Originally posted by Monsatan
But if they really were listening to the people we wouldn't have the electoral college (who can conveniently ignore the will of the people)
The Electoral College is bound by law to vote in the manner prescribed. They don't "conveniently ignore the will of the people." The mistake here
is assuming only the vote of the people matter and all votes should be strictly person to candidate. So once in awhile you have a candidate who wins
via the electoral college when the popular vote was very close, but opposite.
If there were no Electoral College, then the East and Eest Coast states would elect the President, and everyone iin any other state should just as
well stay home, including all the flyover states. Because of the nature of the Electoral College, candidates are forced to pay attention to all
states, even those with few electoral votes, because each one on its own could tip the election.
This was done originally quite on purpose in an attempt to keep the power out of the hands of the Federal government and in the hands of the states,
i.e.: States were considered equal partners in the Federal government because iot was teh States that agreed to form the union. The People had a
direct voice through the House and an indirect voice through the Senate. In other words, Senators were to be the representatives of the States, not
direct representatives of the people. The 17th amendment changed all that.
Now the argument is that the Electoral College should be eliminated, but look what we have done. The 17th amendment stripped states rights and gave
that power not to the people, but consolidated it in the Federal government and cutting the states completely out of governing the Federation.
Abolishing the Electoral College would complete the process. In wanting power for ourselves, we ceded it to an over-reaching government.
Next, we will be complaining about the power of the Federal government. well, if we give it to them, what do you expect? We killed what power the
states had, then we bemoan the fact that the Feds keep telling us what to do.