It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by bigfatfurrytexan
Let me ask you (and this is the second time I have posed this question in this thread)....exactly who is it that would consider themselves "lower class"? No matter how poor someone is, they will generally look at themselves as "middle class", even if near homeless. What differentiates lower and middle class? Is it really income? Because I know people with only welfare income who enjoy a better standard of living than myself (an executive with a wife that is a nurse). While anyone on Earth would call me "middle class", i would retort with "there is no middle class any more". And I feel it, too.
Originally posted by bigfatfurrytexan
So, how do you pit the "middle class" against the "lower class"? Does anyone really say that they are "lower class"? I would bet that most Americans see it as an insulting term (in this hypermaterialistic society that we have). And I doubt that many would self identify in such a manner, regardless of the reality of their circumstances.
Originally posted by bigfatfurrytexan
When you hear the term "lower class" used in politics, it is used during times of financial prosperity to help push social programs through by making people feel like they are helping out those poor unfortunate saps. When the prosperity ends, the political debate is about the "middle class", because to talk about "lower class" would alienate 99% of the nation. No one identifies as lower class, they only thing of others in that way.
Originally posted by Bluesma
The lower class ain't got no computers. They don't count none in this cyber werld.
I'm kidding. I am not in the US and don't know what all is up there.
(though I don't deny there isn't something to consider there, about the modern world and communication....)edit on 7-10-2012 by Bluesma because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by John_Rodger_Cornman
The lower class and impoverished classes are just a glorified political football. Used as a ends to a political means.
Originally posted by Ophiuchus 13
Originally posted by John_Rodger_Cornman
The lower class and impoverished classes are just a glorified political football. Used as a ends to a political means.
Which in some ways means they don't matter, wow nice to know I didn't matter when I was in the projects growing up hmmm. Wild thing is I knew I didnt as do many who still are growing up in those hoods smh
Originally posted by Pilot
I digress, not trying to be off topic, but when the systems are not constructed to favor certain individuals, and they ARE constructed to favor others, I look to the systems as the origin of "lower" classes existing in the first place.
A conceptual leap but I think still fairly on topic.
Originally posted by Pilot
I don't know why politicians say half the crap they say, usually it's diversionary, so to the point, they aren't discussing the poor because pretty soon, the poorest of the poor are going to be on their own. The drought that hit the states this year has sent food prices way up, and I'll bet food stamps won't be increased to make up the difference. Whomever gets the presidency will not have the power to do anything about it because by then we will be caught up in another military operation somewhere in the world, and money will be ever tighter, even for the mythical middle class.
Originally posted by Pilot
All this class talk is another divide and conquer bit. We are one species that certain members of which like to control and abuse the rest. There are issues both rich and poor can agree upon, but that won't happen, the divide is psychological concrete, and takes effort to break.
Rambling, but more on topic?
Originally posted by Logarock
Originally posted by Ophiuchus 13
Originally posted by John_Rodger_Cornman
The lower class and impoverished classes are just a glorified political football. Used as a ends to a political means.
Which in some ways means they don't matter, wow nice to know I didn't matter when I was in the projects growing up hmmm. Wild thing is I knew I didnt as do many who still are growing up in those hoods smh
Well if you ever ate off of food stamps or live by some government means you can thank the middle class......cause were thinkin about you.
Originally posted by ldyserenity
reply to post by Ophiuchus 13
It's because they think we're all just a bunch of lazy no good moocher whiners living off government subsidies, we are the new slave class (As far as rights and respect are concerned).
Originally posted by ldyserenity
. That doesn't make me lazy, that makes me someone with values tyvm.edit on 8-10-2012 by ldyserenity because: spelling
Originally posted by Ophiuchus 13
These bigfatfurrytexan are the people I am discussing but not only for there are some within middle class boundaries who if they experience a 'wrong turn' from the influences may be on their way to the next level down all based off of bad decision making from presidential candidates. This should be another reason for those close to actual lower class who are still lower middle class to want to keep in mind the lower class experiences. But it seems the lower class is looked at like well get up already do something (but with no real guidance)??? or plan for them to thrive? they vote too but I guess if they live in impoverishment areas their votes really dont count that much?
Originally posted by Pilot
reply to post by Ophiuchus 13
Enjoying your thread and everyone's responses. Thanks Ophichus.
one thing I have to admit is when I hear the word "class", I experience a visceral understanding of this word as an outmoded, old world construct, and at the same time a reality that is uncouth to discuss, like religion and politics. It is fairly driven into your head that our great democracy has transcended something so backward, like monarchy and a peerage.
Originally posted by Pilot
Yet you certainly experience the class differences in real life. It's just not a subject many people are willing to discuss freely in a reasonable manner.
Originally posted by Pilot
It's easy enough to imagine how shame is visited on the poor while still in childhood. When they get to school, they learn that the Dentist or Executives kid gets treated better by teachers, and they set the trends, etc. Those same privileged kids might grow up feeling a bit of shame and guilt for their privilege, and get jobs in the public sector, to help the poor.
Originally posted by Pilot
Can't we move on? I'm so booooored!! There is always an alternative. It is useful to ask, "what" at this point. I don't think we can pre-plan a revolution. I think what makes a revolution authentic is an energetic groundswell that emerges spontaneously, and cannot be predicted. I think it would be amazing to be a part of a non-violent revolution in my lifetime, we just have to imagine what it might look like, not try to have all the pieces of the puzzle in place beforehand. All we have to do is imagine.
Originally posted by bigfatfurrytexan
Most of what you describe is me.
Originally posted by bigfatfurrytexan
However, my question about who is "lower class" was mostly rhetorical, meant to catalyze thought.
When you ask, "why does no one talk about the lower class anymore? Do they not care?", the ansewr is simple: because of political speaking.
Originally posted by bigfatfurrytexan
Right now the majority of the nation would fall into the lower class. But no one wants to be called "lower class". So when the presidential debates, at the current moment, refer to "middle class relief", they are actually meaning "lower class relief". They are using the words that people self identify as.
When times are good, they refer to the "lower class" because the majority of people know they aren't hurting, and the bigger gain in votes comes from the feeling that the candidates give that they will help us be more charitable. It makes us feel pious when times are good to talk about helping those poor "lower class".
Originally posted by bigfatfurrytexan
Let me ask you this: are you concerned with the lower class because you, yourself, are struggling to make ends meet? Or because you are concerned about your fellow human? I don't ask this in any sarcastic way, so please don't take it as such. But your answer may, if put in the framework of the above, answer your initial question from the OP.
Originally posted by bigfatfurrytexan
BTW, for what its worth....i grew up poor oilfield trash. Life in the West Texas during the big bust years of the 80's was no cake walk. Matter of fact, I remember winning a cake at a cake walk, and how excited the whole family was to have it at home that night. I remember getting food from churches and food pantries. I remember having only 1 pair of Wrangler jeans for the school year (we couldn't afford the more fashionable Levi's). And wearing shoes bought from Safeway (nope...no social acceptance for me growing up). I remember the big Christmas my little sister had one year when she had her name selected from the Angel Tree by some very generous benefactor (who is still, to this day, anonymous to us). I have been there. I still work to be there. The poor...they are my people. Why do you think I do so well as a business manager? My people see me as "one of them", not "the man". Because I grew up with them. I think most of us have a similar story, to be honest.