What constitutes an advanced civilization?, page 2

reply to post by SLAYER69

---

Only problem is that they went to war to obtain captives for more sacrifices.
All ancient cultures were brutal by todays standards, some more so than others.
Its the sheer savagery of the way the meso americans sacrificed, not only war captives but thier own people, that we as a modern people have a hard time accepting.
Beyond the beheading and impalement, or the being tossed into a well or having your back broken or the ever so popular riping of the heart from the living body, the priests would skin people alive, then put on the skin while the victim was still alive watching.
many of the peoples of the med. basin and near east practiced human scarifice at some point or another, but they gave it up fairly early on.
And the sacrifices were considered to be the most precious thing that could be given to a god.
Many cultures adopted ritualistic sacrificial offerings, such a circumcision or the sacrifice of domestic animals.

reply to post by zazzafrazz

---

From what I can see AC wants to define 'advanced', not define 'civilization'...am I right or wrong AC?

You are still right along my way of thinking, and again you are putting it far better in writing than I do.

Originally posted by punkinworks
reply to post by SLAYER69

---

Only problem is that they went to war to obtain captives for more sacrifices.
All ancient cultures were brutal by todays standards, some more so than others.

No actually that is all part of eliminating the "resource" competition.

reply to post by merka

---

Yeah I agree it was too wide spread to get an accurate account of just how many cultures around the world have done it

Human sacrifice

* 1 Evolution and context
* 2 History by region
o 2.1 Ancient Near East
+ 2.1.1 Ancient Egypt
+ 2.1.2 Mesopotamia
+ 2.1.3 Levant
+ 2.1.4 Phoenicia
o 2.2 Europe
+ 2.2.1 Neolithic Europe
+ 2.2.2 Greco-Roman Antiquity
+ 2.2.3 Celts
+ 2.2.4 Germanic peoples
+ 2.2.5 Slavic peoples
o 2.3 China
o 2.4 India
o 2.5 Pacific
o 2.6 Pre-Columbian Americas
+ 2.6.1 Mesoamerica
+ 2.6.2 South America
+ 2.6.3 North America
o 2.7 West Africa
* 3 Prohibition in major religions
o 3.1 Judaism
o 3.2 Christianity
o 3.3 Islam
o 3.4 Eastern religions
o 3.5 Blood libel
* 4 Contemporary human sacrifice
o 4.1 India
o 4.2 Sub-Saharan Africa
o 4.3 Ritual murder

reply to post by merka

---

Here is one of my favorites.

A wicker man, that, according to Caesar, was used to sacrifice humans to the gods.

Celts
Main article: Celts and human sacrifice

As written in Roman sources, Celtic Druids engaged extensively in human sacrifice.[27] According to Julius Caesar, the slaves and dependants of Gauls of rank would be burnt along with the body of their master as part of his funerary rites.[28] He also describes how they built wicker figures that were filled with living humans and then burned.[29] It is known that druids at least supervised sacrifices of some kind. According to Cassius Dio, Boudica's forces impaled Roman captives during her rebellion against the Roman occupation, to the accompaniment of revellery and sacrifices in the sacred groves of Andate.[30] Some modern-day scholars question the accuracy of these accounts, as they invariably come from hostile (Roman or Greek) sources.[31] Different gods reportedly required different kind of sacrifices. Victims meant for Esus were hung, those meant for Taranis immolated and those for Teutates drowned. Some, like the Lindow Man, may have gone to their deaths willingly.

reply to post by merka

---

There where no worldwide *need* to slaughter people to make the sun move, so in comparison they where rather savage.

In comparison to what?
I wont go back through the Wests timeline such as the Inquisition, or the GENOCIDE of the Indigenous popluation of the Americas. WHy was their cutting out of a heart so much worse than the slaughter of them all? Why is slaughter for land, power and gold, more civlised than if you are killing for a cultural purpose? You've lost me. The attrocities carried out during colonialism are beyond belief, it is belived that 30-40 million people were killed or enslaved by European colonialism. How very civilised and unsavage of them.

