If a previous civilization had even a fraction of the technology that we have today, would that technology or even a small minute portion have
survived?
If for instance they invented something similar to our modern day computer, or even similar to the computers of the 60’s and 70’s, would anything
have survived over time? If these things would not survive can we be sure that the ancient civilizations did not have such things and perhaps had a
written language that they stored on these “computers”, which in turn would earn them the right of an advanced civilization?
I am not making a statement that they had these things, just asking a what if question.
What constitutes an advanced civilization?, page 4
privacy
reply posted on 2-9-2009 @ 05:17 PM by Scott Creighton
reply to post by AlienCarnage
Hello Alien Carnage,
Good question. To me, however, the entire question of what earns an ancient civilisation the right to be regarded by us here in the 21st century CE as 'advanced' is fairly subjective, the goalposts of which are always shifting as new discoveries of our ancestors are made that changes what we know (or thought we knew) of them. And it is not all about physical artefacts, albeit this is the best form of evidence that allows us to determine a particular culture/civilisation's technological advancement.
Did the ancients understand that the Earth was a sphere? I think the answer is unequivocally "yes". Did the anicents navigate the Earth's oceans and trade with the AMericas? I think there is a very strong argument in favour of this. Did the ancients understand the precession of the stars and could they calculate and project their precessional motion, something most of us require modern computers to do? Again - I think the answer is a resounding "yes". So, 'advanced knowledge' does not always equate with nor does it necessarily transcend into the production of advanced physical artefacts.
The ancients may have KNOWN how to make an A-Bomb but simply chose not to do so - metaphorically speaking, of course.
Regards,
Scott Creighton
Hello Alien Carnage,
AlienCarnage: If these things [modern computers] would not survive can we be sure that the ancient civilizations did not have such things and perhaps had a written language that they stored on these “computers”, which in turn would earn them the right of an advanced civilization?
Good question. To me, however, the entire question of what earns an ancient civilisation the right to be regarded by us here in the 21st century CE as 'advanced' is fairly subjective, the goalposts of which are always shifting as new discoveries of our ancestors are made that changes what we know (or thought we knew) of them. And it is not all about physical artefacts, albeit this is the best form of evidence that allows us to determine a particular culture/civilisation's technological advancement.
Did the ancients understand that the Earth was a sphere? I think the answer is unequivocally "yes". Did the anicents navigate the Earth's oceans and trade with the AMericas? I think there is a very strong argument in favour of this. Did the ancients understand the precession of the stars and could they calculate and project their precessional motion, something most of us require modern computers to do? Again - I think the answer is a resounding "yes". So, 'advanced knowledge' does not always equate with nor does it necessarily transcend into the production of advanced physical artefacts.
The ancients may have KNOWN how to make an A-Bomb but simply chose not to do so - metaphorically speaking, of course.
Regards,
Scott Creighton
reply posted on 3-9-2009 @ 09:22 PM by AlienCarnage
reply to post by Byrd
Okay I know I was stretching a bit by implicating they might have had parallel tech to our own, but the reason i was asking was to find answers to what would be left of technology from a previous age.
The reason for trying to find that out has mainly to due with the Antikythera Mechanism I know this subject has been brought up before, but what evidence was left behind that led to it's development?
I know it appears to be some kind of astrological device, but the design of it is what I am questioning. We already know that the Greeks were advanced for their time in several different aspects but the interworkings were advanced even in Greek terms.is it possible there were other such devices, is it possible they evolved beyond this device, or were they at the end of their period of development when this device was created?
[edit on 9/3/2009 by AlienCarnage]
Okay I know I was stretching a bit by implicating they might have had parallel tech to our own, but the reason i was asking was to find answers to what would be left of technology from a previous age.
The reason for trying to find that out has mainly to due with the Antikythera Mechanism I know this subject has been brought up before, but what evidence was left behind that led to it's development?
