It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: lostgirl
a reply to: Tangerine
In the Bluebook cases I've read, if the experiencer 'believes in' UFOs, their reliability is questioned!
originally posted by: lostgirl
a reply to: Tangerine
In the Bluebook cases I've read, if the experiencer 'believes in' UFOs, their reliability is questioned!
originally posted by: lostgirl
do you think that's safe?
Because they are the most beautiful tarot cards I've ever seen...and the archetypal images are portrayed in a way that is just so 'me', that it really 'feels' as if they were 'meant' for me...
originally posted by: ZetaRediculian
originally posted by: lostgirl
a reply to: Tangerine
In the Bluebook cases I've read, if the experiencer 'believes in' UFOs, their reliability is questioned!
That is kind of odd. Lets say I saw God once. If I believe in God, then my reliability as a witness to God should be questioned? If I don't believe in God and said I talked to God then don't I believe in God? If I didn't believe in God then I would just say that I had a strange hallucination and there would really be nothing to talk about.
So lets say I don't believe in UFOs as in alien space vehicles. If I say I saw a UFO and describe it as an alien space ship, I am a better witness? Obviously, you would have to believe in UFOs in order to report something to MUFON. I mean, how else would you know about MUFON? If I ever see an alien space ship, my first trip is to a neurologist, not MUFON! So I would make an incredibly reliable witness since I would write off any sighting as a symptom of a brain tumor?
Bluebook was at an interesting time period. One thing that is overlooked is where psychology was at that time. There was a category for "crackpot" cases. So I suppose everyone here would be considered a crackpot back in the day. That they even used the word "crackpot" ....
originally posted by: Tangerine
It's nothing of the sort. If you dance with the trickster you'll wish that you hadn't.
a reply to: Tangerine
You didn't ask me but I would strongly suggest that you avoid "playing" with tarot cards. I get the impression that you think going down the rabbit hole is fun. It's not. You have a WIccan background and Wicca traditionally paints a twinkly happy bunny face on this sort of stuff. It's nothing of the sort. If you dance with the trickster you'll wish that you hadn't.
You're completely missing the point which is that those groups do not record seeming non-UFO anomalous experiences reported by people who also report UFO encounters/sightings nor do they ask about those experiences.
originally posted by: Tangerine
Bluebook was a government project. We're talking about UFO groups. You're completely missing the point which is that those groups do not record seeming non-UFO anomalous experiences reported by people who also report UFO encounters/sightings nor do they ask about those experiences.
You didn't ask me but I would strongly suggest that you avoid "playing" with tarot cards. I get the impression that you think going down the rabbit hole is fun. It's not. You have a WIccan background and Wicca traditionally paints a twinkly happy bunny face on this sort of stuff. It's nothing of the sort. If you dance with the trickster you'll wish that you hadn't.
originally posted by: lostgirl
originally posted by: Tangerine
Bluebook was a government project. We're talking about UFO groups. You're completely missing the point which is that those groups do not record seeming non-UFO anomalous experiences reported by people who also report UFO encounters/sightings nor do they ask about those experiences.
Actually I did not miss the point - my comment was meant as a comparison of the ridiculousness of two top UFO investigative 'agencies' being so close-minded about the people whose experiences they're supposed to be 'objectively' investigating...
You didn't ask me but I would strongly suggest that you avoid "playing" with tarot cards. I get the impression that you think going down the rabbit hole is fun. It's not. You have a WIccan background and Wicca traditionally paints a twinkly happy bunny face on this sort of stuff. It's nothing of the sort. If you dance with the trickster you'll wish that you hadn't.
I definitely do not "think going down the rabbit hole is fun", at least not since reading people's experiences on this thread...
...But at least back in my 'curious' years, I was cautious enough to go with the "twinkly happy bunny face" of Wicca, rather than the 'door opening', Babylon summoning of Enochian...
I would be interested to know if you ( or someone you know) experienced something negative related to tarot cards?
Do you think the I-Ching is just as bad? Because I use my cards as a tool for self 'awareness' similar to the I-Ching...
- Tangerine, I don't know why you responded to me in such a harsh way (perhaps you didn't mean to 'draw tears', but it did hurt) - if I've offended you, I'm sorry - if you're unhappy with my contributions to the thread, I'll stop posting...
Do you think the I-Ching is just as bad? Because I use my cards as a tool for self 'awareness' similar to the I-Ching...
You're missing the point,too. The discussion was about UFO groups' lack of interest in any anomalous experience that they can't cram into the ET hypothesis. Bluebook has been rehashed to death. So have ETs.
Let's get back on topic discussing non-ET hypotheses for UFOs and other related anomalous phenomena.
As far as I know, it's not only not asked by MUFON, if an experiencer mentions it, it's excluded from the report or the experiencer is regarded as unreliable.
originally posted by: RedCairo
I don't worry about the trickster energy of the universe. I see individuation, certainly to include tarot/astrology/archetype work -- my primary focus the last couple decades -- as a fabulous opportunity, challenge, something that is a GOOD thing even when it hurts, even when it's scary. God (big-G) is with me, I always felt, and much of me is a spectrum between me and that in infinite identity-variation and they're with me too. It's like my own ski-rescue story and I'm always princess of earth, 4th of 4, service and loyalty, and 'Adjustment' -- it's-all-about-ME in the middle.
originally posted by: Tangerine
I'm trying to keep the thread on-topic. The topic is non-physical non-ET hypotheses about UFOs and related anomalous phenomena. I see you trying to turn this into an advice column and that's not what it is.
originally posted by: Tangerine
a reply to: ZetaRediculian
The problem is that it's a rehash of the problem with ufology and not a discussion of non-physical, non-ET hypotheses. Most of us, myself included, have been guilty of that rehashing. Unfortunately, it doesn't move us forward.
There are several interesting people in that group with whom I'd like to brainstorm but the organizer is a MUFON field investigator determined to cram ET down our throats. She's gone so far as to convince a malleable person that an anomalous experience she had that didn't involve anything remotely UFO-like was an abduction by aliens (yes, I know it's all interconnected but you get my point). If there's one thing I'm not, it's malleable.
Anyway, I hope that this thread will lead to some serious brainstorming.
originally posted by: ZetaRediculian
a reply to: Tangerine
There are several interesting people in that group with whom I'd like to brainstorm but the organizer is a MUFON field investigator determined to cram ET down our throats. She's gone so far as to convince a malleable person that an anomalous experience she had that didn't involve anything remotely UFO-like was an abduction by aliens (yes, I know it's all interconnected but you get my point). If there's one thing I'm not, it's malleable.
You are getting me worked up now too. I honestly don't think I could take it. If you do proclaim your Non ET beliefs, do record it. I want to hear all the gasps.
Anyway, I hope that this thread will lead to some serious brainstorming.
It has led to something. Personally, I think all the paranormal talk is fascinating. It's really not my thing but I am thinking there is definitely a common thread with some of the stuff I brought up and everything else being discussed. I just cant quite articulate it yet.