It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
none of the numbers you quoted have anything to do with getting just a normal state approved id, which is 25-50$
required to you know, work and pay taxes.... collect tax returns.
For a start, the self-employed, a large and expanding cohort in the USA (ever heard of the 'gig' economy?) do fill out I-9s.
If that is true, then requiring an ID to get a vaccine is openly racist and life threatening to minorities.
Where is the outrage from the left? Its not just about an ID - this is about a life saving vaccine. Where is the outrage???
Step 3: Bring proof of eligibility to your appointment. Depending on your eligibility category, proof can include an employee ID card, a letter from an employer or affiliated organization, a pay stub, a driver's license, passport, or any legal proof of your date of birth and residency. At the time of your appointment, you'll be asked a series of clinical questions to ensure readiness for a vaccine. You will be asked for insurance information BUT the vaccine is free and there will never be a charge to you. This information is for administrative use only.
You mad bro? Your talking down to me saying you assume I was referring to an I-9 form, I specifically referenced it, by name. If you want to debate, try and keep up. Again you ignore my question, is it somehow prohibitive to require id to work? As a 1099 employee or a w2 employee your still providing your social which is a state issued id. The i9 form is an amazing example here, it provides many opportunities to prove id with multiple documents. Seems perfect for voting. You still haven’t answered any of my questions but your mad as hell!
originally posted by: rnaa
a reply to: Rob808
none of the numbers you quoted have anything to do with getting just a normal state approved id, which is 25-50$
What state do you live in?
How much does it cost to get a copy of your birth certificate?
How much does it cost to hire a wheelchair taxi to get you from your home to the ID issuing office 170 miles away?
But just on your numbers alone, (which are apparently only the fee that the state charges), with 21 million Americans without a State approved ID, that is between $500 million and a billion dollars required to just buy an ID card so you can vote. You do realize that it is unconstitutional to charge a poll tax don't you? Those states that do remember that, and give the ID's away for 'free' are spending that much of taxpayer's money (even before the cost of implementing the system into the election processes).
How many illegal in person (the only kind that your suggested ID might prevent) votes are you stopping for that half billion dollar (lets use the lower figure) spend? 2 or 3 per election - NATIONWIDE. About 30 in 20 years - NATIONWIDE . And here I thought conservatives were against wasting taxpayers money.
required to you know, work and pay taxes.... collect tax returns.
You DO NOT need a 'state issued ID card' to "work and pay taxes.... collect tax returns" in the USA, that is just more ignorant gaslighting.
I assume you are referring to form I-9.
Your first mistake (if we don't count your underlying motive of spreading misinformation) is that NOT EVERY 'worker' is required to fill out a form I-9. For a start, the self-employed, a large and expanding cohort in the USA (ever heard of the 'gig' economy?) do fill out I-9s.
But for the purposes of form I-9, a state ID card CAN be accepted, but NOT BY ITSELF. You need additional accompanying documents: Acceptable Documents for Verifying Employment Authorization and Identity
You need one ID from list 'A' OR you need one item from both list 'B' AND 'C'.
Notice that a State Issued ID (e.g. drivers license) is in the same list (list 'B') as a 'Voter Registration Card' - they are of EQUAL status for the purposes of form I-9 - they BOTH establish IDENTITY.
Notice also that a birth certificate can be used for the item in list 'C' - it establishes right to work (since it establishes citizenship).
You mad bro? Your talking down to me saying you assume I was referring to an I-9 form, I specifically referenced it, by name. If you want to debate, try and keep up.
Meh. I missed the connection. Sorry.
Again you ignore my question, is it somehow prohibitive to require id to work? As a 1099 employee or a w2 employee your still providing your social which is a state issued id.
A social security card is (1) not an Identification document and (2) not State issued. It provides evidence of the right to work and the 'account' number under which taxes are kept.
The i9 form is an amazing example here, it provides many opportunities to prove id with multiple documents. Seems perfect for voting. You still haven’t answered any of my questions but your mad as hell!
And you are required to provided similar forms of identification WHEN YOU REGISTER TO VOTE (but actually more strict of course) in order to prove your eligibility. That is the template you are matching here. The argument presented in the original post is about ID required at voting time - not at registration time. Try to keep up.
How does one work, pay taxes and collect tax return without providing their social, a state issued id? not ID, not state issuedYour just lying now. Yours is a straw man argument, one does not need to be eligible to vote in order to work, one does not need to pre-register before hand to establish your eligibility to work before you apply for a job. They aren't the same thing at all..
You talk about gas lighting when you quote voter outreach programs as a cost to prevent voter id laws and call it a money grab, projection is clearly a familiar act for you. (I also haven’t specifically any specific kind of voter id be used, another projection on your part, you are battling phantoms my foolish friend...)
The 'what kind of ID' that is being talked about is well known as are the problems that 21 million eligible voters have in accessing that kind of ID whether you say it or not.
By law EVERY STATE demands PROOF of Identification and Citizenship and eligibility to vote when you register to vote. This is exactly the process you, and others are attempting to deny exists. The reason that this pre-registration process exists in the first place is to make election day quick and easy. Get the 'hard' stuff out of the way beforehand and then on polling day, sign your name in the poll list and vote.
One last time if you want to play. Is it prohibitive or bias to require these forms of id such as through the I-9? You keep ignoring my question and are asking for personal info from me...
I have fully addressed your question several times even though it is a strawman that has nothing to do with voting.
You are avoiding my question: why do you want to force the American public to spend a billion dollars to try to prevent 3 bad votes (nationwide) per election (maybe 30 nationwide in 20 years out of several billions). At what point does the law of diminishing returns enter your mental computations?
If, as some on the left assert, it is difficult for minorities to acquire state ID for voting purposes, then making that same ID mandatory for vaccines is an open threat to the lives of minorities. Is it really that hard to figure out?
