Reminder of the UK knives and offensive weapons law., page 2


Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 3 times


reply posted on 26-11-2012 @ 04:05 PM by CX
There appears to be a little confusion around the web on this matter of the legality of kubotans.

Here it says it is illegal to sell them.....so carrying them would be the same....


kubotan (cylindrical container, holding spikes)

Knives: The Law on buying and carrying



Some people say that the above description means that you are ok as long as the kubotan doesn't have spikes, but i think they are reading that wrong. They are reading it as though "if the kubotan holds spikes", it's illegal.

I read it as kubotans are illegal, so are holding spikes....as in a weapon that is a spike that you hold.

All i know is i got told about mine by a copper, and i've only ever carried the flat ended round one.

Very handy though, i have a few of them. You can get the official kubotan training manual for a few quid online, enough vids on them too.

CX.


reply posted on 26-11-2012 @ 05:06 PM by CX
reply to post by Vulcha



Last year i went into my local police station, talked to the police officer on the desk about if i could take a small bushcraft knife into the woods so me and the kids could use one. His answer was, a local copper probably would turn a blind eye, however the difficulty lies in if a passer by reports it.

If they got a report of a guy in the woods with a knife and a couple of kids, without doubt you'd have an armed repsonse team there pretty sharpish. He said you'd then have to explain it to the judge, and at the end of the day, if it's not for work, they are pretty strict on what is a decent reason to have one in public.

It's just for you to decide whether it's worth the risk.

As for the shotgun.....don't you need a reason for having one of those too? I didn't think it was as easy as you imply?

Thanks for the info though, always good to hear others experiences.

CX.

ETA: As for camping on public land......you can't in The New Forest....i know that much. Well.....can't get caught put it that way.
edit on 26/11/12 by CX because: (no reason given)



reply posted on 26-11-2012 @ 05:16 PM by DrumsRfun
reply to post by blupblup



Those sticks you mentioned,you can actually make.
Find it,fire harden it and you would be surprised how strong they are.
I challenge people to get 2 sticks the size of a pencil.
Harden one with fire and keep the other one as you found it.

After you made one strong with fire....test them both and you will see the difference.

Now take a stick the size of a jumbo hotdog but 3 feet long and fire harden it.....thats a weapon,and its free and its legal.
Its a walking stick.


Its so easy,even a caveman can do it.
edit on 26-11-2012 by DrumsRfun because: (no reason given)



reply posted on 26-11-2012 @ 05:20 PM by severdsoul
reply to post by Vulcha


That is good, at least it is not as bad as it
sounded.
thanks for the info


reply posted on 26-11-2012 @ 06:42 PM by PuterMan
reply to post by CX



Some people say that the above description means that you are ok as long as the kubotan doesn't have spikes, but i think they are reading that wrong. They are reading it as though "if the kubotan holds spikes", it's illegal.


It is all in the wording "container". If it is solid it is NOT a container, therefore one which does NOT contain spikes is NOT a weapon if the description is cylindrical container. It would be rather difficult to enforce a solid piece of wood or plastic as a weapon. Chopstick, Walking stick etc?


reply posted on 26-11-2012 @ 06:50 PM by CX
Originally posted by mr-lizard
The thing is.

We CAN go camping and hiking and such with knives. Police just don't expect anyone to have good reason to be carrying a non-foldable blade on the streets. Unless you can prove the blade is for work (maybe you need a knife for cutting tape while plumbing or maybe for fishing) but you need to prove it.

There are certain knives which are illegal and many of them are flick-knives or concealable blades. Saying that though, the police aren't going to bust you for taking a knife camping, but they'll bust you if they find you with one in the streets. Context.


Hi mr-Lizard, cheers for the reply.

Just to say......there is so much umming and arring over this.....so i just phoned Hampshire Police general enquiries, spoke to a lovely lady who said....

