It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Joe Cat
you can call them freedom fighters if you prefer.......
I wasn't questioning the dead of the first 2, im questioning the need to kill a wounded man....
i wasnt there but neither were you guys there....
so u cant say for sure it was a RPG...
Originally posted by Joe Cat
you can call them freedom fighters if you prefer.......
I wasn't questioning the dead of the first 2, im questioning the need to kill a wounded man....
i wasnt there but neither were you guys there....
so u cant say for sure it was a RPG...
Originally posted by COOL HAND
[No, the right of self defense gave them the right to kill those people in the video.
They had the right to kill the first two but IMO the third kill was a crime, he was wounded....not a real threat...
Originally posted by Joe Cat
They had the right to kill the first two but IMO the third kill was a crime, he was wounded....not a real threat...
Originally posted by Joe Cat
Originally posted by COOL HAND
[No, the right of self defense gave them the right to kill those people in the video.
They had the right to kill the first two but IMO the third kill was a crime, he was wounded....not a real threat...
Kinda off point... what the heck does IMO stand for?? i put somethin about the 3rd bloke in the last post i made
Originally posted by Joe Cat
you can call them freedom fighters if you prefer.......
I wasn't questioning the dead of the first 2, im questioning the need to kill a wounded man....
i wasnt there but neither were you guys there....
so u cant say for sure it was a RPG...
Originally posted by Stuey1221
Originally posted by Joe Cat
Originally posted by COOL HAND
[No, the right of self defense gave them the right to kill those people in the video.
They had the right to kill the first two but IMO the third kill was a crime, he was wounded....not a real threat...
Kinda off point... what the heck does IMO stand for?? i put somethin about the 3rd bloke in the last post i made
In my opinion.
Originally posted by Joe Cat
im not a expert on this but wasnt it supose to arrest the gay, after all POW have rights, the right to medical aid and all......maybe the geneva convetion doesnt apply to the US...i dont know....
Originally posted by Joe Cat
im not a expert on this but wasnt it supose to arrest the gay, after all POW have rights, the right to medical aid and all......maybe the geneva convetion doesnt apply to the US...i dont know....
Originally posted by Joe Cat
im not a expert on this but wasnt it supose to arrest the gay, after all POW have rights, the right to medical aid and all......maybe the geneva convetion doesnt apply to the US...i dont know....
Originally posted by Joe Cat
IMO means in my opinion...u r going to see that a lot here in ATS.
Originally posted by Joe Cat
lets not talk about treatment for the POW...you guys arent treating your POW that well either....
Because i have no room in the heli, that gives them the right to kill....
no room, sorry i have to kill you....
Originally posted by Joe Cat
lets not talk about treatment for the POW...you guys arent treating your POW that well either....
Because i have no room in the heli, that gives them the right to kill....
no room, sorry i have to kill you....
Originally posted by Joe Cat
the geneva convention didnt seemed to be aplied at guantanamo(where are afeghans and other terrorists) .......that's why i was asking!
Originally posted by COOL HAND
Originally posted by Joe Cat
lets not talk about treatment for the POW...you guys arent treating your POW that well either....
Because i have no room in the heli, that gives them the right to kill....
no room, sorry i have to kill you....
Compared to how they treated our guys, the Iraqis are getting off light.
Did anyone ever consider that maybe they brought this upon themselves based on their treatment of our prisoners in the past? You never heard about Iraqi prisoners being mistreated during DS.
Back to the subject, what would you have had them do?
Call for someone to come in and get them, thus putting more people at risk?
[Edited on 6/5/04 by COOL HAND]