It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
I tried fixing the link. Try copy and paste it, take out the "no link" part.
originally posted by: Phage
a reply to: Wolfenz
Yes. Quite standardized symbolism.
sprezzatura.it...
Maybe. But they would be wrong. We didn't have to restart though, did we. We know the actual history of the medieval period and its symbology. We know what the artists (who were not at the events they painted) are representing.
And when they Discover ( the Coin ) What would they think the Coin Represents ! a Eagle with a Olive Branch Landing On the Moon ?
originally posted by: Phage
a reply to: Rosinitiate
Ain't art cool? Symbolism is a powerful thing.
originally posted by: Phage
a reply to: Wolfenz
what was Shown in the 1930s of Scifi Pulp Fiction
1930s
Drawings to get people to buy Science fiction magazines.
They called them disks back then. And I'm pretty sure you know the story of how the term saucer came to be used later.
Btw, You think those stories are historical?
originally posted by: Phage
a reply to: Wolfenz
Yes. Quite standardized symbolism.
sprezzatura.it...
Maybe. But they would be wrong. We didn't have to restart though, did we. We know the actual history of the medieval period and its symbology. We know what the artists (who were not at the events they painted) are representing.
And when they Discover ( the Coin ) What would they think the Coin Represents ! a Eagle with a Olive Branch Landing On the Moon ?
originally posted by: NoNameNeeded
originally posted by: Teratoma
It appears to me that the artist was attempting a realistic rendering of something from a more symbolic/representational/iconic format; in this case a shield he'd only seen on coins. There is no reason to assume the artist had access to an actual round, Roman-era shield to use for reference.
It does appear obvious to me that the same symbolism is being depicted here, as much as I would like it to have been a spaceship.
What? Did you even compare the painting to the coin? Why is the shield on the painting not circular in shape? It is on the coin, which you suggest the artist duplicated.. I disagree
And why would he not had have access to a shield for reference? If not an accurate one, any shield would do.
originally posted by: Subaeruginosa
originally posted by: NoNameNeeded
originally posted by: Teratoma
It appears to me that the artist was attempting a realistic rendering of something from a more symbolic/representational/iconic format; in this case a shield he'd only seen on coins. There is no reason to assume the artist had access to an actual round, Roman-era shield to use for reference.
It does appear obvious to me that the same symbolism is being depicted here, as much as I would like it to have been a spaceship.
What? Did you even compare the painting to the coin? Why is the shield on the painting not circular in shape? It is on the coin, which you suggest the artist duplicated.. I disagree
And why would he not had have access to a shield for reference? If not an accurate one, any shield would do.
The shield in the painting is clearly circular in shape, it just has a rounded serrated rim. It also clearly has a boss in the centre, which is exactly what you'd expect from a parma shield. The flower pedal (for lack of a better phrase) pattern admittedly doesn't seem particularly common from a few google searches, but it's well known that man has been making decorative weapons with unique patterns ever since we started working with metals.
It really makes no sense to fixate on the (apparently) unique decorative aspect of the shield as evidence of it being a flying saucer anyway. Since it doesn't fit with depictions of flying sauces at all, which are usually said to be smooth and rounded and don't have a boss in the centre.
I want to see proof of extraterritorial life as much (or more) as anyone, but it would just be incredibly naive to draw conclusions with evidence as circumstantial as this.
originally posted by: Phage
a reply to: intrptr
Found another version with the same theme. No historical records. Just a story started by Frank Edwards.
deliyannis.blogspot.com...
Furthermore, they [the Tyrians] would heat bronze shields in a blazing fire, fill them with hot sand and boiling excrement and suddenly hurl them from the walls.