I know it appears to be some kind of astrological device, but the design of it is what I am questioning. We already know that the Greeks were advanced for their time in several different aspects but the interworkings were advanced even in Greek terms.is it possible there were other such devices, is it possible they evolved beyond this device, or were they at the end of their period of development when this device was created?
[edit on 9/3/2009 by AlienCarnage]
reply posted on 3-9-2009 @ 09:44 PM by Byrd
Originally posted by AlienCarnage
reply to post by Byrd
Okay I know I was stretching a bit by implicating they might have had parallel tech to our own, but the reason i was asking was to find answers to what would be left of technology from a previous age.
I actually understood what you intended.
My answer still stands -- things don't just magically appear. The civilization has to have the
technology to produce it. The reason for trying to find that out has mainly to due with the Antikythera Mechanism I know this subject has been brought up before, but what evidence was left behind that led to it's development?
Although it may have been its inventor's prototype, there already was brass, gold, silver, and bronze jewelry and items for gods' temples that show equally detailed work. There's (on paper) tables of hours and the civilizations of the era had been using wheels, screws, and cogs (I believe... Roman use, certainly). Like the Baghdad batteries of the same era, none of the materials are amazingly out of place for what they knew, and the detail work is in line with what they were doing in jewelry and art.
I know it appears to be some kind of astrological device, but the design of it is what I am questioning.
Astronomical... or so I think I've read... rather than astrological.
We already know that the Greeks were advanced for their time in several different aspects but the interworkings were advanced even in Greek terms.is it possible there were other such devices, is it possible they evolved beyond this device, or were they at the end of their period of development when this device was created?
It was during the rise of the great Roman engineers that this occurred. I think it's a unique device, but I have heard there were some similar things (I'm in a hurry and don't have time to look these up right now.) I think that if it hadn't been lost at sea in an accident, we might have had its inventor's name and known more about it.
My own speculation is that he was on board the ship when it went down. I have no way of knowing whether this is true -- it's just guesswork that we might have had someone in that time period who was the equivalent of Leonardo da Vinci. Hieron was an earlier engineer who invented (among other things) steam power, so these kinds of inventive minds show up in all cultures and ages. Their limits are only the materials and manufacturing available to the people at that tiime.
reply posted on 3-9-2009 @ 09:57 PM by punkinworks
reply to post by AlienCarnage
The Antikythera mechaism is a celestial position calculator, basically its a really complicated hand crank clock, it says so right on it
You enter a date via a crank, then by cranking it with other handles? you could find the positions of the sun and moon and possibly all five planets known to the ancient greeks, on any given day, and a bunch of other reaally amazing date/time cycles.
The Antikythera mechanism also represent the pinacle of ancient greek mechanical engineering.
But its nothing that cant be made given an understanding of these basic concepts, geometry( the greeks were well known for thier understanding of geo), basic mathematics (they were also very good a trigonometry)
Once you know those two basic principals a geared mechanism is only just a bunch of tedious math away.
It wasnt the only thing of its kind im sure, but the only one that still exists.
There were couple of large mechancal clocks in different places in greece at the time.
The Antikythera mechaism is a celestial position calculator, basically its a really complicated hand crank clock, it says so right on it
You enter a date via a crank, then by cranking it with other handles? you could find the positions of the sun and moon and possibly all five planets known to the ancient greeks, on any given day, and a bunch of other reaally amazing date/time cycles.
The Antikythera mechanism also represent the pinacle of ancient greek mechanical engineering.
But its nothing that cant be made given an understanding of these basic concepts, geometry( the greeks were well known for thier understanding of geo), basic mathematics (they were also very good a trigonometry)
Once you know those two basic principals a geared mechanism is only just a bunch of tedious math away.
It wasnt the only thing of its kind im sure, but the only one that still exists.
There were couple of large mechancal clocks in different places in greece at the time.
reply posted on 3-9-2009 @ 10:12 PM by AlienCarnage
reply to post by punkinworks
This one device was almost lost and to me, it makes me ponder what other ingenious other devices they may have been able to come up with that may have been lost to time.
Just how close were they to making further advances in our direction before their decline.
