remind you that the soldier who murdered that wounded prisoner in that mosque in fallujah was aquited by US courts.
Originally posted by rogue1
Given the penchant for these Islamic extremists to commit suiced using a variety of explosive devices, I would have shot him myself if I had been in that situation. WHat makes this insurgents even more ridiculous is that they like to kill themselves because of some mythical god, fortunately ( althogh only after teh fat ) there is no heaven waiting fr them
As far as some guy involved in a shootout being shot when its discovered that he's not dead and is moving around, so what. That kind of thing is allways going to happen in war, and if a person doesn't want it to happen to them, they can.....no take up arms and join in the war. But this issue of raping kids in prison....
Originally posted by Syrian Sister
As far as some guy involved in a shootout being shot when its discovered that he's not dead and is moving around, so what. That kind of thing is allways going to happen in war, and if a person doesn't want it to happen to them, they can.....no take up arms and join in the war. But this issue of raping kids in prison....
I take it you haven't seen the video,
He wasn't moving around at all."he's dead now" said your animal.
WHICH IS WHY I AM AGAINST WAR AND EVERYONE THAT STARTS THEM.
Originally posted by Nygdan
As far as it hurting our "war effort"...too bad, raping kids is where everyone should draw the line, and if anything would help our war effort, it'd be people seeing that america actually doesn't tolerate that kind of criminality and abuse, and will actually do something about it.
....no take up arms and join in the war. But this issue of raping kids in prison....
[edit on 30-10-2006 by Nygdan]
The insurgency doesn't take prisoners. Americans can't be expected to
Why is this guy an animal? Becuase he didn't take this guy prisoner?
All the iraqis have to do to get the americans out of iraq is vote in a party that will ask the americans to leave.
I wish you were right about America not tolerating this kind of actions,
Originally posted by Syrian Sister
That's a blatent lie.
Because he shot and killed a wounded and incapacitated man, who wasn't a threat to anyone.
You can't see the dishonour in that? You really have lost your humanity nygaand.
I've seen several images of your soldier shooting people who where waving a white flag.
If you don't see this as criminal, then i think you should take your place among the torturers.
LOL LOL, which planet do you live on? There is no such party,
Well if we take nygaand as an example, the american people will tolerate alot, including the murder of wounded prisoners.
Originally posted by Syrian Sister
The only way for iraqies to get the americans out, is to push them out with force, and that's just what they are doing.
Originally posted by marg6043
I will like to bring another link to the story supply by another member on this topic a while back.
I guess many took the story for granted and make it into an outraged lie.
But this has been circulation for a while.
Rumsfeld May Have Ordered Children To Be Raped and Sodomized In Front Of Parents For Information
politics.abovetopsecret.com...
I guess it was no rumors after all.
Originally posted by Syrian Sister
I take it you haven't seen the video, the man was already shot, unconcious but still breathing before your animal put 10 bullets in him.
He wasn't moving around at all.
"he's dead now" said your animal.
And i do agree that these things happen in war, WHICH IS WHY I AM AGAINST WAR AND EVERYONE THAT STARTS THEM.
Originally posted by Nygdan
Waitaminute, there's a big difference between there being people that were at abu garaib and who abused kids there, and "Don Rumsefeld ordered children to be raped".
Originally posted by rogue1
10 BUllets, what a damn waste of taxpayers money, This scum didn't even deserve the cost of one bullet being wasted on him. They should have used a knife or something.
LOL, I think you get off on this Iraq War, you wouldn't have anything to talk about otherwise. Lets face it, you havea hard on for the guerilla's in Iraq, your nice safe life in Australia would be so much more boring without them
Let's face it half of these " guerilla's " would be in prison in a peaceful life, most are just to sadistic and babaric to live in civilian society.
PS. I doubt Rumsfeld could order children to be raped and sodomised, ridiculous.
Originally posted by Astygia
Do you not see how this line of thought is cruel, regardless of who's using it? These are people. They don't sit under a rock somewhere waiting for a war to start. They have lives, just like you and I.
How easily you laugh at the passion of a real issue. Were I using the same logic but pro-war, you would likely back me 100%, yes?
I don't mean to put you down, but attacking the poster for their intensity and feeling on a subject are uncalled for, even if it's a view you don't agree with.
Half of these guerillas began life as civilians. Most of them are just people, with no real training or military experience. Do I want them to kill soldiers? No. But does the fact that they do, make them monsters?