posted on Jan, 27 2010 @ 06:53 PM
Hi Trouble—
You better do your homework before you start airing your ignorant assumptions for the whole world to see:
You wrote: "1. Between OT prophecies being made and fulfilled, MSS were translated into other languages,the date these translations were done is
known. 2. You are ignorant about the methods of transmission,the way the manuscripts were copied and preserved, all minor errors were recorded and
faulty copies destroyed. 3. This could have been a viable argument before the discovery of the Dead Sea Scolls,that confirmed the reliability
between copies."
You clearly are not conversant with the Facts of the matter in terms of hand written transmission and copies of ancient Hebrew, Aramaic and Greek HAND
COPIED texts that form today’s messy manuscript hotchpotch called the ‘Bible’.
A Prophecy was first ORAL, not written; when it WAS written, it was set down by 2nd or 3rd generation compilers, on any material that was at hand
(potsherds, palm leaves, stones) the oracles being all OUT OF ORDER, in pericopes and. not worked up into books until a generation or two later AFTER
THE SOCALLED PROPHET HAD DIED.
B Later ‘prophets’ would sometimes try to coat-tail on the success of one of his predecessors and FAKE various prophecies in the name of that
earlier more widely known 9and more widely hand-copied)’ prophet ‘(e.g. Isaiah chapters 40-55 (aka Deutero-Isaiah written c. 550 BCE) are a
slavish FAKE imitation of the style of the man who was responsible for the jumbled oracles found later in chapters 1-39 (aka protoIsaiah c. 701 BCE)
and was CLEARLYwritten by a different person.
Ditto for Zechariah chapters 9-12 which are NOT written by the same person who wrote Zech chapters 1-8, and many other examples of the same kind of
pseudo-imitation by LATER hands.
Because of this, the content of prophetic ‘oracles’ can never be known in its earliest form --e.g. the PRIMARY ‘oral’ stage which is ‘non
permanent’ –hence HEAR the ORACLE of YHWH, (not READ the Oracle) the few exceptions being e.g. Jeremiah who used a scribe named Beruchiah
sometimes since he could not write, like most prophets, wandering 'oral bards') thus what was LATER copied BY hAND in their names could easily be
faked/changed/adapted/worked into what what later known to have happened—i.e. LONG AFTER AN EVENT BECAME FACTUAL.
That you are NOT aware of any of this is of course no excuse for you.
It is also clear that you have no working knowledge of the Dead Sea Scroll material in Caves 1-11 (the oldest MSS of the Scrolls sealed up in AD 68)
for if you had bothered to read for example (that is if you COULD read un-pointed Paleo-Hebrew) the Scroll known as 1Q-IS-b and bothered to compare it
to 1QIs-A (2 copies of the ‘Scroll of the Book of the Prophet Isaiah’ you woud know that there is a 20% difference between these two copies of
the same book, that is, if you closely compare consonant by consonant (you did know, didn’t you, that Hebrew writings in antiqutiy were ALL hand
copied WITHOUT vowels didn’t you?!)
C. Contrary to your claim, translations OUT of the HEBREW into other languages occurred at a very late stage in the written development of the texts
in question (i.e. after they had been already tampered with by their final Hebrew editors), so your nonsense reveals your total ignorance of the true
state of affairs in this subject.
The messy state of the MSS evidence that to-day’s scholars can examine under the ‘cold light of day’ shows the shameless methodology by which
Hebrew (and later Greek) texts of the so-called Old Testament (and later ‘New’ Testament) were hand-copied/transmitted over time in various places
and by various levels of scribal accuracy & intentions--especially the prophetic writings which since they deal with ‘oracles’ are particularly
vulnerable to SCRIBAL Tampering.
See the wording of the Plagues Warning to copyists to ‘tamper with the texts’ found at the end of the Apocalypse of Yohanon at the end of your
Bible—hardly a necessary Warning if scribes were ‘honest’ about their work, or as Jeremiah likes to draw the picture:
‘THE LYING PEN OF THE COPYISTS !!’ (see: Jeremiah 8:8ff)
If you did have any working knowledge ref this matter (even the BASICS !) you would know right away that prophetic texts were ALWAYS handed down FIRST
BY WORD OF MOUTH to DISCIPLE GROUPS and only much later were they copied BY HAND (i.e. worked into books) where even MORE errors and sometimes
theologically deliberate changes were placed into the margins and later copied into the main bodies of the texts, as Dr Bart Ehrman likes to lay out
in some detail for his general-audience readership most of whom alas have no understanding of this (e.g. 'Jesus Interrupted' or 'MisQuoting
Jesus') in the original languages
Of course, you would have to be able to read PaleoHebrew, Aramaic and Greek to be able to understand the actual MSS copies that have come down to us
after so much hand-copied tampering ---texts that one may now happily examine under a microscope for deliberate scribal changes—and to be able to
understand the nuances of how these texts came to be copied in different places at different times, hence the random mess that e.g. Origin discovered
when he compiled (for his Hexapla) all the various CONTRADICTORY Greek Old Testament Texts in AD 200 that were all based on earlier CONTRADICTORY
Hebrew Vorlagen (Hebrew Underlay texts from which the Greek was translated OUT OF).
D. Contrary to your claim that the Dead sea Scrolls actually support a 'consistent' MSS transmission, it is in fact QUITE THE OPPOSITE in terms of
what was actually discovered when the MSS in caves 1-11 sealed up in June of AD 68, – books that later contradicted what is written in modern OT
traditions e.g. the Masoretic text of the Jews used today, which are based on a SINGLE Manuscript from Leningrad from c. 960 CE--the DSS material is
1000 years older.
By 200 CE the protoMasoretic text of the paleoHebrew was censored / codified by the Rabbinnic councils into one nearly single unpointed paleo Hebrew
MSS family following the so-called Council of Jamnia-Javneh in AD 90 after Jerusalem was ground to powder by the Romans in AD 70 and there was no more
Temple (thus more codified texts were used for general worship purposes) – all copies that did NOT match Hillel II’s version of the Hebrew Text
were destroyed..only Qumran 1-11 preserved the older MSS showing all the messy Scribal errors.
[edit on 27-1-2010 by Sigismundus]