Regarding camping or "bushcraft" type stuff in the woods (a public place), anything with a blade over 3in is illegal for the average member of public. Has to be a folder too, non locking. A campsite would be classed as a public place due to the amount of public that also frequent it (even if it is owned by someone).

Fishing: Yep this would be deemed ok as you are doing a specific task with the knife, as long as you only do that specific task with the knife. I asked would doing a specific bushcraft or camping task not make it ok to carry something over 3in....she said no. I said, "Not even for carving bits of wood, cutting stuff for dens and the likes?" She said no.

So i guess it's a case of it's up to you to be sensible enough not to raise an eyebrow with a knife. Has to be pretty task orientated though to get away with it if you are pulled up. So whilst the police may not always bust you for carrying a larger knife camping or in the woods, it is illegal. Just pointing that out to a few people.

Thanks for all the replies anyway, always something to learn....much appreciated.

CX.
edit on 26/11/12 by CX because: (no reason given)



reply posted on 27-11-2012 @ 12:59 AM by Vulcha
reply to post by CX



It's ridiculous, isn't it? Maybe go for a big hike somewhere out the way where people are unlikely to show up? I don't know why, but the majority over here really do look down on weapon ownership of any kind.

With a shotgun, you don't need to give a specific reason to own one, and you don't need a land check. The police have to think of a reason why you can't have one. If you hav land to shoot on, you can say you want the shotgun for shooting pigeons, crows, rabbits, etc. They won't check the land. You need to give a reason to own a rifle. For example, if you wanted a .17hmr to shoot rabbits, or a .308 for deer, you have to have the land you shoot on checked to make sure it's safe to use the guns. If there don't happen to be any deer on said land, you won't get the .308. Basically, the police need to provide a reason for you to not have a shotgun, but you need to provide a reason to own a rifle.

Strangely, you can own a shotgun on a shotgun certificate that holds no more than two cartridges. You can have a shotgun with a non-detachable magazine such a a semi auto, provided the magazine holds two cartridges. If you want a higher capacity magazine, you have to go through the same procedure as a rifle to obtain a firearms certificate. This includes a land check. I don't understand why as the effective range would be the same as that of a shotgun with the lower capacity magazine.


reply posted on 27-11-2012 @ 05:43 AM by Vulcha
reply to post by CX



I've camped in Forestry Comission woods before. A place called Cann woods. We got caught a couple times and were asked to put out our fire, and another time we all got moved on. There are loads of mountain bile trails in Cann woods. I believe the Forestry Comission don't mind them being there, but accept no liability for any injuries folk sustain. Dartmoor is owned by the National Trust. You're allowed to camp but no fires, etc. Most everyone just digs a pit for their fires, then fill it when they leave. It's a pretty big place so you could probably have a giant bonfire and not get caught!

About carrying knives and things while camping, I always thought camping was a good enough reason. I think I should look in to this. All the laws on weapons here are pretty stupid. I firmly believe if you could own a gun for the reason of home defence, a lot less burglariea and home invasion type crimes would happen. Nobody seems to be fighting for change though.


reply posted on 27-11-2012 @ 07:16 PM by kawika
What about a pointed stick?



I consider the shotgun to be a purely defensive weapon. Now a rifle with a scope, that is an offensive weapon.
edit on 27-11-2012 by kawika because: (no reason given)

Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>    ^^TOP^^



The Oldest and Most Incredible Weapons System...Ever. The ATLATL.
  Posted 4 days ago with 58 member flags
Unemployed? Hate Your Crummy Job? Start Producing!
  Posted 4 days ago with 35 member flags
*Every U.S Army Field Manual in one location*
  Posted 9 days ago with 22 member flags
How To Survive Being Homeless In America
  Posted 7 days ago with 17 member flags
I was attacked last night, and didn\'t know what to do!
  Posted 11 days ago with 16 member flags
Prepping the right way for true survival
  Posted 8 days ago with 15 member flags
Meat in the Wilderness - What\'s that smell?
  Posted 12 days ago with 13 member flags