Originally posted by maes2
reply to post by svmpua
Jazia is approximately an obsolete law in Islam. and that was not just because of not accepting Islam.
so if those black sheeps (Taliban,radicals) are threatening people to pay Jazia. people should defend their rights. those radicals are laying. that is
a Tribute not Jazia !!! and the existence of those murderers is itself contrary to all monotheistic religions !!!!!!!
Well I did not want to bring it .But since you persist , i have to do it .
1)You say "Jazia is approximately an obsolete law in Islam."
Well you may not be aware that there are many muslims who are demanding that Jizya be practised .
Now before you claim that I am lying,i present to you ->
Muslims Demand Catholic Priest Convert To Islam Or Pay
Muslim ‘Gang’ Torments Christian
Copts for Jizya-Money
2)You say " and that was not just because of not accepting Islam. "
Yes you are right.It is because of the protection that the state has to provide too.
It is for 'allowing them to practice their religion too'.
For more details,refer to the thread.
3)You say "so if those black sheeps (Taliban,radicals) are threatening people to pay Jazia. people should defend their rights."
Now lets break it down into two parts :-
(a)Taliban are not black sheep's .They are human just like us.They fight for Islam.
The dictionary defination of human is :-
"a member of any of the races of Homo sapiens; person; man, woman, or child."
The dictionary defination of Taliban is :-
"A fundamentalist Muslim group that controlled much of Afghanistan from 1995 until U.S. military intervention in 2001"
See the difference?
Your claim that the Taliban is "black sheep" is totally a lie and scientifically unproven.They are human's just like us.The only thing is that they
believe they fight for "Quran".Here is more prove ->
an justifies shooting of schoolgirl: "The Quran says that people propagating against Islam and Islamic forces would be killed"
3)You say "those radicals are laying."
What do you mean be "laying".
The dictionary defination of "laying" is :-To place in or bring to a particular position: lay the cloth over the painting.
You see ,your statement does not make any sense and neither does it have any validity.
I fail to understand why you wrote that statement.Do you want to make fun of me.Are are against me because I wrote against Jizya?
Either way this statement is senseless.
4)You say "that is a Tribute not Jazia !"
Do you have any prove that this is a tribute and not Jizya?How can you justify this ?
I have already stated in my thread how Mohammad encouraged even the use of force for the collection of "Jizya".
So your statement this this is a "tribute" is humorous.
5)You say "and the existence of those murderers is itself contrary to all monotheistic religions."
But you must not forget that the Taliban fight for Allah itself.And they follow the Quran too.
I am not making this up.For proof,refer here :-
Taliban and other terroists fight for Allah
edit on 5-12-2012 by svmpua because: (no reason given)