World War II, why is it so important?, page 1
Pages: <<  1    2  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 2 times
Topic started on 23-12-2009 @ 12:48 AM by Bananarama
I was watching a couple of videos on Youtube just now. One was saying that the amount of Jewish casualties during WW2 have been heavily inflated. One was a man saying that there could not have been gas chambers in Germany.

At the moment, I don't know enough to comment on those. But those led me to thinking; Why is it that I am ALWAYS hearing about WW2, I am CONSTANTLY reminded of it. It seems like, here in North America, we are always made to feel really bad about it, and especially bad for the Jews. Many more people died trying to save the Jews by 1945, shouldn't it be the Russians complaining? In fact, why exactly did so many people die for the Jews?

There have been so many times in history when many people have died. Millions upon millions of people from Africa were killed and enslaved during the colonization of the New World. During that same time, millions of natives died because of the new colonies. I think some black people and some natives have exploited these facts for their own pity, but if you compare the number of deaths, the number of Jewish people who died seems almost insignificant.

This could go on longer. I could bring up the Jewish bankers who helped fund Hitler in the first place. In the end, I just think that there are so many perspectives in this world I am missing because one event is constantly being brought up. I'd like to hear about Russia, China, Korea, even the famous Rwanda. It's not just WW2 that has happened, and it's not just Jewish people who have died. I would certainly like to hear about WW2 if I could just hear a bit about the rest of the world, and the other two millenia before those times.


reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 01:50 AM by TaraLou
reply to post by Bananarama



WW2 was evil - it killed many people - the soldiers, the Jews, Gay people. gypsies and it annihilated whole countries.

All wars are evil - please live your life without another war.

Blessings to you.



reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 01:55 AM by MAC269
reply to post by Bananarama



Dear Bananarama

I am going to make a guess here that you are African American??? Certainly American.

Ok first off WW2 was not about the Jews not even a little bit.

It might even have been the first James Bond plot. It was about stopping world domination by the Nazis.

The situation with the Jews was not known to the allies until the very last few week of the war. The high command is another matter.

You are right about the Russians though with 20 million dead they are the ones who suffered.

In short WW2 was the one war that had to be fort, but one dose wonder what today’s world would be like if the allies had lost.


reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 02:24 AM by Monts
reply to post by Bananarama



If you look up any history books, the era from 1945-present is always referred to as the post-modern era. Why post? Because WW2 was an event that pushed humanity beyond what some call the point of no return, from a humanistic approach.

The Nazi's performed absolutely horrific experiments on jews, handicaps, blacks, gays, and any other people they deemed unworthy; from conscious experimental brain surgery to tying the legs of a pregnant woman when she goes into labor. However horrific these experiments were (they would fit in well in the SAW movies), humanity gained a lot of knowledge from these experiments, and much of modern medicine's technology has come from these experiments. Medical education has been using Nazi slides and pictures as recent as the 90's. Humanity crossed the point of no return.

If that isn't reason enough to make it matter, don't forget that what separated this war from all the rest was that this one was based upon race. Wars in the past were fought over resources, feud's, and freedom. This one was fought over race. Never before had a nation's top priority been the extinction of a race. Regardless of what these videos say, Millions of Jews died at the hands of Nazi's; whether they were slaved to death, shot, gassed, burned, beaten, whatever you call it. It is a KNOWN FACT that the holocaust became the top priority of the Nazi's agenda. As the war came closer to an end, instead of funneling resources and power to defending themselves, they used whatever resources they had left to kill more Jews.

This is fact. Whether or not the figure is exaggerated, the motive remains the same.

So WW2 matters, and always will, because it was a time when the people of the world united together to face evil, and vanquished it. WW2 became a changing point in the world's history, where people being killed because of their race was no longer acceptable. Sure it happens all the time today, but we all know it is wrong. Saying that Jewish bankers financed the Nazi's means nothing, because using this as a base for an argument implies that race matters, which was the whole problem to begin with.

I can't help but feel you are being extremely ignorant in asking such a question. If it weren't for the sacrifice of our grandfathers and fathers, the world would be a much different place right now. Millions of people gave up their lives so that we can live in this free world, and no matter how bad things may be now, I would choose this world any day over a world ruled by Nazi's. It's because of their sacrifice that you can be sitting at home expressing your opinion without being afraid.

In fact, it is probably because of this sacrifice that you are even alive at all.

Remember that.


reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 03:59 AM by Bananarama
Originally posted by MAC269
reply to
post by Bananarama



Dear Bananarama

I am going to make a guess here that you are African American??? Certainly American.

