Life in the Universe, page 4
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 2 times


reply posted on 8-2-2011 @ 11:10 PM by Cosmic.Artifact
reply to post by MrXYZ



now... would you like to discuss the Neil Tyson video you posted ?

it is quite short so we can break it down right when he says the word "Cosmic"


reply posted on 9-2-2011 @ 10:08 AM by Cosmic.Artifact
Originally posted by MrXYZ
Humans evolved because of very specific environmental conditions that include earth's gravity, vegetation, landscape features, and number of other external influences and mutations. For humans to exist elsewhere in the universe, the exact same requirements would have to be met...including mass extinctions exactly like on earth.
well I am looking more specifically for the equation of this, which includes variables and the possibility of life giving rise in exactly the same way... here we are afterall, we are one way. Are you saying your equation for this is just 0 ? it's almost like saying we do not exist.

I'd say the chances of that are rather slim
can you show me this in a formulated equation

Let's for a second pretend some islands are other planets "similar" to our own.
how can we even begin to imagine or pretend without data or an equation ? I would like the equation to start off asking the question... "here we are" if you claim the chances are very slim with no supporting equation then that is like saying we are very special in the universe and this chance of happenings was most miracle like, we are unique... but if it is not a miracle then why are the chances very slim if we are made of the most common stuff in the universe ? if we're common then there should be life like ours (all life on earth) everywhere in the universe. because we are here)

Just look at the incredible number of species that only exist on one island and nowhere else, even if the environment is similar in the region.
I agree all that stuff is here and all of it is evidence of atleast only one way the universe gives rise to life (planet earth) I am looking for the math here... all we have when we ask this question my topic wants to address, well all we have is earth and what we know to give us a foundation and a start to the question.

Humanoid lifeforms maybe, but exactly like us to the point where we would call them homo sapiens, I highly doubt it...
why doubt ? lets use symbolic math for this... if life is here and this is a successful way in which it gives rise then there must be atleast 1 other place just like this... perfect distance from their star, have an external object producing tides and winds, having a magnetic field, ect... if we apply the math approaching the question with "yes" here we are, here life is... the math I am sure would come back to reflect more than 1 exact same place (regardless if there are other ways or not) all we have to go on is ourselves and what we know, we are 'fact and 'evidence' of life... why look into the unknown or pretend ?

in fact why are scientist searching for planets at same distances from their source star at the moment ? it is one of the latest trends in astronomy...

edit on 2/9/2011 by Cosmic.Artifact because: (no reason given)



reply posted on 9-2-2011 @ 10:41 AM by MrXYZ
reply to post by Cosmic.Artifact



To get a formula you'd need to fullfil so many requirements:

1) Exactly same gravity.
2) Same weather patterns...including the exact same variations at the same time...like ice ages.
3) Exact same migratory paths of animals as on earth...which means you need the same landscape.
4) Same mass extinction events.
5) Same mutations...so the exact same randomness
6) The plantet would need to be the same in every respect, as evolution makes animals/plants adapt to their exact environment. Same water temperatures depending on location, the exact same climate.

Given that our sample size of planets is only a bit over 500, it would currently be impossible to calculate an accurate figure. We don't even know how many planets there are, or what % is earth like to the point where everything would play out the same. Evolution is incredibly complex, and it took 3.5bil years for humans to evolve due to VERY specific conditions...chances of having the exact same conditions including all randomness being the same on another planet should be incredibly slim imo.

There's too many unknown variables to calculate what you're asking...which shows that the end figure is probably pretty small. Chances for life in general are quite good though imo, everything we have on earth can be found elsewhere, it's just the composition of parts (climate, gravity, distance from sun, etc.) that's different.


reply posted on 9-2-2011 @ 10:54 AM by Cosmic.Artifact
Originally posted by MrXYZ
reply to
post by Cosmic.Artifact



To get a formula you'd need to fulfill so many requirements:
actually this question I ask is very basic... the requirement is the question, "all life on earth" all life is of the same stuff/elements. What are the chances of it forming or giving rise exactly like it successfully did here ? I am asking a "positive" question... what are the chances of the exact same conditions as on earth happening elsewhere ? regardless of environmental or other factors, all we have to go on is here and what we know.

makes one wonder what happened to Dawkins being so adamant against spirituality ? more specifically Roman Catholicism (like a lot of Britons view Christianity, very one sided because they were jaded somehow)

so what happened to Dawkins and others like him ? ...did he watch too many movies like Zeitgeist or books that were it's forerunners ? did he lose his daughter to the Church and "the bigger question" ?

ahh no need to delve into the psychological aspects of his reasoning, he either knows this and is playing on it, or he was genuinely jaded... but I doubt he seriously "knows"

edit on 2/9/2011 by Cosmic.Artifact because: (no reason given)



reply posted on 9-2-2011 @ 11:06 AM by MrXYZ
reply to post by Cosmic.Artifact



I think you're underestimating how complex evolution is...us getting to where we are now in terms of evolution is the result of soooooo many past events, even given the size of the universe, given the number of variables, it's highly unlikely to get "exactly the same".

Similar...maybe...exactly the same...highly unlikely. Either way, due to evolution's complexity, there's just too many variable to get "exactly the same". I'm talking about MILLIONS of variables, possibly billions or more. I know you want a formula, but I hope you understand that would take years, and even then, due to randomness which is almost impossible to calculate, it won't be accurate.


reply posted on 9-2-2011 @ 11:12 AM by Cosmic.Artifact
Originally posted by MrXYZ
reply to
post by Cosmic.Artifact



I think you're underestimating how complex evolution is...
evolution is not complex, it is very simple when taken into another question or added to the equation.

Evolutionary science stops down here it would seem ?

if there was a mathematical symbol to represent all evolution as "fact" and summed up as simply as (E=+True) or something... then we take that and add it to the equation on the chalk-board. true or false it can be expressed mathematically right ? all things can be expressed using math remember...



reply posted on 9-2-2011 @ 11:28 AM by MrXYZ
Originally posted by Cosmic.Artifact
Originally posted by MrXYZ
reply to
post by Cosmic.Artifact



I think you're underestimating how complex evolution is...
evolution is not complex, it is very simple when taken into another question or added to the equation.

Evolutionary science stops down here it would seem ?

if there was a mathematical symbol to represent all evolution as "fact" and summed up as simply as (E=+True) or something... then we take that and add it to the equation on the chalk-board. true or false it can be expressed mathematically right ? all things can be expressed using math remember...


You can't just dumb something as complex as evolution down like that...and yes, it is VERY COMPLEX.


reply posted on 9-2-2011 @ 11:36 AM by Cosmic.Artifact
Originally posted by MrXYZ
You can't just dumb something as complex as evolution down like that...and yes, it is
VERY COMPLEX.
evolution is not complex... it happened right ?

add it to the chalk-board, it's all I am asking and is being done with it anyway.

a footnote or another symbol in the equation, that is all...


reply posted on 9-2-2011 @ 11:52 AM by Cosmic.Artifact
reply to post by MrXYZ



the way I see it...

it is you young Jedi and the chapters of Zeitgeisters (yes it has chapters, check youtube) who have been duped by the NWO's agenda which is to pit the populace against eachother so we may take our eye of the ball and spend time busy squabbling amongst eachother, and hate eachother which could also possibly give rise to war, death and destruction for the sinister population reduction scheme or any other conspiracy motive that may be out there.

and the blind is biting hard !

stop being puppets... Co-Existence is the key !

break free

edit on 2/9/2011 by Cosmic.Artifact because: (no reason given)

Pages: <<  1    2    3    4  >>    ^^TOP^^



How Are Plants Aware of the World Around Them?
  Posted 3 days ago with 5 member flags
The Genesis Code
  Posted 10 days ago with 4 member flags
Explain Diversity Reloaded
  Posted 11 days ago with 3 member flags
Tree of Life and Tree of Knowledge
  Posted 6 days ago with 3 member flags
The carrot (chicken or egg , vegetable version)
  Posted 5 days ago with 3 member flags
A theory of proof of a God
  Posted 12 days ago with 2 member flags
Eden: The Double Sided Coin
  Posted 5 days ago with 2 member flags
We are all connected with nature and The Universe IMO
  Posted 5 days ago with 2 member flags