I have read in the first century AD, that Heron of Alexandria was close to inventing steam power. see link below.
modelengines.info...
< - - - Posted the last before I read Byrd's reply - - - >
[edit on 9/3/2009 by AlienCarnage]
This one device was almost lost and to me, it makes me ponder what other ingenious other devices they may have been able to come up with that may have been lost to time.
Just how close were they to making further advances in our direction before their decline.
I have read in the first century AD, that Heron of Alexandria was close to inventing steam power. see link below.
modelengines.info...
< - - - Posted the last before I read Byrd's reply - - - >
[edit on 9/3/2009 by AlienCarnage]
reply posted on 3-9-2009 @ 10:35 PM by AlienCarnage
reply to post by Byrd
I read so many different sources from many different subjects, I do miss much, which is why I come here to ATS to help fill in the missing pieces.
Where I don't think that ancient civilizations were advanced enough to say have flying machines, I do think that they may have had the potential for such things, shown in artwork and sketches of some of the visionaries of the past. The devices depicted may have not been working, but it does show the ingenuity.
Does make you wonder if these ingenious people show up in recorded history, were there any in prehistory? Were there any attempts at actually creating envisioned devices, or were they merely in the inventors imaginations and plans only?
BTW, I always love reading your answers, no matter the thread.
I read so many different sources from many different subjects, I do miss much, which is why I come here to ATS to help fill in the missing pieces.
Where I don't think that ancient civilizations were advanced enough to say have flying machines, I do think that they may have had the potential for such things, shown in artwork and sketches of some of the visionaries of the past. The devices depicted may have not been working, but it does show the ingenuity.
Does make you wonder if these ingenious people show up in recorded history, were there any in prehistory? Were there any attempts at actually creating envisioned devices, or were they merely in the inventors imaginations and plans only?
BTW, I always love reading your answers, no matter the thread.
reply posted on 3-9-2009 @ 11:30 PM by punkinworks
reply to post by AlienCarnage
In an engineering history class I had, a text we used, mentioned a roman who was experimenting with magnetism and electricity in the 4th? century.
I wish i could remember his name, I think he had gotten as far a wrapping a bar of iron with copper wire, and maybe hooking it up to a battery used for electroplating.
The author of the book figured that they were only a 100 or years from learning to generate electricity at that point, but the turmoil that engulfed the empire in the following years made certain that it didnt happen.
he postulated if certain things hadnt happened and and certain things did, man might have made it to the moon 500 years ago.
Also even though the romans were brilliant practical engineers they werent much for the theoretical endevors that are required to reach the age of electricity, which is the real advancement.
And without the mathematics of calculas it would be all but impossible to understand what you were really doing.
In an engineering history class I had, a text we used, mentioned a roman who was experimenting with magnetism and electricity in the 4th? century.
I wish i could remember his name, I think he had gotten as far a wrapping a bar of iron with copper wire, and maybe hooking it up to a battery used for electroplating.
The author of the book figured that they were only a 100 or years from learning to generate electricity at that point, but the turmoil that engulfed the empire in the following years made certain that it didnt happen.
he postulated if certain things hadnt happened and and certain things did, man might have made it to the moon 500 years ago.
Also even though the romans were brilliant practical engineers they werent much for the theoretical endevors that are required to reach the age of electricity, which is the real advancement.
And without the mathematics of calculas it would be all but impossible to understand what you were really doing.
reply posted on 4-9-2009 @ 04:25 AM by Scott Creighton
reply to post by Hanslune
SC: And it is a dead certainty that our descendants, a few hundred years from now, will be saying the very same thing about us.
SC
[edit on 4/9/2009 by Scott Creighton]
Hans: It is always amazing how they chose not to do these thing while a few believed them capable of amazing thing, which again, they elected to do, but not easier more valuable things.
SC: And it is a dead certainty that our descendants, a few hundred years from now, will be saying the very same thing about us.
