It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
All I'm asking of you is that you go to the site, check the lists and tell us if you're going to take the challenge. OK?
Below, I give seven common lists that I see Christ-mythers give. They say that these are things that pre-Christian deities were credited with doing that influenced the Jesus story. I will give $1000 to the first person who can provide evidence of any one of these lists being valid. Yes, just one. It must be evidence which shows that the deity was believed, prior to the writing of the Gospels, to have done these things. Please contact me (through the link above) if you have the evidence.
As a theist I do not have any "job" to convince you, or anyone else that my theism is valid or correct, anymore than any atheist has any responsibility to prove their beliefs are valid or correct. As a theist, however, the difference between myself and the O.P. is that I have not place unreasonable demands on the O.P. whereas the O.P. has remarkably excused their own believe from any scrutiny demanding that all theist surrender to his, or her, scrutiny. That's a pretty big difference.
I'll take anything which strongly suggests that the "parallel" claim truly existed sometime prior to the writing of the Gospels. For example:
1) Versions of their stories in which we can read about them actually doing these things, provided that the stories are generally agreed-upon by scholars to be pre-Christian. This is the one I'd most like to see. If the deities are truly believed to have done these things, you would think there would be stories somewhere in which they do it.
2) Any information coming from scholarly sources: For example:
a) General mythology books and websites, provided they have no Christ-myther agenda (sorry, I won't accept Wikipedia or similar forums, since there's no way to determine whether the individual doing the posting is a Christ-myther or not). If it's a book, I must be able to acquire it from my local library, or you can mail me the book or e-mail me copies of the pages in question. I won't spend my own money on it (this is to prevent someone from naming some impossible-to-find book and then calling foul on me for not going on a wild and expensive goose chase to get it - remember, I am asking YOU to provide the evidence.)
b) Scholars (Christian or not) who work for a university who agree that the parallels are valid.
c) Anything coming from a mainstream peer-reviewed journal.
3) Photographs of heiroglyphs showing them clearly doing these things (I've seen Christ-mythers claim such hieroglyphs exist for Horus, but every time I ask them to send them to me, I never hear from them again).
Overall, I expect any evidence you provide me with to be something that a reasonable, skeptical and unbiased person (say, someone who is neither a Christian nor a Christ-myther) would accept as convincing evidence that the deity in question was believed, in pre-Christian times, to have done those things. Simply quoting a Christ-myther, or quoting one Christ-myther who quotes another Christ-myther (and so on) obviously will not count. I am expecting evidence that clearly existed prior to and separate from Christ-mythers. (Emphasis added)
That's impossible proof? When all you need to do is come up with some story from before Jesus showing that the other god matched Him? And you've got your choice of seven different gods to try. He's even said that he'll pay a partial reward if you can match a part of the list (at least 1/2).
I'll take anything which strongly suggests that the "parallel" claim truly existed sometime prior to the writing of the Gospels.
Overall, I expect any evidence you provide me with to be something that a reasonable, skeptical and unbiased person (say, someone who is neither a Christian nor a Christ-myther) would accept as convincing evidence that the deity in question was believed, in pre-Christian times, to have done those things.