Ok first off WW2 was not about the Jews not even a little bit.

It might even have been the first James Bond plot. It was about stopping world domination by the Nazis.

The situation with the Jews was not known to the allies until the very last few week of the war. The high command is another matter.

You are right about the Russians though with 20 million dead they are the ones who suffered.

In short WW2 was the one war that had to be fort, but one dose wonder what today’s world would be like if the allies had lost.

I honestly don't know why you made that assumption, but I am not black and I am not American. Other races and other countries can show disinterest in WW2 also.


reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 04:16 AM by Dookie Master
i]reply to post by Bananarama



From an academic point of view there are three changes that occured to sway international relations in the world during the twentieth century.

First, would be World War 1 because it involved many new instruments of war, helped foment a revolution that would affect the world for most of the century and began to change the balance of power in the world.

Second, would be the Second World War (imagine that. Not only, as a poster mentioned above, was this a full world war, it introduced Nuclear Power to the world and it caused many European nations to change their colonization policy. This war completely changed the balance of power in the world, completely shifting away from Western Europe for the rest of the century.

Finally, in the last years of the century and the first years of the next, we have had much of our previous methodologies turned end up with the advent of the "global war on terror" and the loss of individual nations sovereignty to that of trading blocks (E.U., Asean, UN, NAFTA)

But, of course you will only be interested in the statements in the paragraph about WWII.

Notice I did not mention the loss of however many Jewish persons. That can be considered one of the worst losses of human life in the history of the world. Also, as an above poster listed, the loss of Soviet lives were devestating as well.

Also, you could really get into a slippery slope argument when stating which groups losses were worse. I always like to refresh my memory of John Donne's "Meditation 17"


"...No man is an island, entire of itself; every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main. If a clod be washed away by the sea, Europe is the less, as well as if a promontory were, as well as if a manor of thy friend's or of thine own were. Any man's death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind; and therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee..."


[edit on 23-12-2009 by Dookie Master]


reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 05:57 AM by ItsallCrazy
reply to post by ThePeoplesSoldier



The entire second World War wasn't just about the holocaust mate.. it was about world domination and a race for the atomic bomb. And just the Jews didn't suffer, everyone suffered. The German people included. Because of the insanity of one man, pretty much like whats happening now (but maybe that could be expanded to 3 or 4 people in our time)

And your millions figure could be way off the mark, it's highly contested how many people were gassed or shot, but regardless of the figure it wasn't just lines and lines of Jews. It was poles, russians, any other europeans thats stood in their way, homosexuals.

Hitler was pretty much after everyone except decent physical specimens of humanity. I personally believe the level of purely Jewish killed during the Holocaust has been exaggerated beyond epic proportion.

Millions suffered, not just jews. People crying over persecution of Jews is getting sooo old now


reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 06:04 AM by ThePeoplesSoldier
reply to post by ItsallCrazy



Oh no I totally agree I know alot about WW2 im a HUGE history buff, I just thought that since he commented on the fact that the jews really didnt suffer that much I would point out that fact. That war was HUGE. You could make the most epic action movie ever about it. It was Good vs Bad, Evil vs rightous, Hitler attempting to control the world and with one mighty fist the allies standing up and saying NO WE SHALL NOT BE CONQUERED BY THE LIKES OF YOU! Backs against the wall and all odds stacked against them the allies prevail in the face of evil! Wow that would be a bad ass movie.



reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 06:27 AM by ItsallCrazy
reply to post by ThePeoplesSoldier



Well we're on the same page then

It's an incredibly dark but nonetheless interesting chapter in the history of man, there will still be mountains of stuff that went on that we won't know about for years or possibly ever know.

And yeah it could be an absolutely epic film.. or even a trilogy. Just not a pile of crap like Valkyrie, and maybe some German actors this time, not Tom Cruise thinking he's still doing Mission Impossible

Just edited cos I read your sig line - I like it!

[edit on 23-12-2009 by ItsallCrazy]


reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 06:51 AM by Muckster
reply to post by purplemonkey





Poland - joint invasion by Germany and the USSR, germany was recapturing territory that previously belonged to them (prussia)


Wrong.... Hitler invaded Poland for Lebensraum... He promised this to the German people on many occasions before the outbreak of war. Hitler considered the people who lived in Eastern Europe as inferior and sub-human... The land that they lived on was chosen for the expansion of Hitler’s "master" race.


