It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
bigfatfurrytexan
reply to post by snypwsd
"They" are so human that if the roles were reversed, nothing would change.
Yes, "poor people" tend to be more giving. But remove that poor state from their finances, and they become the same scumbags that we are decrying here.
Behavior is 10% individual outlook, and 90% human nature.
PAUL PIFF: We’re playing a game of Monopoly that’s rigged.
PAUL SOLMAN: This game is typical of another kind of experiment Piff likes to run. Instead of studying actual rich people, Piff gets subjects to feel rich in the lab. The designated Monopoly moneybags starts with a few legs up, $2,000 dollars vs. the poor man’s $1,000 dollars, an upscale playing piece the Rolls vs. an old shoe, the right to toss two dice instead of just one.
Two. I have got snake eyes — meaning I, assigned the role of rich person, get an extra turn.
So, but I roll again, because I have got …
PAUL PIFF: Yes, because you rolled doubles.
PAUL SOLMAN: Doubles. Six. One, two, three, four, five, six, and that’s Tennessee Avenue, and, of course, I will buy that.
Meanwhile, poor Paul Piff.
PAUL PIFF: I only get to roll one die. And as it says here, when I pass go, I collect a lower salary. I collect $100 dollars.
PAUL SOLMAN: Here’s your one die.
PAUL PIFF: Great. Thanks so much. I can’t roll doubles. I don’t get opportunities to move very far along the board.
PAUL SOLMAN: Piff has run this experiment with hundreds of people on the Berkeley campus. The rich players are determined randomly by coin toss, the game rigged so they cannot lose. And yet, says Piff, despite their presumably liberal bent going in …
PAUL PIFF: When we asked them afterwards, how much do you feel like you deserved to win the game? The rich people felt entitled. They felt like they deserved to win the game. And that’s a really incredible insight into what the mind does to make sense of advantage or disadvantage.
PAUL SOLMAN: So, even though a subject like myself is just play-acting — you consistently find that I begin to attribute success to myself, even though it’s a coin flip that got me on this side of the board as opposed to that?
PAUL PIFF: You, like a real rich person, start to attribute success to your own individual skills and talents, and you become less attuned to all of the other things that contributed to you being in the position that you’re in.
Another_Nut
Now that i am not just homeless anymore
But i am a working homeless person i would like to tell many of you in this thread
You are wrong
And i hope you are faced with these hard choices soon as our society deteriorates
And i hope you suffer
Badly
Some of use want to improve our state of affairs
But you make it so damn hard
Then blame us
Choke
I agree with your ideas... My only issue with it is that they have to want what you're proposing. I worked at an adult crisis home and a majority of the people who lived there cycled in and out of the system of their own free will, only wanting to be off the streets long enough to eat and maybe clean up or sleep a bit. Within a couple of days they would AWOL and then they'd be back in a few weeks.
jrod
Also if arrested most homeless will get an automatic 30days in jail because they can not afford to be bailed out.
TheConspiracyPages
reply to post by SilverStarGazer
I agree with your ideas... My only issue with it is that they have to want what you're proposing. I worked at an adult crisis home and a majority of the people who lived there cycled in and out of the system of their own free will, only wanting to be off the streets long enough to eat and maybe clean up or sleep a bit. Within a couple of days they would AWOL and then they'd be back in a few weeks.
I struggled with this too when I was working with the homeless. Of course if you work with them you want to see them succeed and you work to try and increase the number that do. But ultimately, even if they refuse or unable to transition out of that world, I don't think the efforts are wasted.
Some people, for various reasons, just don't thrive. None the less, I still think they're owed a little compassion.
jrod
I am from Florida and I can tell you many cities are very anti-homeless. For example in Tampa you can get arrested for feeding a homeless person. There are a plethora of laws that give LEOs a bunch of reasons they can arrest a homeless person. Also if arrested most homeless will get an automatic 30days in jail because they can not afford to be bailed out. 30 days is how long the state has to formally charge someone if in custody for a misdemeanor, since most homeless have a weak case against them the state often will drop the charges after 30 days and that person is released from jail.
That said because there are so many homeless in Florida there are also a lot of charities that cater to the homeless.edit on 7-2-2014 by jrod because: (no reason given)
tinner07
Ok here is my perspective on that.
I live in Michigan, snowing to beat hell. I want to vacation in florida but can't afford the resorts. Can I set up tent in your front yard? No.
Business owners are the same. People have compassion but you get people sleeping in front of a business its going to hurt business.
taoistguy
reply to post by tinner07
we, it's getting closer to them being made illegal.
get out of town? where???
sad, so very sad. :\
Antigod
reply to post by Kmhotaru
Hmm, at the risk of being really unpopular.
The majority of homeless people in the Uk have real mental health problems and/or substance abouse issues, which is what puts them on the streets. You really need ways to contain them. The sane, non criminal ones are a minority. You need to find a way to discourage them from hanging around in the city centres and bugging the straights.