It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by DoomsdayRex
You are cherry-picking. On the one hand, you accept this as the genuine article, taking him at his word and nothing else that this is an actual transmission between Discovery and Houston. However, when the same source admits there may be something else to it, that it may not be genuine, you dismiss it because it is not what you want to hear.
Originally posted by ratcals
I have obtained a copy of the original recordings for mission STS-29 directly from NASA...
Currently I am listening to them to see if I can find the conversation and discern what was said.
Originally posted by ratcals
Once and if I find the specific conversation I will make it available. I could put the entire thing on ATS but there are ten files equaling 1.6g of information.
Originally posted by ratcals
....Once and if I find the specific conversation I will make it available. I could put the entire thing on ATS but there are ten files equaling 1.6g of information.
Originally posted by Cmdraleon
....
Don't believe for a moment that Nasa does not know whats going on.
If someone formerly with Nasa tells you this .
Do not accept it as gospel truth.
Remember those that do not want the truth to be told will play both sides of the game.
Originally posted by Phage
Here's what Donald Ratsch, the one who recorded the transmission (and supposedly a MUFON member) says ;
About a year after that, I was again monitoring the audio from another
NASA mission via my scanner and I heard that voice again, saying something
similar to the target voice a year earlier. However on this mission, all the
astronauts were different compared to the other one. This led me to conclude
that unfortunately, the target voice was a hoax probably from an amateur
radio operator.
www.ufoseek.org...
Originally posted by JimOberg
Originally posted by Cmdraleon
....
Don't believe for a moment that Nasa does not know whats going on.
If someone formerly with Nasa tells you this .
Do not accept it as gospel truth.
Remember those that do not want the truth to be told will play both sides of the game.
CDR, there's some interesting discussions going on here about original investigations of unsubstantiated claims. There are adults at work on real puzzles. Take the wax out of your ears and listen up. You clearly so far have been unable to engage in a give-and-take.
Being defensive about realizing one has fallen for a hoax -- as some here seem to have -- is a normal emotional reaction. Embarrassed at one's own ineptitude, such a victim tries to save their ego by trying to persuade others to fall for the same hoax -- to widen the circle of victims so they don't stand out.
Does that look like what you are doing?
Grownups learn to deal with it, learn, and move on. Please join us.
Briefly I recorded some of the radio broadcast via my audio scanner from the space shuttle Discovery through WA3NAN, the club station of the Goddard Amateur Radio Club at Greenbelt, Md, transmitting on 147.450 MHZ. It is a retransmission from the NASA Select original.
Originally posted by Cmdraleon
A video compiled secret Nasa Audio transmissions that some of which clearly states they are watching ET Craft .
Nasa would like to say they know nothing and are searching for Intelligent life elsewhere.
It seems Nasa knows alot more then they wish the public at large to know.
Nasa has always known this was the case .
Whenever a Space Shuttle goes up and outside the Earths atmosphere you can rest assured that Nasa is getting reports of these Craft on another frequency that is not public.
The video contains audio transmission from various Nasa flights into Space from the 1960's onward .
You can clearly on this video here the Astronaut say "We Still Have The Alien Spacecraft Under Observance" Discovery Mission date 3/13/1989 Astronaut talking to Hoston.
Nasa knows and they have lied to the People all of these years .
I hope this video is not taken off Yoytube .
Everyone needs to see this and let others see it who do not believe .
Blessings and Peace,
CmdrAleon
Originally posted by ratcals
Well if the link Phage provided above is anything to go by then it is a hoax. Especially when coupled with the recordings I have. The alleged conversation took place at 0642EST. The first recording I listened to covers all the way up to 0950EST. There was no mention of any alien spacecraft, fire, or a change of frequency. There were, howver, several conversations regarding communication problems. I hesitate to add that because I know it will cause some to jump to conclusions. Although there is and admittance of comm problems at no time during the recordings did I feel anything had been left out. Disclaimer: I am not an expert.
YR MO DA TAPE CATALOG MISSION DESCRIPT GMT-ST GMT-END MET-ST MET-END LOC-ST LOC-END
89 03 13 01 940-AAI STS-29 Mission Audio and Selected Air to Ground 1 1/4" Voxed contains Launch at 08:57am CST 2:53 072:09:08 072:15:50 T-03:40 000:00:54 03:08a 09:50a
Originally posted by Phage
reply to post by SeeingBlue
It was not recorded directly from the shuttle transmission.
Briefly I recorded some of the radio broadcast via my audio scanner from the space shuttle Discovery through WA3NAN, the club station of the Goddard Amateur Radio Club at Greenbelt, Md, transmitting on 147.450 MHZ. It is a retransmission from the NASA Select original.
www.ufoseek.org...
Originally posted by Cmdraleon
How do you know the Astronauts audio is out of text?
How is it out of text?
Originally posted by Cmdraleon
I take it from your post you do not believe this happened ?
Let me ask you a simple question do you trust Nasa?
Do you believe that Nasa has nothing to hide ?
Originally posted by Cmdraleon
Again until I see real proof that this Audio was faked which sofar the attemps shown in another post from my perspective was weak at best.
Originally posted by JimOberg
Ratsch never claimed he recorded the shuttle transmission. He always made it clear -- and he is a careful, diligent researcher, unlike others -- he was recording the retransmission of the air-to-ground sent out by a Greenbelt, Maryland, amateur radio club.
Didn't you know that?