I would collapse the ATS server if i listed the savagery of 'civilsed ' societies. So lets stick with 20 century to now.

Genocide in Bosnia: search srebrenica
Genocide in the Sudan
The Indigenous Asutralians Stolen generation
Jewish Holocaust
Stalins slaughter of 20 million Russians and displacement of 28 million
Zionism and Palestinie genocide
Husseins genocide of Kurds
British Genocide of millions in India and Malaysia
The genocide of Muslims in India
Khmer Ruge and Polpott in the Killing fields
The genocides in India/Africa and Asia through deliberate food shortages causing stavation
Over 1 million Iraquis killed since the US led invasion

World War 1 / 8 500 000 soldiers were killed from all nations but when you add civilians killed its is over 20 000 000 killed

World War 2 over 60 million killed

I could go on but surely you get my point? Your definition of 'savagery' and 'civilsed' needs to be reassessed. So when I compare them as you have asked, I think we come out a little worse.





Edit to add quote





[edit on 10-5-2009 by zazzafrazz]

reply to post by merka

---

Yes and I brought it to a comparison study on advanced modern civilisation just s you asked, not a rant. They were no more savage than us today, whilst they may not have had xboxs, they certainly had recreation, romance and the rest of the good stuff that all humans enjoy.
My point is that cutting out hearts to make the sun move doesnt makes them 'more savage in comparison', yes it is was savage, but so was the slaughter of them for a shiny thing called gold, that was no less savage. So when I compare them to not only their contemporary colonisers/enslavers/murderers as well as modern societies, I see savagery all the same everywhere, just wears a different 'savage' costume.






[edit on 10-5-2009 by zazzafrazz]

reply to post by AlienCarnage

---

I don't think you're advanced until you re-write your code.
So, we are not advanced quite yet (selective breeding doesn't count) but once we really go for genetic engineering, then we will be.
Without the re-write, you are just playing out the cards you were dealt, chugging down the tracks to the next train station. Once you do a thorough rewrite (several different simultaneous rewrites) then you have truly risen above your initial random arbitrary configuration/situation...only then, it seems to me, do you deserve to be considered advanced.
I guess if you could obtain physical immortality, without a rewrite, I would count that as sufficiently transcending your initial conditions to be advanced, too...I have no big intellectual rationale for why to draw the line at these points, however...They just seem to me to stand out...

reply to post by zazzafrazz

---

Dont forget the Roman Gladiators all that slicing and dicing.

OH wait or was that a sport? Anyway nice place to take the wife and kids for a nice Sunday outing. Throw another Christian to the lions.




[edit on 10-5-2009 by SLAYER69]

reply to post by SLAYER69

---

Hey slayer, You are soooo right! who needs XBOX when you have such fun things to do like :

stonings


The Colloseum family fun Park


witch murders

reply to post by Inkrinhuminge

---

hey OP fix up your spelling of civilization, (cicilization) in the OP title thread. it made me giggle.

Whoa, you just discovered what was right under our noses, the number one indicator of an advanced civilization - SPELLCHECK!

Ancient Walled City, Older than Egypt\'s Pyramids, Unearthed off US Georgia Coast
  Posted 12 days ago with 102 member flags

Origin of Ancient Jade Tool Baffles Scientists
  Posted 7 days ago with 96 member flags

12,000 Years Old Unexplained Structure
  Posted 4 days ago with 81 member flags

The Uluburun shipwreck sunk 3,400 years ago
  Posted 15 days ago with 70 member flags

Sigiriya : The 8th Wonder of the World
  Posted 4 days ago with 45 member flags

Tomb of Queen Heterpheres
  Posted 16 days ago with 29 member flags

42,000-year-old paintings : \'The oldest work of art ever\' discovered
  Posted 3 days ago with 26 member flags

R.O.V. Photos of Sunken Megaliths off Western Cuba
  Posted 11 days ago with 21 member flags

Newest topics, updated in real-time:

Newest topics getting flags, in real-time:

Newest topics getting replies, in real-time: