It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by adjensen
Originally posted by AllIsOne
reply to post by adjensen
... but respect the fact that they have conclusions, that they're as entitled to them as you are, and that they likely feel as "right" as you do, even if you disagree 100%.
No, nobody is entitled to be a child molester
Kind of playing Devil's Advocate at this point for obvious reasons, but, as I said the issue is about whether a person is entitled to their own opinion, regardless of what that opinion is and whether you agree with it or not, are you suggesting that mind control or lobotomies would be reasonable treatments for persons who exhibited the beliefs (not behaviours -- there's nothing to say that someone who thinks child abuse is fine could think that without ever acting on it) that you think no one should be entitled to?
Do you have a right to lobotomize someone for believing something, whether they act on it or not?
Originally posted by dominicus
.......I found that there definitely is One. After this direct experience ...
Originally posted by AllIsOne
Yes, somebody who is even thinking about molesting a child needs serious treatment. Do you really want to argue that ... ???
Originally posted by adjensen
Originally posted by AllIsOne
Yes, somebody who is even thinking about molesting a child needs serious treatment. Do you really want to argue that ... ???
Like I said, once one moves to an extreme such as this, the ability to argue is curtailed.
But do I believe that someone (in a general sense) should be lobotomized for their thoughts, assuming that they'd not acted on them? No, I do not believe that to be appropriate, I am not a proponent of the concept of "thoughtcrime".
Originally posted by AllIsOne
Originally posted by adjensen
Originally posted by AllIsOne
Yes, somebody who is even thinking about molesting a child needs serious treatment. Do you really want to argue that ... ???
Like I said, once one moves to an extreme such as this, the ability to argue is curtailed.
But do I believe that someone (in a general sense) should be lobotomized for their thoughts, assuming that they'd not acted on them? No, I do not believe that to be appropriate, I am not a proponent of the concept of "thoughtcrime".
Sorry, but I have a hard time following you. Treating a person (psychologically) for deranged thoughts of child molestation is extreme?
So presumably I'd get your subjective experience and somehow believe in Invisible Magic Man. Okay. One thing I don't believe you explained is how this would "solve all the world's problems eventually".
Originally posted by Pinke
As much as this is a joke ... there is just certain people whose perspectives I might never want to see.
Can you imagine feeling deep compassion for a sex offender's point of view? Or for Rick Astley's?
It's too terrible to contemplate.
Originally posted by adjensen
Originally posted by AllIsOne
Yes, somebody who is even thinking about molesting a child needs serious treatment. Do you really want to argue that ... ???
Like I said, once one moves to an extreme such as this, the ability to argue is curtailed.
But do I believe that someone (in a general sense) should be lobotomized for their thoughts, assuming that they'd not acted on them? No, I do not believe that to be appropriate, I am not a proponent of the concept of "thoughtcrime".
Originally posted by AllIsOne
reply to post by Deaf Alien
Do you have children?
I never talked about surgery, that was brought up by the other guy ...
Originally posted by Deaf Alien
Originally posted by AllIsOne
reply to post by Deaf Alien
Do you have children?
I never talked about surgery, that was brought up by the other guy ...
I apologize. I haven't read the whole thread. Besides what does having children have to do with anything?
If there is a technology that causes everybody to understand each other... why they feel they way they do, their perspectives, etc... do you think we will still have the problems we have today?