It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Jennyfrenzy
a reply to: nonspecific
Living in the United States, we really don't hear that much about the IRA but ISIS is on the MSM every single day.
I also find it doubtful that the IRA would be beheading people, including children, left and right in the name of god.
originally posted by: crostkev
a reply to: nonspecific
Not sure "fairly well documented" equals qualification of your statement
Is this incorrect ?
originally posted by: tadaman
a reply to: nonspecific
Honestly, the OP is very disingenuous. A person who knows nothing of human conflict or even human nature cant distinguish between different people, cultures, and history. They see all "cool" rebels as "freedom fighters".
To be simple, we treat them differently because they are different. The IRA was happy to put down arms once a respectable situation was achieved and would have anyways once Ireland was whole in the most extreme cases.
ISIS wants to establish an Islamic empire so as to conquer the world. Its their freaking mission statement.
Thats a HUGE difference. There are countless others. The IRA didnt go around raping, maiming and torturing citizens of the UK to name another...
Every group is different. Just like people. Why on earth would we treat them as the same? Is a hooligan the same as a serial rapist?
The IRA of today is just a terrorist organization. Every bit of validity went out the window once they got what they wanted and especially when they killed non combatants for no damned reason.
originally posted by: nonspecific
originally posted by: tadaman
a reply to: nonspecific
Honestly, the OP is very disingenuous. A person who knows nothing of human conflict or even human nature cant distinguish between different people, cultures, and history. They see all "cool" rebels as "freedom fighters".
To be simple, we treat them differently because they are different. The IRA was happy to put down arms once a respectable situation was achieved and would have anyways once Ireland was whole in the most extreme cases.
ISIS wants to establish an Islamic empire so as to conquer the world. Its their freaking mission statement.
Thats a HUGE difference. There are countless others. The IRA didnt go around raping, maiming and torturing citizens of the UK to name another...
Every group is different. Just like people. Why on earth would we treat them as the same? Is a hooligan the same as a serial rapist?
The IRA of today is just a terrorist organization. Every bit of validity went out the window once they got what they wanted and especially when they killed non combatants for no damned reason.
I have read your posts and until now how always given you creedence and even a couple of stars here and there but what was that?
Please for the sake of argument could you re read your post and then we can maybe try again.
I refer mainly to your statement that "The IRA of today is just a terrorist organization"
I do not understand the difference between acceptable terrorism and unacceptable terrorism.
I look forward to future coments.
originally posted by: tadaman
a reply to: nonspecific
I am sorry.
Well, I was referring to the historical IRA that was born of natural resistance to bad government by the UK. I do not support them but honestly the heavy hand of past governments under the monarchs was what birthed them.
Please dont think I hold some to be more noble than others. They killed innocents in every age, but IMO when they first came about it was a natural to response to violence with violence. The Irish were utterly crapped on in the past.
Again, They were not justified, I just think it was understandable for them to get tired of what they used to endure. Their response was wrong, but the root of the problem WAS their abject slavery.
I may be wrong, but thats how I see it.
The point I wished to make is that we are not bombing Ireland because there are " terrorists" in the country.