SC
[edit on 4/9/2009 by Scott Creighton]
reply posted on 4-9-2009 @ 10:42 AM by Byrd
Originally posted by AlienCarnage
reply to post by Byrd
Does make you wonder if these ingenious people show up in recorded history, were there any in prehistory?
They do. We tend to have a western civilization bias about our information, but they show up all over. And in prehistory, yes... otherwise we wouldn't have gone much beyond walking around the grasslands looking for food and running from leopards.
Were there any attempts at actually creating envisioned devices, or were they merely in the inventors imaginations and plans only?
There are a lot of devices around, from automated vending machines (dating back 2,000-3,000 years) that dispensed soap and water so you could ritually wash before entering the temple... and on and on and on.
And that's just the West. In China they had things like fairly sensitive earthquake detectors (off the top of my head).
So there's a lot of it around. Sometimes the inventors are known, sometimes not. But this is how we all advance... the brilliant and not-so-brilliant taking a chance and crafting new things.
reply posted on 5-9-2009 @ 11:13 PM by Hanslune
reply to post by Scott Creighton
Probably not as they will have more detailed records and will in general be more capable of making rational decisions. Instead of making stuff up.
Probably not as they will have more detailed records and will in general be more capable of making rational decisions. Instead of making stuff up.
reply posted on 5-9-2009 @ 11:55 PM by Phage
reply to post by Hanslune
It's a nice idea but I wouldn't count on an increase in rational thought or an increased aversion to making stuff up. I think our general capacity for both has been pretty much unchanged for 30 or 40 thousand years.
It's the ones who excel in rational thought and studiously avoid making things up that have gotten us where we are. They have been few, but they are the ones we owe a lot to. They are the ones who made the steps forward. And they were all human.
[edit on 9/6/2009 by Phage]
It's a nice idea but I wouldn't count on an increase in rational thought or an increased aversion to making stuff up. I think our general capacity for both has been pretty much unchanged for 30 or 40 thousand years.
It's the ones who excel in rational thought and studiously avoid making things up that have gotten us where we are. They have been few, but they are the ones we owe a lot to. They are the ones who made the steps forward. And they were all human.
[edit on 9/6/2009 by Phage]
reply posted on 6-9-2009 @ 05:19 AM by Scott Creighton
reply to post by Hanslune
Hello Hans,
SC: Alas I am not actually in the business of "making stuff up". "Making stuff up" infers 'fantasy'. This is no fantasy.
Regards,
Scott Creighton
Hello Hans,
Hans: Probably not as they will have more detailed records and will in general be more capable of making rational decisions. Instead of making stuff up.
SC: Alas I am not actually in the business of "making stuff up". "Making stuff up" infers 'fantasy'. This is no fantasy.
Regards,
Scott Creighton
reply posted on 6-9-2009 @ 01:31 PM by Hanslune
reply to post by Phage
Agreed, however our ability to make stuff up is now tempered by the methodogy of science which has tended to suppress the belief in the irrational and unlogical. However I suspect that trait will continue to plague us until our species dies out.
Agreed, however our ability to make stuff up is now tempered by the methodogy of science which has tended to suppress the belief in the irrational and unlogical. However I suspect that trait will continue to plague us until our species dies out.
reply posted on 6-9-2009 @ 01:35 PM by Hanslune
reply to post by Scott Creighton
Howdy Scott
To you its real but to the rest of us, its just your amusing, if odd little obsessive fantasy. Or are we not allowed to disagree with your imperial majesties opinions?LOL
So going back to my post a few back - why would a civilization forget those things that would cause their beloved children to live longer while retaining complex mathematically knowledge?
Howdy Scott
To you its real but to the rest of us, its just your amusing, if odd little obsessive fantasy. Or are we not allowed to disagree with your imperial majesties opinions?LOL
So going back to my post a few back - why would a civilization forget those things that would cause their beloved children to live longer while retaining complex mathematically knowledge?
reply posted on 7-9-2009 @ 04:22 AM by Scott Creighton
reply to post by Hanslune
Hello Hans,
SC: Now this REALLY IS a fantasy - since when were you appointed to speak on behalf of "...the rest of us..."?
