Ok,
Now that we've discussed it, I'd like to see a show of hands:

If you think that WITD was real, say YES
If not, say NO

If you think his message was real, but that HE was not (IE not a gov insider) your vote is NO.

If you're unsure, don't vote. Re-read the other WITD thread and post when you are ready.

Please, ONE WORD REPLIES. If you have comments, put them on that other thread

[Edited on 4-9-2003 by onlyinmydreams]

YES

(that is, 'real' for those following me)

YES

Yes.

One word replie's aren't possible ...

"We're sorry, we like to encourage posts that contribue to the discussion.
Your post has been determined to be too short. Please use your browser's back button and add to your message."

No.

And you know why.

Yes,

And we ALL know why

No....

Yadda yadda yadda

P...
m...

Yes

He's as real as you and me!

Yes,
and yes dr, I know why too...
- Tassadar

NO

I'll vote: it doesn't matter as we cannot confirm nor deny his/her existance even if we wanted to.

6 to 3 with one abstain in favor of Whispers being real so far.

No...for the same reasons as William....

no, because he was we-todd-did.

So it's 6:5 now... getting close!

Did anyone ever figure out his references to a "friend from the past" or whatever?

Yes For all reasons stated!

I was reading his post from the beginning but can't say for sure if everything he posted was there from the start.

I'm 80% sure he posted the Jakarta issue before it happened. I was too preoccupied with that dam world wide seismic thread and missed the action.

His other information is somewhat true. Re-read his post and compair with current events.

What is "real" is the more important question.

Was WITD 100% genuine as a whistleblowing DoD officer, with awesome insider knowledge and predictive powers, and did he anticipate Jakarta, and was he correct in everything about August?

Obviously, NO.

Did he entertain, and was he reasonably astute, and did he have trolling and hacking ability? Yes.

WITD is no more real than MaskedAvatar is SimonGray.

hmmmm....

No.

And I kind of felt that Whispers was the "crazy canuck" from ikon boards gone past a.k.a. Wisdom.



[Edited on 9-4-2003 by William One Sac]