It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.

Please white-list or disable in your ad-blocking tool.

Thank you.


Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.


Shame, shame, shame, shame....

page: 1

log in


posted on Oct, 7 2005 @ 06:06 PM

Bedlam erupts in Congress over oil refinery vote; 'Shame, shame'

A controversial bill that offered abandoned U.S. military bases to private industry for the construction of oil refineries and granted federal insurance to refiners ensnared in litigation passed by a razor-thin margin in the House Friday afternoon 212-210 as Democrats chanted "shame, shame, shame."

The vote, which was supposed to take five minutes, lasted 45. About a dozen Republicans reversed their votes as the Republican leadership circled the chamber pressuring members of their party to ensure the bill's passage.

When over two dozen Republicans initially voted no, DeLay, Barton, House Speaker Dennis Hastert and new Majority Leader Roy Blunt circled the chamber to cajole holdouts.

Eventually, enough Republicans switched to pass the bill.


House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi also complained, saying the proceedings brought "dishonor to the House."

Democrats in the chamber chanted "shame, shame, shame" as the final tally was announced.


I think this article speaks for itself...

You can watch the video here.

[edit on 7-10-2005 by loam]

posted on Oct, 7 2005 @ 07:18 PM
wow, have never seen what happens in the american parliament b4 and it seems pretty similar to happenings in britain with shouting and so forth. what gts me is the fact that a bill like this only needsa majority to win eg 51 to 49 in favour to get passed, i never understandwhy 2/3ds or 3/4 are needed.
Poor environment takes another hit from a rushed law. shame

posted on Oct, 7 2005 @ 07:24 PM
Hmm. Those bases have houses where displaced people could have relocated, right? But big business is more important in America than Americans, right?

posted on Oct, 7 2005 @ 07:37 PM
Long after all the votes were in and this travesty of a bill defeated, they kept the floor open and went looking for Republicans to strong arm into changing their vote. They eventually forced two to flip.

Thus the shame, shame, shame....

This bill was clearly defeated, but grasped from the jaws of defeat by GOP thugs. No other way to put it.

This is not democracy. It's MOB rule.

posted on Oct, 8 2005 @ 07:56 AM

Originally posted by RANT

Long after all the votes were in and this travesty of a bill defeated, they kept the floor open and went looking for Republicans to strong arm into changing their vote. They eventually forced two to flip.

And this surprises you? ...This administration routinely ignores the law, breaks the law, changes the law, when it doesn't serve their purposes.

No kidding "shame, shame..."


posted on Oct, 8 2005 @ 10:41 AM

Originally posted by soficrow
And this surprises you?

What surprises me is that so few are outraged. Bit by bit we are allowing our democracy to be reduced to a simple farce.

posted on Oct, 8 2005 @ 01:33 PM
Press release from Nancy Pelosi:

Pelosi: ‘What You Saw on the House Floor This Afternoon Was a Shameless Display of the Republican Culture of Corruption’

Washington, D.C.– House Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi joined House Democratic Whip Steny Hoyer at a news conference this afternoon to condemn the Republican abuse of power that occurred on the floor of the House today. The Republican leadership held a five-minute vote on the energy bill open for 45 minutes to twist arms to get their Members to switch votes. Below are Pelosi’s remarks:

“What you saw on the House floor this afternoon was a shameless display of the Republican culture of corruption, as it exists in the House of Representatives. It demonstrated once again that the Republican majority will go to any length to satisfy the greed of the energy companies over meeting the needs of the American people.

“A vote that was supposed to take five minutes took more than nine times that long because the indicted Republican leader of the House of Representatives needed extra time to twist the arms necessary to pass a bill that is against the interests of the American people, against consumers, against taxpayers, and against the environment.

“The fact that the Republicans are handmaidens of the special interests is nothing new. The fact that they would shamelessly display their servitude should come as no surprise. But today’s extortion is an especially shameful display – a sad day for democracy. The people spoke and the vote was clearly against this bill.

“How long will the Republican caucus condone this behavior? Until the rank-and-file Members break with the culture of corruption, they are all complicit and they all enable. The American people must object.

“Our country’s democracy is based upon every American having his or her voice heard on the floor of Congress. Republicans have shut down debate here. Now they are shutting down the reasonable outcome of a vote.

“Democrats have proposed guidelines for how we think the House of Representatives should operate, a Minority Bill of Rights. Included in this document is the declaration that ‘No vote shall be held open in order to manipulate the outcome.’ When we take back the People’s House, we will heed that declaration.”

See also, at the same URL, a list of the "LONGEST VOTES ON HOUSE FLOOR"

top topics


log in