You should well understand by now, Hans, that labelling evidence as 'fantasy' won't actually make it 'fantasy' nor will such derisory and empty comments cut it as a viable counter-argument.
You really have to do much better than this.
Best regards,
Scott Creighton
[edit on 7/9/2009 by Scott Creighton]
Hello Hans,
Hans: To you its real but to the rest of us, its just your amusing, if odd little obsessive fantasy. Or are we not allowed to disagree with your imperial majesties opinions?LOL
SC: Now this REALLY IS a fantasy - since when were you appointed to speak on behalf of "...the rest of us..."?
You should well understand by now, Hans, that labelling evidence as 'fantasy' won't actually make it 'fantasy' nor will such derisory and empty comments cut it as a viable counter-argument.
You really have to do much better than this.
Best regards,
Scott Creighton
[edit on 7/9/2009 by Scott Creighton]
Ancient Walled City, Older than Egypt\'s Pyramids, Unearthed off US Georgia Coast
Posted 12 days ago with 102 member flags
Posted 12 days ago with 102 member flags
42,000-year-old paintings : \'The oldest work of art ever\' discovered
Posted 3 days ago with 26 member flags
Posted 3 days ago with 26 member flags
Newest topics, updated in real-time:
Many parents 'better off on the dole' after tax credit changes.
Other Current Events, Posted 39 minutes ago
Other Current Events, Posted 39 minutes ago
Newest topics getting flags, in real-time:
Iran to announce "very important" nuclear achievements
Middle East Issues, Posted 13 hours ago, 18 flags
Middle East Issues, Posted 13 hours ago, 18 flags
Occupy Wall street, we are witnessing social revolution.
Social Issues and Civil Unrest, Posted 14 hours ago, 15 flags
Social Issues and Civil Unrest, Posted 14 hours ago, 15 flags
Jacques Vallee: Implications of UFO Phenomena - Thinking Allowed.
Aliens and UFOs, Posted 11 hours ago, 12 flags
Aliens and UFOs, Posted 11 hours ago, 12 flags
Parenting 101: how to instill respect for others.
Social Issues and Civil Unrest, Posted 6 hours ago, 12 flags
Social Issues and Civil Unrest, Posted 6 hours ago, 12 flags
The Scale of the Universe- Amazing, Controllable Flash Animation!
Fragile Earth, Posted 10 hours ago, 11 flags
Fragile Earth, Posted 10 hours ago, 11 flags
Newest topics getting replies, in real-time:
Catholic Bishops: Obama's Solution 'Is Unacceptable'
Breaking Political News, Posted 15 hours ago, 77 replies
Breaking Political News, Posted 15 hours ago, 77 replies
Parenting 101: how to instill respect for others.
Social Issues and Civil Unrest, Posted 6 hours ago, 76 replies
Social Issues and Civil Unrest, Posted 6 hours ago, 76 replies
Iran to announce "very important" nuclear achievements
Middle East Issues, Posted 13 hours ago, 50 replies
Middle East Issues, Posted 13 hours ago, 50 replies
Why Argentina WILL Invade the Falklands & How Iran are Involved
General Conspiracies, Posted 6 hours ago, 47 replies
General Conspiracies, Posted 6 hours ago, 47 replies
The Above Top Secret Web sites are a
wholly owned social content community of
The Above Network, LLC.
This content community relies on
user-generated content from our member contributors.
The opinions of our members are not those of site ownership
who maintains strict editorial agnosticism and simply provides
a collaborative venue for free expression.
ATS Server: www2.theabovenetwork.com
Header data: 0.007 seconds
Page processed in: 0.255 seconds
wholly owned social content community of
The Above Network, LLC.
This content community relies on
user-generated content from our member contributors.
The opinions of our members are not those of site ownership
who maintains strict editorial agnosticism and simply provides
a collaborative venue for free expression.
ATS Server: www2.theabovenetwork.com
Header data: 0.007 seconds
Page processed in: 0.255 seconds