Without consideration of "traditions" and prejudices, it [Germany] must find the courage to gather our people and their strength for an advance along the road that will lead this people from its present restricted living space to new land and soil, and hence also free it from the danger of vanishing from the earth or of serving others as a slave nation.
--- Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf 1


Notice what Hitler says here?? "New land and soil" not recapture old lands as you claim!!!



Holland - They needed it as a way of getting into france, defensive.


If someone who lives in my street threatens to beat me up does that give me the right to bulldoze my innocent neighbour’s house so that I may get gain easier access to the threat??

I'm sorry but that’s a pathetic excuse!!



France - the french declared war on germany, it was defensive



No... France was being defensive... Are you are forgetting what France suffered in WW1??? France had to watch as the German war machine went into gear once again... do you blame France for being worried??? Britain and France gave Hitler an ultimatum... "Do NOT invade Poland" Hitler ignored it and so War was declared.







Czechoslovakia - Large number of ethnic germans, hitler wanted to 'protect' them.


Again this is an excuse... Could Hitler not have just opened the doors to any ethnic Germans living in Czechoslovakia???





Russia - If the germans didn't invade the USSR the USSR would of declared war on germany, and their industrial machine would of over powered germany's if they left it to long. I think the americans call this Preemptive war *cough* iraq *cough*, however in this case it was actually legitament.


The relationship that existed between Russia and Germany was complex and both sides wanted to buy time. However, Hitler had already hinted in Mein Kampf (1925) that he wanted to invade Russia...

For centuries Russia drew nourishment from this Germanic nucleus of its upper leading strata. Today it can be regarded as almost totally exterminated and extinguished. It has been replaced by the Jew. Impossible as it is for the Russian by himself to shake off the yoke of the Jew by his own resources, it is equally impossible for the Jew to maintain the mighty empire forever. He himself is no element of organization, but a ferment of decomposition. The Persian empire in the east is ripe for collapse. And the end of Jewish rule in Russia will also be the end of Russia as a state.
--- Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf


That’s Hitler’s own words... hate filled megalomaniac xenophobe nut job who got defeated by the very Race’s he viewed as inferior!!



Oh... and as a final note... The decision to invade Poland was far from popular with the average German...

What does that tell you about Hitler as a leader? A man who ignores the will of his people (who he claims to cherish) in favour of his own personal aspirations!!!

[edit on 23-12-2009 by Muckster]


reply posted on 23-12-2009 @ 07:04 AM by redoubt
reply to post by Bananarama




Why is it that I am ALWAYS hearing about WW2, I am CONSTANTLY reminded of it. It seems like, here in North America, we are always made to feel really bad about it, and especially bad for the Jews. Many more people died trying to save the Jews by 1945, shouldn't it be the Russians complaining? In fact, why exactly did so many people die for the Jews?


You seem to have a very narrow view to see the broad expanse of history. Millions did not die for the Jews. Unless you selectively choose to deny it, it was actually the Jews, the Russians and the Chinese that saw millions upon millions killed by a raging fascism that threatened the entire planet.

WW2 is an important event because the world came very close to a new dark age and it was only through the sacrifice of so many that we are here to even talk about it freely today.

And yes, I am biased. Our family saw one member die flying a B-17 over Germany in 1944 and another terribly wounded when his tank was hit in North Africa. So if you want to dismiss my opinion, please feel free. I just gave you license to do so. But I would merely suggest that you not be so quick to join contemporary, political if not wholly distorted views of WW2... or any other single point in history.

Humanity's many mistakes are all there in history books and if we have the slightest interest in avoiding repeat performances of some of those most horrible, regrettable moments, we should take it all to heart and not spew it back out as if there were meaningless to us in our current lives.

Best
Pages: <<  1    2  >>    ^^TOP^^



Main Stream Media Taking It To Far!!
  Posted 15 days ago with 22 member flags
Iranian Aircraft Carriers in the Gulf of Mexico
  Posted 10 days ago with 10 member flags
A few questions for those of you who hate the Confederate flag
  Posted 11 days ago with 9 member flags
Why Do You Insist On Doing This?
  Posted 2 days ago with 9 member flags
Getting off of oil.
  Posted 12 days ago with 7 member flags
***Overwhelming Debt? Here Are A Few Steps To Help!!***
  Posted 3 days ago with 7 member flags

Newest topics getting replies, in real-time:

Santorum wants more fracking!!!
  US Political Madness, Posted 10 hours ago, 53 replies
Pass Me My Rifle
  World War Three, Posted 6 hours ago, 49 replies