In regards to photo Id, I question your research skills. This took me less than a minute to find:
Social security isn’t a state issued form of id?
Do you not understand what the term “state” is? I’ll let you figure this out. So many wrong things in your head...
I’m not calling for billions to be spent and to claim as such is blatantly misrepresenting reality, much like your thought process here, point out exactly where I do what you’ve claimed?
emphasis added
You must have several documents to prove your identity, and one of those is a United States Social Security card. You must provide Social Security number in order to apply for your US passport. If you don't have you Social Security Card, you should order a replacement card for when you apply for your passport.
originally posted by: rnaa
a reply to: Rob808
I’m not calling for billions to be spent and to claim as such is blatantly misrepresenting reality, much like your thought process here, point out exactly where I do what you’ve claimed?
Exactly WHAT is the problem you are trying to solve?
Exactly WHAT is the severity of that problem?
Exactly WHAT is your proposal to solve that problem?
Exactly WHAT needs to be done to implement your proposal?
Exactly WHAT side effects might be raised by your proposal?
Spell it out. Don't continue arguing if you are going move the goal posts each time you are shown to be talking about nothing. Pin your self down or go home.
If you aren't calling for a plan that has been demonstrated to cost billions to implement, then what exactly ARE you calling for?
A social security card does have a code which reflects the state in which it was issued.
No it doesn't.
Once upon a time the leading digits were an indicator of the regional office that processed the SS application - but a regional office often handled multiple states. This was necessary to ensure duplice SSN's were not assigned in the days before national computer networks. The leading digits mean absolutely nothing since at least the 1970's (Barrack Obama's (original) SSN, applied for from Hawaii sometime in the mid 70s, has a leading code that once indicated it was issued from Baltimore Maryland regional office but in fact it was just a number generated by the national computer system.
Social security cards are also one of the primary forms of ID for many government services, not just social security or banking. In the absence of a national identity card the social security card has become the de facto national ID.
It is NOT identification. It is evidence of registration, nothing more. Yes it is the 'key' to government services, but it is NOT ID. Just because I have possession of an SSN card does not mean that it is MY SSN card. In fact I lost my SSN card many years ago, and have no trouble accessing government services with just the number.
It is also the fact that many non-government services have no right to demand your SSN. The University I attended incorrectly used SSN as student ID because it was 'convenient', but if a student (like me for instance) refused to give them their SSN they could not require them to do so. If there is a legitimate reason for asking for the SSN, for instance because the student is working for the University or other Federal government reporting requirements, then they have to have it like any other employer - but not as the student ID. Your employer does not use your SSN as your employee ID either.
You can use a social security card as one form of ID to get a passport.
Actually NO. What you need to get a passport is PROOF OF CITIZENSHIP. Citizenship has nothing to do with Social Security. My wife has a Social Security card and she is NOT a CITIZEN and not every citizen needs to be registered to Social Security to legally work.
Here is the OFFICIAL State Department information - if you study this page, you will notice that the Social Security Number is not mentioned.
U.S. DEPARTMENT of STATE — BUREAU of CONSULAR AFFAIRS - Travel.State.Gov: Citizenship Evidence
Proof of Identity
You may submit items such as the following containing your signature AND a photograph that is a good likeness of you: previous or current U.S. passport book; previous or current U.S. passport card; driver's license (not temporary or learner's license); Certificate of Naturalization; Certificate of Citizenship; military identification; or federal, state, or municipal government employee identification card. Temporary or altered documents are not acceptable.You must establish your identity to the satisfaction of the acceptance agent and Passport Services. We may ask you to provide additional evidence to establish your identity. If you have changed your name, please see travel.state.gov for instructions. IF YOU CANNOT PROVIDE DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE OF IDENTITY as stated above, you must appear with an IDENTIFYING WITNESS, who is a U.S.citizen, non-citizen U.S. national, or permanent resident alien that has known you for at least two years. Your witness must prove his or her identity and complete and sign an Affidavit of Identifying Witness (Form DS-71) before the acceptance agent. You must also submit some identification of your own
Federal Tax Law
Section 6039E of the Internal Revenue Code (26 USC 6039E) and 22 U.S.C. 2714a(f) require you to provide your Social Security number (SSN), ifyou have one, when you apply for or renew a U.S. passport. If you have never been issued a SSN, enter zeros in box #5 of this form. If you are residing abroad, you must also provide the name of the foreign country in which you are residing. The U.S. Department of State must provide your SSN and foreign residence information to the U.S. Department of Treasury. If you fail to provide the information, you are subject to a $500 penalty enforced by the IRS. All questions on this matter should be directed to the nearest IRS office.
No it doesn't.
Once upon a time the leading digits were an indicator of the regional office that processed the SS application - but a regional office often handled multiple states. This was necessary to ensure duplice SSN's were not assigned in the days before national computer networks. The leading digits mean absolutely nothing since at least the 1970's (Barrack Obama's (original) SSN, applied for from Hawaii sometime in the mid 70s, has a leading code that once indicated it was issued from Baltimore Maryland regional office but in fact it was just a number generated by the national computer system.
When the Social Security numbering system was developed, one or more area numbers were allocated to each State based on the anticipated number of issuances in the State (table 1). Because an individual could apply for an SSN at any Social Security office, the area code did not necessarily indicate where the person lived or worked. Since 1972, the Social Security Administration has been issuing SSN’s centrally from its headquarters in Baltimore. The area code now indicates the person’s State of residence as shown on the SSN application.
Step 3: All applicants must provide proof of full Social Security number (SSN). (Examples are: an SSN card, a W-2 or a pay stub with full SSN.)
It’s not issued by a state and instead some unnamed mystical entity