It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Kali74
reply to post by Quadrivium
A better question is why aren't you concerned about what they are doing with their wealth? Because what they do with their wealth affects us all. I don't care about being that rich, I care about being able to survive. Billions of peoples ability to survive is at the economic desires of but a few.
History shows that people revolt for a variety of reasons and "wanting your stuff" is one of them--at least on the surface.
Quadrivium
reply to post by Visitor2012
Kali74
reply to post by Quadrivium
A better question is why aren't you concerned about what they are doing with their wealth? Because what they do with their wealth affects us all. I don't care about being that rich, I care about being able to survive. Billions of peoples ability to survive is at the economic desires of but a few.
And you believe all of these people to be evil?
What about the low end crooks stealing other's identities? Or those that actually make a living off of cheating the elderly and poor.
As I said before, I know that some of these people are scum bags but you don't need a lot of money to be a scum bag.
The fact of the matter is that many people need someone to blame. It makes them feel better to think that the situation they are in is someone else's fault.
But before we blame them for making our lives miserable and not trying to make the world a better place with their fortunes. We need to ask ourselves what we have done to make our lives and this world a better place.
It starts with each of us, not from the top, not from the bottom but from each and every one of us as individuals.
Quadedit on 20-1-2014 by Quadrivium because: (no reason given)
Spiramirabilis
It's about accountability - and fairness
It's about all of us being treated equally under the law
Maybe it's also about fairness of opportunity - which isn't the same as wealth
CIAGypsy
AthlonSavage
reply to post by stargatetravels
Is CiaGypsy on list?
Nope... My banks had a rather crappy week and I fell to #86.
Spiramirabilis
reply to post by beezzer
I care not for the cause of the revolt. I'm only all too aware of the aftermath.
Well, I guess that makes things easier for you - and it explains some things for me. Our positions are so much easier to defend if they aren't all mussed up with facts I guess :-)
So, you actually do not care what led up to the revolution?
Do you have any idea what the Russian people were living through at the time?
Do you think they were spoiled? Lazy? Ingrates? An aimless mob of wanton losers out to kill the Tsar for his Xbox and some cash?
Do you think things were pretty cool in Russia before the Commies showed up?
edit on 1/20/2014 by Spiramirabilis because: (no reason given)
Spiramirabilis
reply to post by Logarock
Well now I beg to differ.
Differ - with what?
What were the conditions in Russia prior to Stalin getting to have his say or his way with anything?
You think the whole thing started in 1917?
Sometimes we have a tendency to turn history into some kind of simplistic cartoon - don't we?
ImaFungi
reply to post by stargatetravels
Off with their heads!
stargatetravels
ImaFungi
reply to post by stargatetravels
Off with their heads!
Well i'm not advocating murder & decapitation, would much prefer a non-violent revolution.
There have been some amazing posts and posters in this thread and it's shown me that most people get it, they know the truth.
Spiramirabilis
reply to post by NavyDoc
History shows that people revolt for a variety of reasons and "wanting your stuff" is one of them--at least on the surface.
How about wanting some stuff?
People want and need hope. A chance to better their lives - a future. Some measure of safety and stability
If people are denied these things, take away freedom, a sense that there is some kind of justice and order - leave them with nothing to hold on to, nothing to look forward to...and you've got yourself people who have nothing to lose
You don't have to care about people - but you shouldn't be surprised that under certain conditions people lose their respect, their trust and their fear
It must be nice to ignore the outcome, regardless of what precipitated it.
What ended up happening in time is that party officials and cronies became wealthy, the people starved by the millions, hardly anyone could even afford bread and they had to open up a massive prison system to deal with decenters.
However, these desperate people are often manipulated by unscrupulous agitators from people who want equality under the law to people who just want stuff taken from those who seem to have more and given to them by force.