posted on May, 23 2013 @ 04:10 PM
reply to post by alfa1
But neoholographic's argument is that we can set up this experiment such that I would instantly KNOW that you've setup the web page, and the
actual value of the checkbox is more or less irrelevent.
Yes, his scenario would be the equivalent of me "Alice" taking a measurement or checking the checkbox but you only see it as checked. Unless you
have 3 in which case some are checked and some aren't depending on which one of his own arguments he's misunderstanding.
Now even if you receive an email as soon as I check or uncheck the box and all you can see is the state as one value, cecked, that value is
meaningless since its always checked.
Now if you can truly detect by way of automated email, that the checkbox was checked or unchecked by me, you still don't have much other than a
couple of emails. If I could send you a flurry of emails say 3 in a row at a certain interval and give that some meaning, that's all we need. His
whole one value scheme is completely useless because in order for it to work, it actually has to be capable of 2 values which he keeps saying it is
not but gives example after example of how it is.
I think that I get the Nobel peace prize for pointing this out of course once the inspector particle detector is invented. They will need programmers
and I will be there day one.